| Home Page |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
|||
| GB
Male Suicidality at a Glance! Results of 30 studies in four tables. "Attempted Suicide" Results For Homosexually Oriented Males & Females: More Than 140 Studies! At Another Website (Includes Transgender Study Results) |
|||||
|
Male Suicide Problems (Part 6 of 6: YRBS Study Results) |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
| See: More Than 250 Full Text Papers and Documents Related to GLBT Suicidality. Two Studies Are Re-Analysed by Plöderl et al., (2013) In The Published Study: "Suicide Risk and Sexual Orientation: A Critical Review." Conclusion: Sexual Minority Adolescents Are At Greater Risk for Dying by Suicide. The Expanded Analysis Related to This Study is Available! |
Document Containing the Resources Available for GLBT Adolescent Suicide Prevention in Schools:
SAMHSA (2012). Preventing Suicide: A Toolkit for High Schools. PDF Download.
Special: Calculating the "Total Homosexuality Factor In Adolescent Suicidality" Using the Seattle 1995 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results - Males: "Attempted Suicide" [ > 34.3% of the Problem ] - Males "Attempted Suicide & Received Medical Attention" [ > 38.4% of the Problem ] - Females: "Attempted Suicide" [ > 38.8% of the Problem ] - Females "Attempted Suicide & Received Medical Attention" [ > 44.1% of the Problem ]. Important Note:
Not one Adolescent Survey has collected the data required to calculate
the total "Homosexuality Factor" in Adolescent Suicidality.
Is it Possible or Likely that "The Homosexuality Factor" is Associated
With Close to 50% of the More Serious Adolescent Suicidality?
In A Well-Designed Canadian Random Study of Young Adult males, Bagley and Tremblay (1997, Full Text)
Reported that 62.5% of the Serious Suicide Attempters Were homosexual/Bisexual-Identified
and/or Reported Having Same-Sex Sex in the Past Six Months.
Minnesota* 1987, Minnesota Student Survey 1992, 1998, 2004.
Massachusetts 1993, 1995, 1997, 1999, 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009.
Vermont 1995, 1997, 1999, 2001, 2005, 2007, 2009, 2011; Vermont: Franklin County 2005.
Massachusetts/Vermont 1995/1997: Re-Evaluation Study.
Wisconsin 1997, 1999, 2001, 2007, 2009, 2007 & 2009 Combined, 2007, 2009 & 2011, Combined.
Rhode Island 2007.
Oregon, 1997, 1999, 2007 Oregon Healthy Teens Survey, 2006-2007-2007 Oregon Healthy Teens Survey.
Connecticut** 1997.
San Francisco, 1997, 2009.
Boulder County, Colorado 2003. Boulder County Results in One Table: 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009, 2011.
Washington, DC 2007, 2009.
Seattle 1995 - General Results; 1995 Males & 1995 Female Results, Two Suicidality Variables, Includes suicidality Related to Anti-Gay/Lesbian Abuses Directed at Those Presumed to be Gay or Lesbian in All Sexual Orientation Categories; 1995 & 1999 Males & 1995 & 1999 Female Results, Two Suicidality Variables.
Chicago 2003, 2005, 2009 & 2011. - Illinois, Including Chicago 2009. Illinois 2011.
San Francisco, 1997, 2009.
New York City 2005.
British Columbia Adolescent Health Survey 1992, 1998, 2003.
Montreal 2004.
Important: Caveat for homosexuality related studies of adolescents.
*Study done using the Minnesota
Adolescent Health Survey Questionnaire amended to solicit "sexual orientation"
information.
**Voice of Connecticut Youth
Survey
In 2011, the CDC - via its MMWR publication -
reported the suicidality results for all the 2001 to 2009 Youth Risk
Behavior Surveys - each as a grouped data set from 2001 to 2009 - from both states and cities
- that had solicited sexual orientation information, such as identity
and/or the sex of one's sexual partner(s). The "In the Past Year" suicidality results are
re-tabulated here to show that sexual minority adolescents (males and females, combined) are, as a rule (generally), but with some exceptions, at increasing risk - relative to heterosexual adolescents - for
the more serious suicidal behaviors or outcomes. This fact would
strongly suggest that sexual minority adolescents are also more at risk
for suicide. The Suicidality Variables Data Tables are:
A. State Study Results Generated on the Basis of Sexual Identity: Delaware, Maine, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Vermont.
B. City Study Results Generated on the Basis of Sexual Identity: Boston, Chicago, New York, San Francisco.
C. State Study Results Generated on the Basis of the Sex of One's Sexual Partner(s): Connecticut, Maine, Delaware, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Vermont, Wisconsin.
D. City Study Results Generated on the Basis of the Sex of One's Sexual Partner(s): Boston, Chicago, Milwaukee, New York, San Diego.
High School Youth Risk Behavior Surveys
Calculating The Total "Homosexuality Factor" in
The Male "Attempted Suicide" Problem
Sexual
Orientation,
Ns, %
Gay/Bisexual
N = 126
Unsure
N = 215
Heterosexual
N = 3,344
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence
19.8% (25 / 126)
13.0% (28 / 215)
4.8% (160 / 3,344)
Targeted for
Anti-gay Abuses
n, %
Yes
36
28.6%
No
90
-
Yes
24
11.2%
No
191
-
Yes
125
3.7%
No
3,219
-
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence19.4%
7 / 36
20.0%
18 / 90
29.2%
7 / 24
11.0%
21 / 191
16.0%
20 / 125
4.3%
140 / 3219
Same-Sex Sex Reported
Information Not Solicited
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
Counts & Results Generated From The 1995 Seattle Youth Survey
Total Male Suicide Attempters: 213.
Counts Made Available by E. Saewyc, University of Minnesota in 2002.
1. Males Identifying as Gay or Bisexual (N = 126): 25 / 213 Attempters = 11.7% of the Problem
2. Males Unsure About Their Sexual Orientation (N = 215) = 28 / 213 Attempters = 13.1% of the Problem.
3. Heterosexual Identified Males Subjected to Anti-Gay/Bisexual Abuses (N = 125) = 20 / 213 Attempters = 9.4% of the Problem
Total: The above 466 Males (126 + 215 + 125) or
12.6% of Males (466 / 3,685) Account for 34.3% (73 / 213) of the Male
Suicide Attempters.
Missing: The Suicidality of Heterosexual Identified Males (In Bold & Red)
who Would Report Having Engaged in Same-Sex Sex... given that they
would know of the negative "gay" implications, and especially if others
knew about their same-sex sex experience(s).
High School Youth Risk Behavior Surveys
Calculating The Total "Homosexuality Factor" in
The Male "Attempted Suicide + Medical Care" Problem
Sexual
Orientation,
Ns, %
Gay/Bisexual
N = 126
Unsure
N = 216
Heterosexual
N = 3,319
Attempted Suicide /
Received Medical Care
% Incidence
11.1% (14 / 126)
2.8% (6 / 216)
1.6% (53 / 3,319)
Targeted for
Anti-gay Abuses
n, %
Yes
35
27.8%
No
91
-
Yes
24
11.1%
No
192
-
Yes
122
3.7%
No
3,197
-
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence11.4%
4 / 35
11.0%
10 / 91
4.2%
1 / 24
2.6%
5/ 192
6.6%
8 / 122
1.4%
45 / 3197
Same-Sex Sex Reported
Information Not Solicited
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
Counts & Results Generated From The 1995 Seattle Youth Survey
Total Male Suicide Attempters Who Received Medical Care: 73
Counts Made Available by E. Saewyc, University of Minnesota in 2002.
1. Males Identifying as Gay or Bisexual (N = 126): 14 / 73 Attempters + Medical Care = 19.2% of the Problem
2. Males Unsure About Their Sexual Orientation (N = 216) = 6 / 73 Attempters + Medical Care = 8.2% of the Problem.
3.
Heterosexual Identified Males Subjected to Anti-Gay/Bisexual Abuses (N
= 122) = 8 / 73 Attempters + Medical Care = 11.0% of the Problem
Total: The above 466 Males (126 + 216 + 122) or 12.7%
of Males (466 / 3,661) Account for 38.4% (28 / 73) of the Male Suicide
Attempters Who Received Medical Care.
Missing: The Suicidality of Heterosexual Identified Males (In Bold & Red)
who Would Report Having Engaged in Same-Sex Sex... given that they
would know of the negative "gay" implications, and especially if others
knew about their same-sex sex experience(s).
High School Youth Risk Behavior Surveys
Calculating The Total "Homosexuality Factor" in
The Female "Attempted Suicide" Problem
Sexual
Orientation,
Ns, %
Lesbian/Bisexual
N = 173
Unsure
N = 237
Heterosexual
N = 3,485
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence
21.3% (37 / 173)
8.9% (21 / 237)
7.3% (254 / 3,485)
Targeted for
Anti-gay Abuses
n, %
Yes
66
38.2%
No
107
-
Yes
30
12.7%
No
207
-
Yes
292
8.4%
No
3,193
-
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence24.2%
16 / 66
19.6%
21/ 107
33.3%
10 / 30
10.1%
21 / 207
22.6%
66 / 292
7.3%
232 / 3193
Same-Sex Sex Reported
Information Not Solicited
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
Counts & Results Generated From The 1995 Seattle Youth Survey
Total Female Suicide Attempters: 320
Counts Made Available by E. Saewyc, University of Minnesota in 2002.
1. Females Identifying as Lesbian or Bisexual (N = 173): 37 / 320 Attempters = 11.6% of the Problem
2. Females Unsure About Their Sexual Orientation (N = 237): = 31 / 320 Attempters = 9.7% of the Problem.
3.
Heterosexual Identified Females Subjected to Anti-Lesbian/Bisexual
Abuses (N = 292) = 66 / 320 Attempters = 20.6% of the Problem
Total: The above 702 Females (173 + 237 + 292) or 18.0%
of Females (702 / 3,895) Account for 38.8% (124 / 320) of the Feale Suicide
Attempters Who Received Madical Care.
Missing: The Suicidality of Heterosexual Identified Females (In Bold & Red)
who Would Report Having Engaged in Same-Sex Sex... given that they
would know of the negative "lesbian" implications, and especially if others
knew about their same-sex sex experience(s).
High School Youth Risk Behavior Surveys
Calculating The Total "Homosexuality Factor" in the
Female "Attempted Suicide + Medical Care" Problem
Sexual
Orientation,
Ns, %
Lesbian/Bisexual
N = 173
Unsure
N = 236
Heterosexual
N = 3,489
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence
6.9% (12 / 173)
4.2% (10 / 236)
2.6% (89 / 3,489)
Targeted for
Anti-Lesbian Abuses
n, %
Yes
67
38.7%
No
106
-
Yes
30
12.7%
No
206
-
Yes
293
8.4%
No
3,196
-
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence9.0%
6 / 67
4.7%
6 / 106
13.3%
4 / 30
2.9%
6 / 206
9.2%
27 / 293
1.9%
62 / 3196
Same-Sex Sex Reported
Information Not Solicited
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Yes
?
No
?
Attempted Suicide
% Incidence?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
Counts & Results Generated From The 1995 Seattle Youth Survey
Total Female Suicide Attempters Who Received Medical Care: 111
Counts Made Available by E. Saewyc, University of Minnesota in 2002.
The "Homosexuality Factor" in Adolescent Female Suicidality + Medical Care Would Include:
1. Females Identifying as Lesbian or Bisexual (N = 173): 12 / 111 Attempters + Medical Care = 10.8% of the Problem
2. Females Unsure About Their Sexual Orientation (N = 236): = 10 / 111 Attempters + Medical Care = 9.0% of the Problem.
3.
Heterosexual Identified Females Subjected to Anti-Lesbian/Bisexual
Abuses (N = 293) = 27 / 111 Attempters + Medical Care = 24.3% of the
Problem
Total: The above 702 Females (173 + 236 + 293) or 18.1%
of Females (702 / 3,898) Account for 44.1% (49 / 111) of the Female Suicide
Attempters Who Received Medical Care.
Missing: The Suicidality of Heterosexual Identified Females (In Bold & Red)
who Would Report Having Engaged in Same-Sex Sex... given that they
would know of the negative "lesbian" implications, and especially if others
knew about their same-sex sex experience(s).
| Minnesota Student Survey: 2004 - Homo-Sex & Hetero-Sex Active Males - By 'Race'/Ethnicity & Grade Level Attempted Suicide Incidence, Lifetime |
||||||
| Category |
Homo- Sex %F 1 |
Total |
Homo-Sex 2 (% in category) |
Attempted Suicide, Lifetime |
2 Hetero- Sex |
Attempted Suicide, Lifetime |
| All Sexually Active Males |
[4.1%] |
10,672 |
1,452 (13.6%) |
402 3 29.0% |
9,220 |
1,135 3 12.6% |
| Odds Ratio |
- |
- |
- |
Homo-Sex vs. Hetero-Sex Males OR: 2.49 (2.08, 2.98) 4 |
||
| 1135 / Grade 9 |
3.2% |
4,069 |
777 (19.1%) |
? |
3,292 |
? |
| Grade 12 |
4.0% |
6,603 |
675 (10.2%) |
? |
5,928 |
? |
| White |
3.5% [3.4%] |
17,364 |
970 (67.0%) |
? |
7,282 |
? |
| Black |
7.5% [7.9%] |
543 |
90 (16.6%) |
? |
453 | ? |
| Hispanic |
10.5% [9.9%] |
370 |
81 (21.9%) |
? |
289 | ? |
| Asian |
5.0% [4.6%] |
374 |
71 (19.0%) |
? |
303 | ? |
| Native American |
7.0% [6.9%] |
175 |
25 (14.3%) |
? |
150 | ? |
| Mixed / Others |
8.0% |
913 |
211 (23.1%) |
? |
702 | ? |
| Mixed: Native American |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
| Mixed: Non-Native |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
| Others: Not Mixed |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
| Original Family |
5,815 |
776 (13.3%) |
? |
5,039 |
? |
|
| Not Original Family |
4,857 |
676 (13.9%) |
? |
4,181 |
? |
|
|
||||||
Minnesota Department of Education (2004). 2004 Minnesota Student Survey Statewide Tables: Fall 2004. Internet: http://www.dhs.state.mn.us/main/groups/healthcare/documents/pub/dhs_id_049112.pdf .
Institute for Women’s Policy Research (IWPR, 2008). Status of Girls in Minnesota. Research and Writing by the Institute for Women’s Policy Research in Partnership with the Women’s Foundation of Minnesota. PDF Download.
Note: Download Page for Documents Produced from the Minnesota Student Survey. On this page, the following is stated: "The Minnesota Student Survey (MSS) provides students, parents and their communities a dynamic vehicle for on-going communication about issues vital to the health, safety and academic success of youth. Some survey results and additional reports are available below. Most documents are in PDF format." Maybe it should read as follows: 'The Minnesota Student Survey (MSS) provides students, parents and their communities a dynamic vehicle for on-going communication about issues vital to the health, safety and academic success of youth on the basis of sex and race/ethnicity, but not on the basis of same-sex sex behavior that would be a proxy for sexual orientation. Given that the great majority of youth are heterosexual, the results therefore best approximate the situation only for heterosexual students. Over the years, we have specialized in not including any "at risk" results on the basis of sexual orientation for reasons that we would rather not reveal. Some survey results and additional reports are available below. Most documents are in PDF format.'
| Minnesota Student Survey: 2004 - Homo-Sex & Hetero-Sex Active Females - By 'Race'/Ethnicity & Grade Level - Attempted Suicide Incidence, Lifetime | ||||||
| Category |
Homo- Sex %F 1 |
Total |
Homo-Sex 2 (% in category) |
Attempted Suicide, Lifetime |
2 Hetero- Sex |
Attempted Suicide, Lifetime |
| All Sexually Active Females |
1.9% [2.1%] |
11,255 |
803 (7.1%) |
409 3 52.4% |
10,452 |
2,559 3 24.8% |
| Odds Ratio |
- |
- |
- |
Homo-Sex vs. Hetero-Sex Females OR: 2.63 (2.15, 3.23) 4 |
||
| Grade 9 |
2.0% |
3,679 |
483 (13.1%) |
? |
3,196 |
? |
| Grade 12 |
1.9% |
7,576 |
320 (4.2%) |
? |
7,256 |
? |
| White |
2% [1.7%] |
9,112 |
539 (5.9%) |
? |
8,573 | ? |
| Black |
3.5% [3.7%] |
388 |
43 (11.1%) |
? |
345 |
? |
| Hispanic |
4.5% [4.2%] |
308 |
35 (11.4%) |
? |
273 | ? |
| Asian |
1.5% [1.8%] |
355 |
31 (8.7%) |
? |
324 | ? |
| Native American |
6.5% [6.6%] |
157 |
21 (13.4%) |
? |
136 | ? |
| Mixed / Others |
4.5% |
902 |
130 (14.4%) |
? |
772 | ? |
| Mixed: Native American |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
| Mixed: Non-Native |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
| Others: Not Mixed |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
? |
| Original Family |
6,017 |
336 (5.6%) |
? |
5,681 |
? |
|
| Not Original Family |
5,238 |
467 (8.9%) |
? |
4,771 |
? |
|
|
||||||
1998 Minnesota Student Survey, N = 22,029
Grade 9 & 12 Students Suicidality:
Same-Sex Sex Students vs. Opposite-Sex Sex Students
Categories
Males
Females
Same-Sex
Sex,
Only
Both-Sex
Sex
Opposite
Sex-Sex,
Only
Same-Sex
Sex,
Only
Both-Sex
Sex
Opposite
Sex-Sex,
Only
N's
Males & Females Reporting
Same-Sex Sex in Past Year = 9%
?
?
?
?
?
?
Depressed
Mood
%
%
%
%
%
%
Thought About
Killing Yourself?
39.8%
OR: 1.26
48.7%
OR: 1.7
(1.6−2.0)
34.5%
70.6%
OR: 1.96
72.5%
OR: 1.9
(1.5−2.4)
55.1%
Tried to Kill
Yourself?
19.9%
OR: 1.95
29.1%
OR: 3.0
(2.7−3.5)
11.3%
43.1%
OR:
47.1%
OR: 2.3
(1.9, 2.9)
24.9%
Data Source: Saewyc et al. (2007a): Includes all ORs with Confidence Intervals.
Other ORs Calculated by Webpage Author Using Given Incidence % & Using 2-way Contingency Table Analysis.
All ORs Relative to "Opposite-Sex Sex, Only" Category for Males & Females,
Some with unknown Confidence Intervals likely being not Statistically Significant.
1992 Minnesota Student Survey, N = 24,978
Grade 9 & 12 Students Suicidality:
Same-Sex Sex Students vs. Opposite-Sex Sex Students
Categories
Males
Females
Same-Sex
Sex,
Only
Both-Sex
Sex
Opposite
Sex-Sex,
Only
Same-Sex
Sex,
Only
Both-Sex
Sex
Opposite
Sex-Sex,
Only
N's
Males & Females Reporting
Same-Sex Sex in Past Year = 7%
?
?
?
?
?
?
Depressed
Mood
%
%
%
%
%
%
Thought About
Killing Yourself?
37.4%
OR: 1.96
39.2%
OR: 2.0
(1.8, 2.3)
23.4%
43.5%
OR: 1.42
46.9%
OR: 1.4
(1.1, 1.8)
35.1%
Tried to Kill
Yourself?
21.4%
OR: 1.79
26.4%
OR: 2.3
(2.0, 2.6)
13.2%
17.8%
OR: 0.52
38.5%
OR: 1.3
(1.0, 1.7)
29.3%
Data Source: Saewyc et al. (2007a): Includes all ORs with Confidence Intervals.
Other ORs Calculated by Webpage Author Using Given Incidence % & Using 2-way Contingency Table Analysis.
All ORs Relative to "Opposite-Sex Sex, Only" Category for Males & Females,
Some with unknown Confidence Intervals likely being not Statistically Significant.
Research Highlights: - A 1987 sample of 36,254 grades 7 to 12 Minnesota students from whom sexual orientation and suicidality information was solicited. This was a part of the Adolescent Youth Risk Behavior Survey which was amended given that the standard (CDC-approved) questionnaire does not solicit sexual orientation information. Self-identified gay/bisexual male adolescents (about 1% of males) were deemed to be at significantly greater risk (by a 7-times factor) for a suicide attempt compared to heterosexual male adolescent. Their respective lifetime attempted suicide rates are 28.1% versus 4.2%.
Comment: This study demonstrating that gay/bisexual male adolescents are at higher risk for suicide attempts than their heterosexual counterparts is, however, only a part of the "at risk" picture for these boys. A 1996 study of the same sample reported that "homosexual males were more likely to report a poor body image (27.8% vs. 12.0%, frequent dieting (8.9% vs. 5.5%), binge eating (25.0% vs. 10.6%), or purging behaviors (e.g., vomiting: 11.7% vs. 4.4%) compared with heterosexual males." (French SA, Story M, Remafedi G, Resnick MD, and Blum RW, 1996. Sexual orientation and prevalence of body dissatisfaction and eating disordered behaviors: a population-based study of adolescents. International Journal of Eating disorders, 19(2), 119-26. PubMed abstract. Full Text.
Saewyc EM, Bearinger LH, Heinz PA, Blum RW, Resnick MD (1998). Gender differences in health and risk behaviors among bisexual and homosexual adolescents. Journal of Adolescent Health, 23(3), 181-8. (PubMed abstract. PDF)
Research Highlights. Further analysis of the 1987 Minnesota Adolescent Health Survey sample first reported on by Remafedi et al. (1998). Suicide attempt rates for homosexual/bisexual males and females were 28.1% and 20.5%, respectively, versus 4.2% and 14.5% for their heterosexual counterparts. The authors of this study, however, note that "nearly 1 of 3 older boys and girls reported at least one suicide attempt." No explanation is given for this but the implications would be that, by the age of 15 to 18 (for this sample ranging in age from about 12 to 18), about one-third of homosexual / bisexual adolescents have attempted suicide - the female attempted suicide rate having become insignificantly different from the male rate. Two explanations are possible. With age, the lifetime "attempted suicide" tally increases, more for females. And/or: with age, more individuals (especially females) are self-identify as gay, lesbian, or bisexual, thus increasing the tally of lifetime suicide attempters in this category - who may have been listed in the "heterosexual-identified" category if they had been studied at an earlier age. Younger students, even after having attempted suicide for reasons related to sexual orientation, may not be ready to reveal the "homosexuality" aspect of themselves to anyone (possibly because they were rejecting or denying this aspect of self to themselves)- and they would therefore also not report this aspect of self on a pencil-and-paper questionnaire.
Remafedi G,
Resnick M, Blum R, Harris L (1992)
Demography of sexual orientation
in adolescents. Pediatrics. 89(4-2), 714-21. (PubMed abstract. PDF)
Youth
Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (2009)
Summary Available at: - http://www.mass.gov/cgly/YRBS09Factsheet.pdf. Download Page.
Sample Size: 2,707 students, 59 randomly selected public high schools.
| Massachusetts 2009 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 Sexual Orientation Related Results |
|||
| Categories | GLB Students |
Other Students | Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Attempted suicide in the past year |
24.7% | 5.6% | RR: 4.4 OR: 5.5 |
| Received medical attention as a result of a suicide attempt |
8.8% |
2.2% | RR: 3.8 OR: 4.1 |
| Skipped school in the past month because of feeling unsafe on route to or at school |
13.9% |
3.4% | RR: 4.1 OR: 4.6 |
| Was threatened/injured with a weapon at school in the past year |
17.3% |
6.4% | RR: 2.7 OR: 3.1 |
| Was In a physical fight resulting in treatment by doctor or nurse |
9.0% |
3.0% | RR: 3.0 RR: 3.2 |
| Has been pregnant or gotten someone pregnant |
10.5% |
5.2% |
RR: 2.0 RR: 2.1 |
|
|||
Massachusetts 2009 YRBS Results: GLB vs. Others: Attempted Suicide (24.7% vs. 5.6%), Attempted, Received Medical Attention (8.8% vs. 2.2%).
Youth
Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (2007)
Summary Available at: - http://www.mass.gov/cgly/yrbs07.pdf (Download Page) & http://akconsultingservices.com/akjoomla/index.php/services/statistics/2007-youth-survey.html.
Sample Size: 3,131 students, 59 randomly selected public high schools.
| Massachusetts 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 Sexual Orientation Related Results |
|||
| Categories | GLB Students |
Other Students | Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Attempted suicide in the past year |
29.1% | 6.4% | RR: 4.5 OR: 6.0 |
| Received medical attention as a result of a suicide attempt |
12.1% |
2.2% | RR: 5.5 OR: 6.1 |
| Skipped school in the past month because of feeling unsafe on route to or at school |
13.3% |
4.2% | RR: 3.2 OR: 3.5 |
| Was threatened/injured with a weapon at school in the past year |
18.7% |
4.5% | RR: 4.2 OR: 4.9 |
| Was In a physical fight resulting in treatment by doctor or nurse |
12.7% |
3.7% | RR: 3.4 RR: 3.8 |
|
|||
Massachusetts 2007 YRBS Results:
"29.1 percent attempted suicide and 12.1 percent attempted suicide that
required medical attention. That compares to 6.4 percent and 2.2
percent respectively in those same categories for their straight
counterparts. - Massachusetts High School Students and Sexual Orientation, Results of the 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: GLB vs. Others: Attempted Suicide (29.1% vs. 6.4%), Attempted, Received Medical Attention (12.1% vs. 2.2%).
Youth
Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (2005)
Summary Available at: - http://www.mass.gov/cgly/yrbs05.pdf. Download Page.
3.7 percent of students surveyed described themselves as gay, lesbian or bisexual.
6.4 percent of all students described themselves as gay, lesbian or bisexual and/or reported same-sex sexual contact.
Students who described themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual were
significantly more likely than their peers to report attacks, suicide
attempts and drug and alcohol use. When compared to peers, this group
was:
over four times more likely to have attempted suicide in the past year.
over four times more likely to miss school in the past month because of feeling unsafe.
almost twice more likely to have been injured or threatened with a weapon at school..
| Massachusetts 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 Sexual Orientation Related Results |
|||
| Categories | GLB Students |
Other Students | Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Attempted suicide in the past year |
24.8% | 5.7% | RR: 4.4 OR: 5.5 |
| Received medical attention as a result of a suicide attempt |
8.2% |
2.2% | RR: 3.7 OR: 4.0 |
| Skipped school in the past month because of feeling unsafe on route to or at school |
16.3% |
3.5% | RR: 4.7 OR: 5.4 |
| Was threatened/injured with a weapon at school in the past year |
10.2% |
5.2% | RR: 2.0 OR: 2.1 |
| Was In a physical fight resulting in treatment by doctor or nurse |
11.7% |
3.7% | RR: 3.2 RR: 3.4 |
|
|||
Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (2003)
Summary Available at: - http://www.mass.gov/gcgly/yrbs03.pdf .
3.5 percent of students surveyed described themselves as gay, lesbian or bisexual.
6.0 percent of all students described themselves as gay, lesbian or bisexual and/or reported same-sex sexual contact.
Students who described themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual were
significantly more likely than their peers to report attacks, suicide
attempts and drug and alcohol use. When compared to peers, this group
was:
over five times more likely to have attempted suicide in the past year.
over three times more likely to miss school in the past month because of feeling unsafe.
over three times more likely to have been injured or threatened with a weapon at school..
| Massachusetts 2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 Sexual Orientation Related Results |
|||
| Categories |
GLB Students |
Other Students | Risk Ratio Odds ratio |
| Attempted suicide in the past year |
40.4% | 7.2% | RR: 5.6 OR: 8.7 |
| Received medical attention as a result of a suicide attempt |
18.3% |
2.2% | RR: 8.3 OR: 10.0 |
| Skipped school in the past month because of feeling unsafe on route to or at school |
16.3% |
4.2% | RR: 3.9 OR: 4.4 |
| Was threatened/injured with a weapon at school in the past year |
19.2% |
5.8% | RR: 3.3 OR: 3.9 |
| Was In a physical fight resulting in treatment by doctor or nurse |
13.3% |
3.4% | RR: 3.9 OR: 4.4 |
All differences between GLB students and Others are statistically significant, p < 0.05
RRs & ORs: Calculated by Webpage Author Using Given Data: 2-way Contingency Table Analysis. GLB versus Others.
Massachusetts' YRBS Report: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/03/results.pdf . Excerpts:
Sexual minority youth (i.e., students who either identified as gay,
lesbian, or bisexual or had any same-sex sexual contact) were more
likely than other students to be current smokers (48% vs. 19%) and
daily smokers (23% vs. 6%).
Sexual
minority youth were significantly more likely than other students to
report current alcohol use (60% vs. 45%) and binge drinking (44% vs.
26%).
Sexual
minority youth were significantly more likely than other students to
report lifetime drug use (73% vs. 46%) and current drug use (49% vs.
29%).
Certain
groups of students reported higher rates than their peers of
violence-related behaviors. These groups included male students,
students in younger grades, Black students, students of Other or
Multiple Ethnicity, students in urban districts, recent immigrants,
sexual minority students, and students with disabilities.
Sexual
minority youth (i.e., students who either identified as gay, lesbian,
or bisexual or reported any same-sex sexual contact) were significantly
more likely than other students to have carried a weapon (24% vs. 13%),
been in a physical fight (44% vs. 30%), and to have been in a gang (23%
vs. 9%). They were also significantly more likely to have skipped
school because they felt unsafe (15% vs. 4%), been bullied (42% vs.
21%), been threatened or injured with a weapon at school (22% vs. 5%),
and to have experienced dating violence (30% vs. 9%) or sexual contact
against their will (41% vs. 8%).
Students in
urban districts, recent immigrants, students with disabilities, sexual
minority youth, and students who have experienced violence were more
likely than their peers to report a suicide attempt.
Certain
groups of students were significantly more likely than their peers to
report a suicide attempt:... Sexual minority youth (32% vs. 7% of other
students), Students who were bullied at school (15% vs. 6% of students
who were not bullied), Students who skipped school because they felt
unsafe (33% vs. 7% of students who did not skip school for safety
concerns), and Students who had experienced dating violence or sexual
contact against their will (27% vs. 5% of students who did not
experience dating violence or sexual contact against their will).
Adolescents
who have experienced school victimization, dating violence, sexual
contact against their will are especially vulnerable to suicidality, as
are gay, lesbian, and bisexual adolescents, students in urban areas,
and recent immigrants.
Sexual
minority youth were significantly more likely than other students to
report never or rarely wearing a seat belt (29% vs. 15%), riding with a
drunk driver (45% vs. 26%), and driving after drinking (24% vs. 11%).
Sexual minority youth and students in urban communities had higher rates than their peers of most sexual risk behaviors.
Four percent
(4%) of all students described themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual
and 5% had same-sex sexual contact98 in their lifetimes. In all, 6% of
students could be considered sexual minority youth; that is they either
identified as gay, lesbian, or bisexual or had any same-sex sexual
contact in their lifetimes.
Sexual minority youth were significantly more likely than other
students to report lifetime sexual intercourse (77% vs. 39%), sexual
intercourse before age 13 (21% vs. 4%), sexual intercourse with four or
more partners in their lifetimes (32% vs. 9%), and recent sexual
intercourse (54% vs. 29%). Among students who ever had sexual
intercourse in their lifetimes, sexual minority youth were
significantly more likely than other students to report having ever
been or gotten someone pregnant (17% vs. 9%) and having been
diagnosed with HIV or another STD (16% vs. 7%).
Sexual
minority youth were significantly less likely than other students to
have been taught about AIDS or HIV infection in school (85% vs. 92%)..
Recent immigrants, sexual minority students and students in urban
districts were significantly less likely to have received AIDS or HIV
education in school.. Similarly, sexual minority youth have
significantly higher rates than their peers of sexual risk behaviors
and may be at particularly high risk of STDs and HIV infection.
Sexual
minority youth (i.e., students who either identified as gay, lesbian,
or bisexual, or had any same-sex sexual contact) were significantly
less likely than other students to report having breakfast every day
(22% vs. 33%), participating in regular vigorous physical activity (44%
vs. 62%), playing on a sports team (40% vs. 55%), and were
significantly more likely to be at risk of becoming overweight (22% vs.
13%) and to have used an unhealthy weight control method (38% vs. 16%).
Patterns of
risk are different for different students. Certain groups of students
appear to be at greater risk for health and academic problems because
of higher rates of risk behaviors. Gender, race/ethnicity, grade level,
sexual orientation, kind of community, and many other factors were all
related to variations in risk behavior. Although all students need the
knowledge, encouragement, and skills to develop healthy lifestyles, it
may also be appropriate to develop “targeted” programs aimed
specifically at the risks faced by certain segments of the adolescent
population.
Youth
Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (2001)
Data at Source: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrbs/01/results.pdf N/A
(PDF Download). New URL: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/01/results.pdf .
|
Problem |
Students 5.0% N = 210 |
Students 95.0% N = 3984 |
Likelihood For Problem |
95% Confidence Intervals |
Percentage of Problem |
|
Suicide |
n = 99 |
n = 757 |
Times |
|
(99/756) |
|
Suicide |
n = 78 |
n = 558 |
Times |
|
(78/636) |
|
Suicide |
n = 65 |
n = 319 |
Times |
|
(65/384) |
|
Receiving Medical Attention |
n = 34 |
n = 120 |
Times |
|
(34/154) |
Sexual
Minority Youth vs. Others: Intercourse, life (73% vs. 43%) - Intercourse,
recent (52% vs. 32%) - Pregnancy Involment (27% vs. 11%) - >= 4 Sex Partners,
life (36% vs. 11%) - HIV, STD Testing (42% vs. 24%).
The
Safe Schools Program for Gay & Lesbian Students: Program
& Resources.
Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (1999)
"Sexual minority adolescents (those who identified themselves as gay, lesbian, bisexual and/or reported any same-sex sexual contact) comprised 5.5% of students participating in the survey." Citation From: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrbs99/chapter6.html. N/A New URL: http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/99yrbs6.pdf - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/chapter6.html - Download Page: http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/default.html .
A total of 4,415 students participated in the study. Therefore, there are about 243 "sexual minority youth" and 4,172 students defined as "other students." These figures are used for calculation in data tables below. The actual numbers may be slightly different.
"Sexual minority youth (i.e, adolescents
who either identified themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual and/or those
who had any same-sex sexual experience [5.5% of students]) reported higher
rates than their peers of considering suicide (49% vs. 20%), making a suicide
plan (39% vs. 15%), actually attempting suicide (29% vs. 7%), and of requiring
medical attention for a suicide attempt (18% vs. 3%). Differences were
statistically significant both for self-identified sexual orientation and
for same-sex behavior."
|
Problem |
Students 5.5% N = 243 |
Students 94.5% N = 4172 |
Likelihood For Problem |
95% Confidence Intervals |
Percentage of Problem |
|
Suicide |
n = 119 |
n = 834 |
Times |
|
(119/953) |
|
Suicide |
n = 95 |
n = 626 |
Times |
|
(95/721) |
|
Suicide |
n = 71 |
n = 292 |
Times |
|
(71/363) |
|
Receiving Medical Attention |
n = 44 |
n = 125 |
Times |
|
(44/169) |
NOTE: One out of five male and female adolescent suicide attempters and one of four male and female adolescent suicide attempters who received medical attention is a sexual minority youth. On the basis of the Garofalo et al. (1999) study, it is likely that the proportion will be significantly higher for sexual sexual minority male youth, and lower for sexual minority female youth when compared to their same-gender counterparts.
Data / Citation Source: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrbs99/chapter8.html N/A. New URL: http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/99yrbs8.pdf - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/chapter8.html - Download Page: http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/default.html .
"Sexual minority youth (those who
identified themselves as gay/lesbian/or bisexual and/or who had any same-sex
sexual contact) had higher rates of drug use than their peers, including
higher lifetime rates of using marijuana (70% vs. 49%), cocaine (29% vs.
9%), methamphetamines (30% vs. 7%), and injected drugs (18% vs. 2%)."
|
|
Students 5.5% |
Students 94.5% |
Likelihood |
|
|
|
|
Times |
|
|
|
|
Times |
|
amphetamines |
|
|
Times |
|
Drugs |
|
|
Times |
NOTE: One out of 3 students reporting having injected illicit drugs is a sexual minority youth. The 18% of sexual minority youth reporting injecting illicit drugs (n = 44) and the 2% of other students having done the same (n = 83) produces a total of 127 adolescents reporting such activities. Therefore, 34.6% of students (44/126 = 34.6%) reporting injecting illicit drugs are sexual minority youth who form 5.5% of the student population.
Data / Citation Source: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrbs99/chapter4.html. N/A New URL: http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/99yrbs4.pdf - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/chapter4.html - Download Page: http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/default.html .
"Sexual minority adolescents (that is, those who identified themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual and/or had a history of same-sex sexual contact) reported substantially higher rates of school-related violence than their peers, regardless of whether comparisons were made on the basis of self-identified sexual orientation, same-sex behavior, or both."
|
|
Students 5.5% |
Students 94.5% |
Likelihood |
|
at School - Past Year |
|
|
Times |
|
at School - Past Month |
|
|
Times |
|
Injured at School Past year |
|
|
Times |
|
School: Fear Past Month |
|
|
Times |
"Among male students, those who identified themselves as gay or bisexual and/or who had any same-sex sexual experience were more likely than their male peers to consider themselves overweight (41% vs. 22%). They had significantly higher rates than other male students of trying to control their weight by fasting (21% vs. 6%), taking diet pills (19% vs. 4%), and vomiting or taking laxatives (22% vs. 4%). On the other hand, they were similar to other males in terms of actual Body Mass Index."
Citation Source: - - http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrbs99/chapter10.html N/A.
New URL: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/99yrbs10.pdf - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/chapter10.html . - Download Page: http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/99/default.html .
Four percent (4.2%) of all students reported having same-sex sexual experience at some time; percentages of youth with same-sex sexual experience were the same for males and females. Most adolescents (52%) who have had same-sex sexual experience identify themselves as heterosexual; an additional 12% of these youth identify themselves as "not sure" of their sexual orientation.
In all, 5.5% of all students and 9.4% of sexually experienced students could be considered "sexual minority" youth; that is, they have had same-sex sexual contact and/or describe themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual.
Among adolescents with any history of sexual activity, sexual minority youth were more likely than their peers to report other sexual risks, including:
The MYRBS found that:
Students who described themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual were significantly more likely than their peers to report attacks, suicide attempts and drug and alcohol use. When compared to peers, this group was:
| Reported Behaviors | GLB Students* | Other Students |
|---|---|---|
| Attempted suicide in the past year | 32.8 % | 7.6% |
| Required medical attention as a result of a suicide attempt | 18.5% | 3.7% |
| Skipped school in the past month because of feeling unsafe on route to or at school | 20.0% | 6.0% |
| Was threatened/injured with a weapon at school in the past year | 24.4% | 8.2% |
| Was In a physical fight resulting in treatment by doctor or nurse | 20.3% | 4.2% |
Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (1997)
Demographic Results: "Two percent (2.0%) of students (1.6% of males, 2.4% of females) describe themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual. One fourth (26%) of these students have had no sexual experience in their lives. - Three percent (3.0%) of all students (3.5% of males, 2.4% of females) have at some time had same-sex sexual experience. About one percent (0.9%) of students both identify as gay, lesbian, or bisexual and have had same-sex sexual experience. - In all, 4.0% of all students, and 6.1% of sexually active students have had some same-sex sexual contact and/or describe themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual."
Considering only adolescents with any history of sexual activity, those who described themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual and/or who had ever had any same-sex sexual partner were more likely than other sexually experienced students to report other sexual risk behaviors, including:
Suicidality Results: Adolescents who identified themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual and/or those who had any same-sex sexual experience reported significantly higher rates than their peers of considering suicide in the past year (54% vs. 22%), making a suicide plan (41% vs. 18%), actually attempting suicide (37% vs. 8%), and of requiring medical attention for a suicide attempt (19% vs. 3%). Citation Source: http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrbs97/97yrbstoc.html#TOC N/A . New URL: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/97/ .having had four or more sexual partners during lifetime (44% vs. 24%), having experienced sexual contact against their will (56% vs. 18%), having used alcohol or drugs prior to last sexual intercourse (36% vs. 23%), and having ever been or gotten someone pregnant (24% vs. 12%) 53
Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Massachusetts (1995)
Garofalo R, Wolf RC, R, Lawrence MS, and Wissow S (1999). Sexual orientation and risk of suicide attempts among a representative sample of youth. Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine, 153(5), 487-93. Abstract from APAM web site. Related Reuters' article (May, 1999): Gay, lesbian adolescents face high suicide risk. (Alternate Link)
Research Highlights:
The study is an analysis of 3.8% of public school students reporting being GLBN (gay, lesbian, bisexual, or "not sure" of their sexual orientation), and 96.2% reporting being heterosexual, their average age being 16.1 years. Latter group includes individuals reporting same-sex activity, but not identifying as GLBN, or 0.81% of the sample. The 1.9% percent of the sample reporting same-sex activity had a suicide attempt rate (for the past 12 months) of 30.6% versus 9.2% for their heterosexual counterpart. The suicide attempt rate for adolescents identified as GLBN was 31.0% versus 9.1% for heterosexual identified adolescents, .22.7% versus 9.1% for adolescents "not sure" of sexual orientation, and 35.3% versus 9.1% for GLB adolescents (not including "not sure" adolescents). GLBN adolescents also at significantly greater risk than heterosexual adolescents for receiving a high score on the three "risk behaviors" scales used for analysis (p < .001): (1) drug use, (2) sexual behavior, and (3) violence / victimization. Given that 18.3% of adolescents did not answer either the sexual orientation question (11%) or the suicide attempt question (10%), the analysis applies only to 81.7% of the total sample: N = 3365 out of 4167 students.
Result of bivariate analysis: GLBN adolescents were 3.4 times more likely (p < .001) than heterosexual adolescents to report a suicide attempt in the past 12 months (31.0% versus 9.1%). For females, reporting a suicide attempt was 2.02 times more likely (p < .006) for LBN adolescents. For males, reporting a suicide attempt was 6.5 times more likely (p < .001) for GBN adolescents.
Result of logistic regression - OR (Odds Ratio) - for cited factor predicting a suicide attempt in the past 12 months:
Males and Females: female (4.43), GLBN (2.28), Hispanic/Latino (2.21), Violence/Victimization (2.06).
Females Only: Hispanic/Latino (2.66), Violence/Victimization (2.35), LBN (1.42); LBN orientation not statistically significant predictor of suicide attempt.
Males Only: GBN (3.74), Hispanic/Latino (1.66), Violence/Victimization (2.35); GLBN orientation statistically significant predictor of suicide attempt.
Comments: Being "female" is the best predictor of a suicide attempt but, in itself, this factor explains absolutely nothing about why females are at greater risk for attempting suicide. The same applies for being Latino/Hispanic, GLBN, and GBN (in male category). Although the authors stated that GBN males were 6.5 times more likely than heterosexual males to report a suicide attempt, it was maybe thought unimportant to report the percentage of suicide attempters in each category, but males had a suicide attempt rate of 6.4%. Using an estimate of about 4.7% for GBN males (3.8% GB males + .0.9% "not sure") in calculations, the relative rate of suicide attempters would be 33% versus 5.1% for GBN males compared to heterosexual males, with another estimate also made possible. About one quarter - 24.3% - of male suicide attempters are in the GBN category. Stated otherwise, 4.7% of the students in the GBN category account for about 25% of the male suicide attempt problem.
Missing form this calculation, however, are the male reporting same-gender sexual activity but not identifying as GBN. It is reported that 1.8% of students were in this category and that 55% of them identified as GLBN, while 45% (0.81% of students) identified as heterosexual. This group as a whole, however, has a suicide attempt rate of 30.6%, meaning that maybe the "0.81%" (percentage not given for males only) should have not been placed in the "heterosexual" category - even if they identified as such - given that many in this group are on the path to later GLB identification - as is often reported to have been the case for many GLB adults when reporting on their adolescent years and their often serious problems related to identifying as GLB in spite of most obvious - and acted upon - homosexual desires. Given that this "at risk" group should have been included to the above calculation, the results may have been that GBN males, including the homosexually active ones self-identifying as heterosexual (for a total of about 5.5% of male subjects), would likely account for more that a quarter (+25%) of the male adolescent suicide attempt problem.
Caveats noted in the study
- and especially the ones noted in the Caveat Alert,
indicate that the "24.3%" would be an absolute minimum, as would be the
"6.5-times" greater risk factor for a suicide attempt by GBN males. In
fact, the results of the
Turner et al. (1998)
study of males aged 16-19 years indicate that, at least with respect to
"homo-sex" activity, about 80% of adolescent homo-active males will omit
this information on pencil-and-paper questionnaires - the data intake method
used in YRBS studies - compared to computer-based data intake methods.
A version of the latter was used in the Bagley
& Tremblay (1997) study of 750 randomly sampled males ranging
in age from 18 to 27 years. The results produced an estimate for lifetime
"suicide attempts" to the average age of about 22.5 years, About 11% of
homosexually oriented males (defined on the basis of homosexual or bisexual
self-identification and/or "being currently homosexual active" (but may
not identify as homosexual or bisexual) accounted for 62.5% of the male
youth attempted suicide problem. These males were also 14-times more likely
than other males to report a suicide attempt.
Garofalo R, Wolf RC, Kessel S, Palfrey J, and DuRant RH (1998). The association between health risk behaviors and sexual orientation among a school-based sample of adolescents. Pediatrics, 101(5), 895-902. (Pediatrics Web site "abstract" link. Related press release by the American Academy of Pediatrics. Note disclaimer at bottom of press release. For AAP Policy Statement in the form of the 1993 article Homosexuality and Adolescence published in Pediatrics. . Press Release: Boston Children's Hospital. - Related "Reuters" article, Chicago, May 4, 1998). - Washington Blade Article. - (A PubMed "abstract" link with article delivery service. If link is not working, access abstract via PubMed's Medline. Place this "unique identifier number" - 98232540 - in SEARCH window.)
Research Highlights: - A random sample of 4159 grade 9 to 12 Massachusetts students completed the Youth Risk Behavior Survey in 1995. The survey instrument, however, was amended to solicit sexual orientation information, thus making possible "risk behavior" comparisons on this basis.
Compared to heterosexual-identified adolescents, homosexually-identified adolescents (gay, bisexual, and lesbian, forming 2.5% of the student population) were:
3.6
times more likely to attempt suicide in the past 12 months (35.5% vs 9.9%)
14.4
times more likely to have used cocaine before the age of 13 (17.3% vs 1.2%)
9.4
times more likely to have used cocaine in last 30 days (25.3% vs 2.7%)
4.8
times more likely to have used cocaine in lifetime (33% vs 6.9%)
8.9
times more likely to have used crack or freebase use in lifetime (35.3%
vs 3.5%)
14.1
times more likely to have shared needles for illicit drug use in lifetime
(15.5% vs 1.1%)
6.4
times more likely to have used anabolic steroids in lifetime (25% vs 3.9%)
9.6
times more likely to have injected illegal drugs in lifetime (22.2% vs
2.3%)
2.6
times more likely to have been in a fight at school in the past 12 months
(38.1% vs 14.4%)
3.4
times more likely that a fighting injury required medical treatment in
the past 12 months (14% vs 4.1%)
4.9
times more likely to have missed school in the last 30 days because of
fear (25.1% vs 5.1%)
2.8
times more likely to have brought a weapon to school in the last 30 days
(25.3% vs 8.9%)
5
times more likely to have brought a gun to school in the last 30 days (24.7%
vs 4.9%)
4.6
times more likely to have been threatened with a weapon at school in the
last 30 days (32.7% vs 7.1%)
5.1
times more likely to have had more than 3 sexual partners in last 3 months
(37.9% vs 5.1%)
3.6
times more likely to have experienced sex against their will in lifetime
(32.5% vs 9.1%)
![]()
All
the above and a number of other risk behaviors (with lesser magnitude of
relative risk) were significantly different at the p < .00001 level.
![]()
Additional
research results are available via "abstract" links listed above.
Information Sources: http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrb95/yrb95ltr.html N/A
. New URL: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/95/ .
.- Table
of Contents - Summary of Results by SIECUS
in SHOP Talk (School Health Opportunities and Progress) Bulletin, Vol.
3(5), 1998: - Health
Risk Behaviors and Sexual Orientation Among Adolescents.- The
GLBT Health Access Project [A collaborative project initiated in
1996 by the Massachusetts Department of Public Health (MDPH), and its founding
partners Justice Resource Institute (JRI), The Medical Foundation (TMF),
and JSI Research and Training (JSI)]: GLBT
Health Concerns in Massachusetts: Highlights of Recent Research.
Suicide Information Summary available from the Massachusetts' Department of Education - 1995 Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Survey at - http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrb95/yrb95ltr.html N/A - New URL: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/95/ , and from data made available in Sexual Orientation and Youth Suicide by Lynne Levine & Linda Beeler. Paper presented at Defining the Problem and Meeting The Challenge: Third Bi-Regional Adolescent Suicide Prevention Conference held in Breckenridge, Colorado, September, 1997.
From: the "Sexual Behaviors" section of the file - http://www.doe.mass.edu/hssss/yrb95/yrb95111.html#c6 N/A. - New URL: - http://www.doe.mass.edu/cnp/hprograms/yrbs/95/yrb95111.html#c6 .
Students
who describe themselves as gay, lesbian, or bisexual and/or who have had
same-sex sexual contact are more likely than their peers to report being
involved in violence-related incidences and being threatened, including:
4.4%
of high school students (grades 9-12) identified as gay, lesbian. or bisexual,
and/or reported same-gender sexual activity.
These 'GLB' adolescents were..... (compared to other adolescents):
1.9
times more likely to have considered suicide in the past year (48.8% vs
24.6%).
2.3
times more likely to have planned a suicide in the past year (40.5% vs
17.5%).
4.0
times more likely to have attempted suicide in the past year (36.0% vs
8.9%).
Comment: - Given that 4.4% of students either self-identified or reported same-gender sexual activity, and that 2.5% are said to self-identify (Garofalo et al., 1998), 1.9% of students would therefore be homosexually active but not-self-identifying as gay, lesbian. or bisexual. According to Garofalo et al. (1998), the risk of GLB adolescents for attempting suicide in the past year was 35.5% compared to 9.9% for heterosexual-identified adolescents. Adding the "1.9%" homosexually active but non-GLB-identifying student to the "2.5%" self-identifying group (for a total of 4.4%) did not cause a significant difference in "suicide attempt" results: In fact, above, Garofalo et al (1999), reports that the 1.8% of adolescents reporting homosexual activity had a suicide attempt rate of 30.6%.
Of the "4.4%" of homosexually oriented students (based either on self-identification or being homosexually active), 36% reported a suicide attempted in the past year compared to 8.9% for "non-GLB" students according to Levine & Beeler (1997). or "their peers" according to Massachusetts' 1995 YRBS's "Sexual Behavior" section.If the results represented all student - 4.4% homosexually oriented and 95.6% "their peers" (meaning heterosexual-identified adolescents and the ones in the "not sure" category, GLB adolescents would therefore account for 15.6% of suicide attempters.
Highlights: - From a 1993 sample of 3054 grades 9 to 12 students in Massachusetts: 1668 (57%) report having been sexually active with opposite sex only (heterosexual intercourse, 48.7%), both sexes (bisexual, 1.7%), and same-sex only (homosexual, 2.0%), for a total of 3.7% of students being homosexually active by the average age of 16 years. Homosexually active students were "more likely to report fighting and victimization, frequent use of alcohol, other drug use, and recent suicidal behaviors."
Compared to heterosexually active adolescents, homosexually active adolescents were:
1.5-times
more likely to have considered suicide (41.7% vs 28.6%).
2.1-times
,more likely to have attempted suicide once (27.5% vs 13.4%).
4.2-times
more likely to have made a suicide attempt requiring medical attention
(20.0% vs
4.7%).
8.1-times
more likely to have attempted suicide 4 or more times (16.1% vs 2.0%).
![]()
All
the above are statistically significant at p < .05
Homosexually active adolescents were also more at risk for manifesting behaviors, and/or having experiences which may be associated with adolescent (even adult) suicide problems.
Compared to heterosexually active adolescents, homosexually active adolescents were:
4.0-times
more likely to be involved in episodic heavy drinking (15.0%% vs. 3.8%).
8.7-times
more likely to currently be consuming alcohol every day (10.9% vs 1.2%).
6.0-times
more likely to to have used cocaine at least once (19.2% vs 3.2%).
19.0-times
more likely to have used cocaine 10 or more times (13.3 vs .7%).
5.1-times
more likely to have used illegal drugs other than alcohol, marijuana, or
cocaine (17.8% vs 3.5%).
6.7-times
more likely to have injected illegal drug (20.8% vs 3.1%).
![]()
All
the above are statistically significant at p < .05
Montreal 2004 Youth Risk Behavior Survey
Suicidality Results: Non-Heterosexual Groups vs. Heterosexual
Category
All Hetero-
sexual
No Homo 1
GLB
Identified
Unsure
Identity
Hetero-
sexual
Some Homo 2
p
N, %
1,856
100%
1,624
87.5%
58
3.1%
59
3.2%
115
6.2%
-
Depressed Mood 3
641
34.5%
528
32.5% a
36
62.1% a
26
44.1%
51
44.3%
< 0.001
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Suicide ideation 4
313
16.9%
235
14.5% a,b,c
26
44.8% a
22
37.3% b
30
26.1% c
< 0.001
Odds Ratios
Unadjusted 6
-
Reference
Category
4.80
(2.81–8.21)
p < 0.001
3.51
(2.04–6.06)
p < 0.001
2.09
(1.35–3.24)
p = 0.001
-
Regression Odds Ratios
Adjusted 6-
Reference
Category
2.31
(1.22–4.37)
p = 0.010
2.64
(1.38–5.08)
p = 0.004
1.26
(0.76–2.08)
p = 0.373 ns
-
Suicide Attempt 5
177
9.5%
133
8.2% a,b
17
29.3% a
12
20.3% b
15
13.0%
< 0.001
Odds Ratios
Unadjusted 6-
Reference
Category
4.65
(2.57–8.41)
p < 0.000
2.86
(1.48–5.53)
p = 0.002
1.68
(0.95–2.98)
p = 0.074 ns
-
Regression Odds Ratios
Adjusted 6-
Reference
Category
2.23
(1.15–4.35)
p = 0.018
1.61
(0.77–3.36)
p = 0.203 ns
1.03
(0.55–1.91)
p = 0.926 ns
-
1. Without Same-Sex Attraction or Behavior Reported
2.
With Same-Sex Attraction or Behavior Reported
3. Depressed mood was measured by asking, “During the past 12 months,
did you ever feel so sad or hopeless almost every day for 2 weeks or
more in a row that you stopped doing some usual activities?”
4. Suicidal ideation was assessed dichotomously with the item, “During
the past 12 months, did you ever seriously consider attempting suicide?”
5. Suicide attempt was assessed with the item, “During the past 12 months, how many times did you actually attempt suicide?”
6. Reference Category: Heterosexual, No Homosexuality.
7. Adjusted or Controlled in Binary Regression Model using the
following variables: age, gender, depressed mood, smoking, drinking,
marijuana use, hard drugs, fighting, physical abuse, sexual abuse,
early sexual behavior, and sexual identity.
a. Heterosexual without same-sex attraction/fantasy or behavior
significantly different from GLB, p < .0083 based on Bonferroni
correction.
b. Heterosexual without same-sex attraction/fantasy or behavior
significantly different from unsure, p < .0083 based on Bonferroni
correction.
c. Heterosexual without same-sex attraction/fantasy or behavior
different from heterosexual with same-sex attraction/fantasy or
behavior, p < .0083 based on Bonferroni correction.
Zhao Y, Montoro R, Igartua K, Thombs BD (2010). Suicidal
ideation and attempt among adolescents reporting "unsure" sexual
identity or heterosexual identity plus same-sex attraction or behavior:
forgotten groups? Journal of the American Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 49(2): 104-13. Abstract.
Rhode Island 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey
Suicidality Results: GLBU vs. Heterosexual
Category
N
Weighted
%
Felt Sad
Hopeless 1
%
Considered
Suicide 2
%
Planned
Suicide 3
%
Attempted
Suicide 4
%
Received
Medical
Attention 5
%
Heterosexual
1954
90.1%
20.8%
9.6%
9.7%
6.6%
3.1%
GLBU: Gay, Lesbian,
Bisexual, Unsure
225
9.9%
50.3%
33.5%
26.8%
31.0
10.5%
RR: Risk Ratios
OR: Odds Ratios 6
-
2.4
3.9
3.4
4.6
2.8
3.4
4.7
6.4
3.4
3.7
Binary Regression
Analyses
Controls = 8 variables
-
-
-
-
-
Heterosexual
(Reference Category)
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
GLBU: Odd Ratios
95% Confidence Intervals 7
2.7
(1.6, 4.5)
p < 0.001
3.1
(1.8, 5.2)
p < 0.001
2.0
(1.2, 3.4)
p < 0.001
3.5
(2.4, 5.2)
p < 0.001
2.0
(1.1, 3.5)
p < 0.05
1. Depressed mood was measured by asking, “During the past 12 months,
did you ever feel so sad or hopeless almost every day for 2 weeks or
more in a row that you stopped doing some usual activities?”
2. Suicidal ideation was assessed dichotomously with the item, “During
the past 12 months, did you ever seriously consider attempting suicide?”
3. Planning Suicide was asseessed by asking "During the past 12 months, did you ever seriously consider attempting suicide?"
4. Suicide attempt was assessed with the item, “During the past 12 months, how many times did you actually attempt suicide?”
5. Suicide attempt(s) associated with receiving medical attention was
assessedwith the item: "If you attempted suicide during the past 12
months, did any attempt result in an injury, poisoning, or overdose
that had to be treated by a doctor or nurse?
6. Not given by Zhao et al. (2010). Calculated by webpage author using 2-way Contingency Table Analysis.
7. Results given by Zhao et al. (2010).
The 8 control variables are: Sex, Grade Level, Academic performance,
Usual language at home, Did not go to school owing to safety concerns,
Forced to have sexual intercourse, Current smoking, and Perceived
weight.
Note: The Rhode Island Departments of Health and Elementary & Secondary Education (2009) gives many of the variable incidence results on the basis of sexual orientation.
Jiang Y, Perry DK, Hesser JE (2010). Adolescent suicide and health risk behaviors: Rhode Island's 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. American Journal of Preventative Medicine, 38(5): 551-5. Abstract.
Rhode Island Departments of Health and Elementary & Secondary Education (2009). Sexual Orientation and Health Risks Among Rhode Island Public High School Students in 2007. PDF.
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: Vermont, 2011 Sexual Orientation & "Attempted Suicide" |
|||||
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Unsure (N = 2,100; 8%)* |
Heterosexual (N = 25,900; 92%)* |
*Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
||
| - |
Wgt'd N* |
% (95% C.I.) |
Wgt'd N* |
% (95% C.I.) |
- |
| Reported |
300 |
16% (13.5, 19.0) |
700 |
3% (2.0-3.3) |
RR: 5.3 OR: 6.2 |
| Percentages: CI Midpoints Estimates |
- |
16.25% |
- |
2.65% |
RR: 6.1 OR: 7.1 |
| Data Source: Outright Vermont (2012) *Weighted number, rounded to the nearest 100. RRs & ORs Calculated at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html. Note: GLBU students Account for about 30% of suicide attempters: 300 / (300 + 7000) = 30% |
|||||
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: Vermont, 2011 Sexual Behavior & "Attempted Suicide" |
|||||
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
Students Reporting Same-Sex Sex (n = 428; 5%)* |
Students Reporting Only Opposite-Sex Sex (n = 4204; 51%)* | *Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
||
| - |
Wgt'd N* |
% (95% C.I.) |
Wgt'd N* |
% (95% C.I.) | - |
| Reported |
? |
19% (15.3-23.8) | ? |
4% (3.0-5.3) | RR: 4.8 OR: 5.6 |
| Percentages: CI Midpoints Estimates |
19.55% |
4.15% | RR: 4.7 OR: 5.6 |
||
| Data Source: Outright Vermont (2012a) *Weighted number, rounded to the nearest 100. RRs & ORs Calculated at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html. |
|||||
Outright Vermont (2012). 2011 Vermont Youth Risk Behavior Survey (Risk Behaviors: GLBU vs. Heterosexual Identity]. PDF Download. Download Page: 2011 Vermont Youth Risk Behavior Survey Data.
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: Vermont, 2009 Sexual Orientation & "At Risk" Variable Incidences |
||||
| Categories |
Heterosexual n = 10,319 92% |
Gay or Lesbian n =114, 1% |
Bisexual n = 516 4% |
Not Sure n = 328 3% |
| Attempted Suicide, Past 12 Months Risk Ratios, Odds Ratio 1 |
3% Reference Category: 1 |
24% RR: 8.0 OR: 10.2 |
21% RR: 7.0 OR: 8.6 |
15% RR: 5.0 OR: 5.7 |
| Safety Belt Use |
17% |
33% |
31% |
27% |
| Vomited or Took Laxatives To Control Weight |
4% |
19% |
19% |
15% |
| Skipped school, Feeling Unsafe |
4% |
18% |
16% |
18% |
| Threatened or Injured With Weapon at School |
5% |
25% |
17% |
13% |
| Was Bullied |
16% | 36% |
35% |
34% |
| Physical Fighting |
26% |
48% |
45% |
33% |
| Smoked Cigarettes |
13% |
46% |
42% |
30% |
| Binge Drinking |
20% |
41% |
31% |
22% |
| Marijuana Use |
21% |
46% |
39% |
24% |
| Inhalant Use |
9% |
34% |
29% |
17% |
| Cocaine Use |
3% |
18% |
11% |
10% |
| Heroin Use |
2% |
21% |
13% |
12% |
| Injected Drugs |
2% |
16% |
11% |
10% |
|
Data Source: Outright Vermont (2010)
|
||||
Outright Vermont (2010). 2009 Vermont Youth Risk Behavior Survey N/A (Archive Link):
In the past 12 months, 26% of gay/lesbian students, 29% of bisexual
students and 10% of those 'not sure' of their sexual orientation had
attempted suicide, compared to 4% of heterosexual students.
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: Vermont, 2007 Sexual Orientation & "At Risk" Variable Incidences |
||||
| Categories |
Heterosexual n = 7,746 92.6% |
Gay or Lesbian n =94, 1.1% |
Bisexual n = 286 3.4% |
Not Sure n = 238 2.8% |
| Attempted Suicide, Past 12 Months Risk Ratios, Odds Ratio 1 |
4% Reference Category: 1 |
26% RR: 6.5 OR: 8.4 |
29% RR: 7.3 OR: 9.8 |
10% RR: 2.5 OR: 2.7 |
| Safety Belt Use |
16% |
30% |
32% |
20% |
| Vomited or Took Laxatives To Control Weight |
4% |
17% |
17% |
17% |
| Skipped school, Feeling Unsafe |
3% |
27% |
11% |
15% |
| Threatened or Injured With Weapon at School |
6% |
30% |
14% |
15% |
| Physical Fighting |
26% |
41% |
45% |
34% |
| Smoked Cigarettes |
15% |
40% |
45% |
19% |
| Binge Drinking |
23% |
39% |
34% |
20% |
| Marijuana Use |
21% |
46% |
40% |
23% |
| Inhalant Use |
10% |
38% |
36% |
21% |
| Cocaine Use |
4% |
30% |
16% |
10% |
| Injected Drugs |
2% |
23% |
12% |
10% |
|
Data Source: Outright Vermont (2008)
|
||||
Outright Vermont (2008). 2007 Vermont Youth Risk Behavior Survey N/A (Archive Link): In the past 12 months, 26% of gay/lesbian students, 29% of bisexual students and 10% of those 'not sure' of their sexual orientation had attempted suicide, compared to 4% of heterosexual students.
2005 Franklin County Student Health Survey Regional Results. Internet: http://www.frcog.org/pubs/teen/05survey.pdf.
Suicide and Sexual Orientation
Overall, students who identify as gay, lesbian, or bisexual are
significantly more likely to have considered, planned, and attempted
suicide than their heterosexual peers (p<=.01). Only 6 students
reported identifying as “transgendered”, too small a number to produce
reliable results.
| Sexual Orientation Related Suicidality High School Students, Vermont: Franklin County |
|||||
| Category |
Ns |
*Consider Suicide |
*Planned Suicide |
*Attempted Suicide |
Odds Ratios** 95% CI, p |
| Heterosexual |
927 |
16% |
9% |
37 / 927 = 4% |
|
| Gay/Lesbian |
19 |
42% |
12% |
7 / 19 = 37% |
5.2<14.0<37.7 0.0000 |
| Not Identified |
54 |
17% |
13% |
9 / 54 = 17% |
2.2<4.8<10.6 0.0000 |
| Bisexual |
62 |
42% |
38% |
18 / 62 = 29% |
6.2<12.0<23.1 0.0000 |
| Transgender |
6 |
N/A |
N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Not sure |
80 |
14% |
9% |
5 / 80 = 6% |
0.61<1.6<4.2 0.332 |
| Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual |
81 |
25 / 81 = 30.9% |
6.0<10.7<19.1 0.0000 |
||
* In the Past 12 Months.
** ORs for category versus heterosexual.
Appromimate ORs. Counts used for calculations are estimated from percentages given.
Source: - http://www.outrightvt.org/education/youth_stats.shtml N/A (Archive Link).
The 2005 Vermont Department of Health/Education Youth Risk Behavior Survey1
Overall this year, 7% of students described themselves as lesbian, gay,
bisexual or questioning (LGBQ) (2005 YRBS Report, page 64).
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: Vermont, 2005 Sexual Orientation / Behavior & "At Risk" Variables |
|||||
| Reported Behavior2 | Engaged in same sex sexual intercourse (n=241) |
Engaged in opposite sex sexual intercourse (n=2944) | Not Had Sex (n=6022) | Hetero- sexual (n=8547) |
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Questioning (LGBQ) (n=416) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Was bullied3 (during the past 30 days): |
41% | 16% | 18% | 17% | 33% |
| Safety belts use (never, rarely or sometimes wear): |
45% | 29% | 9% | 16% | 30% |
| Attempted suicide (during the past 12 months): |
42% | 9% | 3% | 5% | 27% |
| Skipped school because of feeling unsafe on route to or
at school (during the past 30 days): |
27% | 7% | 2% | 4% | 15% |
| Threatened or injured with a weapon at school (during the past 12 months): |
35% | 9% | 4% | 6% | 20% |
| Physical fighting (during the past 12 months): |
56% | 37% | 20% | 26% | 40% |
| Smoked cigarettes (during the 30 days): |
64% | 34% | 5% | 15% | 36% |
| Binge drinking (during the past 30 days): |
60% | 42% | 9% | 21% | 31% |
| Marijuana use (during the past 30 days): |
67% | 43% | 9% | 21% | 34% |
| Inhalant use (during lifetime): |
56% | 20% | 6% | 11% | 32% |
| Cocaine use (during the past 30 days): |
41% | 8% | <1% | 3% | 16% |
| Injected drug use (during lifetime): |
32% | 4% | <1% | 2% | 13% |
| Vomited or took laxatives to control their weight (during the past 30 days): |
33% | 7% | 2% | 4% | 17% |
| Heroin Use (during lifetime): | 36% | 5% | <1% | 2% | 16% |
1: The Vermont Department of Health/Education Youth Risk Behavior Survey
(YRBS) has been conducted every two years since 1985. This survey
measures the prevalence of behaviors that contribute to the leading
causes of death, disease, and injury among youth. In 2005, school
staff administered the YRBS to 31,617 eighth to twelfth grade Vermont
students in 146 schools. Participation by both schools & individual
students were completely voluntary. For the purpose of this
report, data are based on a representative sample of 9,342 Vermont
high school & middle school students. (2005 YRBS Report, page
1)
2: It is important to note that until 2005, the YRBS did not ask any questions about sexual orientation, gender identity or expression. So until this year, students' sexual orientation has been assumed based on who they report having had sex with. Obviously this has been not an entirely accurate way to assess the number of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender or questioning (LGBTQ) or queer students and their risk behaviors. This year, sexual orientation was asked & we therefore were able to pull the numbers on students who identified as heterosexual or lesbian, gay, bisexual or questioning (LGBQ). Please note that the survey still does not offer a way for transgender students to identify themselves, so there is still a gap in these stats. Also, this survey only surveys youth who are in public schools, thus failing to get information on homeless youth in Vermont, many of which are homeless due to their sexual orientation or gender variance.
3: This question was new this year, based on the recent legislation
passed in 2004 in Vermont. Bullying was defined as occurring
when, on many occasions, a student or group of students say or do
unpleasant things to another student to make fun of, tease, embarrass,
or scare him/her; or purposefully exclude him/her. Bullying
can occur before, during, or after the school day; on school property,
a school bus, or at a school sponsored activity. It is not bullying
when two students of about the same strength and power argue or fight
or when teasing is done in a friendly way. (2005 YRBS Report, page
10 & 11).
Research Highlights: From the Vermont sample of grades 8 to 12 students (in 79 randomly selected public and private schools, 97.5% white) administered the Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Out of 3886 sexually active adolescent males (36% of boys), 8.7% (Note) reported having been homosexually active (defined by having had "sexual intercourse" with a male).
The statistical analysis basically evaluated the risk for "at risk" behaviors on the basis of the number of male sexual partners reported by males" ("0" to "6 or more"). With an increasing number of male sex partners, males were significantly more at risk for: (1) suicide attempts ( r = .27, p < 0.0002), (2) "being threatened or injured with a weapon at school, the number of days the students did not attend school because they felt unsafe, and the number of times they had been injured in a fight that required medical treatment." ( r = from .21 to .17, p < 0.0002), and (3) other behaviors.
Another statistical analysis compared males (131) with five or more male sex partners with males (895) with five or more female sex partners, thus revealing that 12.8% (131/1026) of the males with the most sexual partners ( > 4 ) are homosexually oriented and over-represented in this category. The result of this analysis indicated that the homosexually oriented males in this category were more likely to have carried a weapon to school in the last 30 days (p < 0.002), and they were even more likely to carry weapons more frequently, not go to school because of fear, be threatened or injured with a weapon, be in a fight, be injured in a fight and requiring medical attention, be threatened with physical violence, and attempting suicide (all at p < 0.0001).
More statistical results are given, but percentage of males in different risk categories are not given. See data below from another source for the percentages of males "at risk" in the homosexually active vs heterosexually active categories.
Note: There are some discrepancies in the cited number and percentages reported. For example, in Table 1, 3547 boys are noted to not have had sexual intercourse with another male, while a total of 278 boys (86 + 27 + 22 + 12 + 8 + 123) are reported to have had intercourse with a male ranging from the category of "one time" (86) to "6 or more" (123). These number, however, do not add up to 3886 males, but to 3825 males. Therefore, the percentages of males homosexually active, based on the table data, is 7.3% (278 / 3825). The reason for this discrepancy is not known.
Information Sources: Data reported below is taken from Sexual Orientation and Youth Suicide by Lynne Levine & Linda Beeler. Paper presented at Defining the Problem and Meeting The Challenge: Third Bi-Regional Adolescent Suicide Prevention Conference held in Breckenridge, Colorado, September, 1997. Relevant information is available from Kelly Hale at The Vermont Department of Health (802) 651-1557, or from Shaun Donahue at The Vermont Department of Education (802) 748-8640.
General Information available from The Vermont Department of Health N/A Archive Link - "Gay and Lesbian Youth: Although many lesbian, gay, and bisexual adolescents lead happy and healthy lives, others face tremendous challenges to growing up physically and mentally healthy. Compared to heterosexual youth, lesbian, gay, and bisexual young people are at higher risk for depression, alcohol and other drug use, suicide, HIV infection, and other sexually transmitted diseases. Suicide is the leading cause of death among this group. They are two to three times more likely to attempt suicide than their heterosexual peers and may account for 30 percent of suicides among youth annually... Same-gender sexual intercourse. 3% of female students and 4% of male students have had sexual intercourse during their lifetime with someone of the same gender. During the past 3 months, 2% of females and 3% of males have had sexual intercourse with same-gender partners." No specific information is given about the "at risk" status of homosexually oriented adolescents.
Suicide Information Summary:
4%
of (grades 8 to 12) male students and 3% of female students reported having
been sexually active with a same-gender individual.
These 'GLB' adolescents were..... (compared to other sexually active adolescents):
1.6
times more likely to have considered suicide in the past year (59.2% vs
37.1%).
1.8
times more likely to have planned a suicide in the past year (52.8% vs
28.7%).
2.7
times more likely to have attempted suicide in the past year (40.7% vs
15.2%).
4.3 times more likely to have attempted suicide which resulted in medical
attention (26.5% vs. 6.2%).
Note: The "at risk"
percentages result in this study are higher than in other studies most
likely because only sexually active adolescents are being compared,
thus indicating that all "sexually" active are more "at risk' than other
adolescents, and that homosexually active adolescents are the
most at risk.
1995 Vermont YRBS Summary of Results: Full Text N/A. Archive Link.
According to the 1995 Vermont Youth Risk Behavior Survey (VRBS),
4% of all 8th-12th male students and 3% of all femals students
have had sexual intercourse with a member of the same sex. When
compared
| Risk Behavior | GLB* Students |
Other Students |
|---|---|---|
| Never, rarely or only sometimes wore a safety belt when riding in a car |
|
|
| Attempted suicide (during past 12 months) |
|
|
| Skipped school because of feeling unsafe on route to or at school *during past 30 days) |
|
|
| Was threatened/injured with a weapon at school (during past 12 months) |
|
|
| Was in a physical fight (during past 12 months) |
|
|
| Smoked cigarettes (during past 30 days) |
|
|
| Binged on alcohol (during past 30 days) |
|
|
| Used marijuana (during past 30 days) |
|
|
| Used inhalants to get high (during lifetime) |
|
|
| Used cocaine (during past 30 days) |
|
|
| Had sexual intercourse prior to age 12 (percentage among sexually active students only) |
|
|
| Was ever forced or pressured to have sexual intercourse (percentage among sexually active students only) |
|
|
| Drank alcohol or used drugs before last sexual experience (percentage among sexually active students only) |
|
|
| Was pregnant or had gotten someone pregnant (percentage among sexually active students only) |
|
|
| Vomited or took laxatives to control their weight (during past 30 days) |
|
|
A 2002 Re-Evaluation of Massachusetts 1995/97 & Vermont 1995/97 Youth Risk Behavior Surveys: Bisexually Active Adolescents Most At Risk.
Robin L, Brener ND, Donahue SF, Hack T, Hale K, Goodenow C (2002). Associations between health risk behaviors and opposite-, same-, and both-sex sexual partners in representative samples of Vermont and Massachusetts high school. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 156(4): 349-55. PubMed Abstract. Full Text.
From this paper, the results of 4 surveys are given: 2 from Vermont, and 2 from Massachusetts. The two surveys from Vermont (1995 & 1997 Youth Risk Behavior Survey) were combined to form one data set, and the two survey from Massachusetts (1995 & 1997 Youth Risk Behavior Survey) were combined to form another data set, and results were presented for "Vermont Students" and "Massachusetts Students" from Grades 9 to 12 (High School) as follows for having attempted suicide in the past year:
Percent Attempting Suicide "In the Past Year" (In square brackets [--]: % with suicide attempt associated with having received medical care) for students in 3 categories: (1) Those reporting only opposite sex sexual partners, (2) those reporting only same-sex sexual partner, and (3) those reporting sexual partners of both sexes:
Vermont Students
Those With Only Opposite-Sex Sex
Partners (n = 6873) - % attempting suicide = 11.9% [4.5%]
Those With Only Same-Sex Sex partners
(n = 249) - % attempting suicide = 16.5% [5.6%]
Those With Sex Partners of Both
Sexes (n = 336) - % attempting suicide = 43.5% [26.8%]
Massachusetts Students
Those With Only Opposite-Sex Sex
Partners (n = 3948) - % attempting suicide = 12.4% [4.5%]
Those With Only Same-Sex Sex partners
(n = 106) - % attempting suicide = 18.5% [7.8%]
Those With Sex Partners of Both
Sexes (n = 122) - % attempting suicide = 52.2% [31.6%]
Notes:
1. The above excludes students who
are not reporting having had sexual intercourse in their lifetime. Suicide
attempts incidences are lower for students who are not sexually active.
2. There are more student who are
bisexually active than students who are only homosexually active - in terms
of having sexual partners.
3. Bisexually active students are
at the greatest risk for having attempted suicide in the past year. They
are also at greater relative risk for suicide attempts associated with
having received medical care. Generally, these would be the most serious
suicide attempts, but not always.
4. Bisexually active students are
also more at risk for a number of other problems. See Paper.
The information presented above is
from Table 2, page 252.
Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Washington DC (2009).
Was the survey purposefully sabotaged to avoid reporting any GLBT "At Risk" data? [Why was information related the the 2007 YRBS - the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual Results - removed from the DC Public Schools Webbsite: Washington, DC 2007 Public High School YRBS: Baseline Findings for GLBQ Items (PDF Download N/A). Use the "search" function at the "DC Public Schools Webbsite" to see if any concerns is noted about gay, lesbian, or bisexual students.]
Chibbaro, Lou Jr (2010): D.C. schools get incomplete score on LGBT youth survey:
A survey of risky behavior by D.C. youth, including LGBT youth, was so
flawed that its data cannot be weighted, hindering local groups as they
work to help gay students and fight HIV... "We’re still going to be
reporting it as un-weighted data," he said. "It doesn’t mean we won’t
be able to use the data to make the case for grant funding. It just
means you won’t be able to compare it to other states and districts."
But Hunter said that un-weighted data only "provides a snapshot of
what’s going on among the students that were surveyed." She said the
data cannot be used to extrapolate the behavior of the entire student
population. Only "weighted data," which is obtained from a response
rate of 60 percent or greater, can be used to assess the behavior of
the larger population group, she said. Tenner said CDC officials told
him the D.C. survey response rate was 36 percent for high school
students and 54 percent for middle school students. "Many of us use the
Youth Risk Behavior Survey for our programs and our grants," Tenner
said in an e-mail to local activists. :"From a city-wide perspective,
many of us were excited to use YRBS data to objectively measure the
city’s effort to improve the health of its youth and to highlight the
challenges that remain."
Najafi, Yusef (2010). D.C.'s
Failing Grade: Local LGBT students not included in national CDC survey
of risk behaviors; District did not achieve adequate response rate for
surveys: "OSSE did the survey and in order for them to meet the
CDC requirement they have to get a 60 percent response rate," explains
David Mariner, executive director of The Center, D.C.'s LGBT community
center. "It wasn’t even close to 60 percent," he adds. "It was a 36
percent response rate. I can’t conceive of how that happened, and I
haven’t heard a satisfactory explanation." As of Tuesday, March 9, no
one has. OSSE did not return calls to Metro Weekly requesting comment
before deadline. And representatives from the OSSE could not address
the matter during a March 5 Committee of the Whole oversight hearing
due to scheduling conflicts. Council Chairman Vincent Gray said during
that meeting that the public would speak, and that OSSE representatives
will speak at a later date. Mariner says in the past the survey has
shed light on the plight of gay, lesbian and bisexual youth whose
answers have demonstrated that they are more likely to use crystal
meth, that they feel less safe going to school than their straight
counterparts, and that they’re more likely to carry a weapon or skip
school. The "unusable" 2009 survey was the first to include gender
identity...
Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Washington DC (2007).
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: Washington D.C., 2009 Sexual Orientation & Suicidality |
||||
| Categories |
Heterosexual |
Gay or Lesbian |
Bisexual |
Not Sure |
| Males [Should be %?] 1 N = 592 |
90.0% [90.7%] N = 537 |
3.1% [2.9%] N = 17 |
4.1% [3.4%] N = 20 |
3.0% [3.0%] N = 18 |
| Females [Should be %?] 1 N = 940 |
86.8% [86.6%] N = 814 |
3.6% [2.9%] N = 27 |
6.3% [6.4%] N = 60 |
3.3% [4.1%] N = 39 |
| Males & Females 2 N = 1,532 Given N = 1,783 Missing? 251? All Males? |
88.2% 1,351 |
2.9% 44 |
5.2% 80 |
3.7% 57 |
| Males & Females 3 N = 1,532 Given N = 1,783 |
88.2% 1,351 |
8.1% 124 |
3.7% 57 |
|
| Sad Two Weeks, Past Year |
25.7% (363) [363 / 1,412] |
40.3% (48) - [48 / 119] RR: 1.6 (1.1 - 2.0) OR: 2.0 (1.3 - 2.9) p = 0.001 |
- |
|
| Consider Suicide, Past Year |
13.8 % (198) [ 198 / 1,435] |
30.6% (37) - [37 / 121] RR: 2.2 (1.6 - 2.9) 4 OR: 2.8 (1.8 - 4.2) p < 0.000 |
- |
|
| Plan Suicide, Past Year |
10.3% (147) [147 / 1,427] | 28.9% (35) - [35 / 121] RR: 2.8 (2.0 - 3.8) OR: 3.5 (2.3 - 5.4) p < 0.000 |
- |
|
| Attempt Suicide, Past Year |
8.6% (100) [100 / 1,163] |
32.6% (28) - [28 / 86] RR: 3.8 (2.6 - 5.3) OR: 5.1 (3.1 - 5.4) p < 0.000 |
- |
|
|
||||
| Washington, DC 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Sexual Minority Results |
|||
| Categories |
Heterosexual or Only Opposite- Sex Sex |
Gay, Lesbian Bisexual or Same- Sex Sex |
Odds Ratio No Controls* |
| Sad, Hopeless for 2 Weeks |
26% |
41% |
2.0 p < 0.05 |
| Considered Suicide |
13% |
31% |
3.0 p < 0.05 |
| Planned Suicide |
10% |
24% |
2.8 p < 0.05 |
| Attempted Suicide |
9% |
34% |
5.2 p < 0.05 |
| Attempted, Received Medical Care |
3 |
10% |
3.6 p < 0.05 |
Data Source: Blake et al. (2010) *Odds Ratios calculated by webpage author from given percentages. Statistical Significance, p < 0.05, given by study authors. |
|||
Blake SM, Ledsky R, Whycoff V, Cleary SD, Castel AD, Acosta Price O (2010). Health & Risk Behaviors of District of Columbia Youth: The Youth Risk Behavior Survey Report, 2007. The Office of the State Superintendent of Education (OSSE), Office of Wellness and Nutrition Services (WNS), June 2010. PDF Download.
Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Seattle, WA (1995).
Information Source:
Safe
Schools Anti-Violence Documentation Project - Part Two: The Seattle Public
Schools' Teen Health Risk Survey N/A (Archive Link). If unavailable,
see Table 4: - http://www.safeschools-wa.org/quant_mh.html
N/A (Archive Link) - and Table 6: http://www.safeschools-wa.org/quant_so.html
N/A (Archive Link). Data source is from
the document "83,000 youth" by Reis and Saewyc (April,
1999) located at - http://www.safeschools-wa.org/ N/A
(Archive Link, New Website) - http://www.safeschools-wa.org/83000youth.pdf N/A
(PDF Download of Document, Archive Link, New Link)
Suicide Information Summary:
"Overall,
about 91% of students [grades 9 to 12, public schools] called themselves
Heterosexual. The other 9% said either that they did not consider themselves
Heterosexual or that they were not sure:"
Question
(#58) used: "How would you describe your sexual orientation / preference?
a. Heterosexual - attracted to opposite sex; b. Bisexual - attracted to
both sexes; c. Homosexual (Gay or Lesbian) - attracted to same sex; d.
Not sure."
1%
identified themselves as Gay or Lesbian.
4%
described themselves as Bisexual.
Approximately
4% said they were not sure of their orientations."
Excluding students who were "not sure" about their sexual orientation - - Compared to heterosexual-identified students, GLB students were:
twice
as likely as heterosexual students to report having seriously considered
suicide in the twelve months preceding the survey (34.4% vs. 16.7%).
twice as likely to say that they made a suicide plan in the twelve months
preceding the survey (31.1% vs. 15.7%).
three
times as likely to report having attempted suicide in the twelve months
preceding the survey (20.6% vs. 6.7%).
more
than four times as likely to report having made a serious enough attempt
on their lives to require treatment by a doctor or nurse in the twelve
months preceding the survey (9.4% vs. 2.2%).
![]()
On
the basis of the data produced in this study, it was possible to estimate
"the homosexuality factor" in the adolescent suicide attempt problem. For
the information and calculations producing the following results, likely
to be minimums, follow this link - Alternate Link.
Gay,
lesbian, and bisexual identified adolescent targeted or not targeted for
anti-gay violence, and heterosexual identified adolescents targeted for
anti-gay violence because they are believed to be homosexually oriented,
account for 27.8% of suicide attempters. (Based on a 'total' student population
which excluded students "not sure" about their sexual orientation - 4%
of sample.)
Gay,
lesbian, and bisexual identified adolescents targeted or not targeted for
anti-gay violence, and heterosexual identified adolescents targeted for
anti-gay violence because they are believed to be homosexually oriented,
account for 37.2% of adolescents for whom their suicide attempt resulted
in medical attention. (Based on a 'total' student population which
excluded students "not sure" about their sexual orientation - 4% of sample.)
Implications:
Numerous
mainstream suicidologists do not seem to understand how "just
being a little faggot or a dyke, or being treated as if one is" could ever
be related to suicide attempts or suicide, and David Shaffer (apparently
an expert (?) in youth suicide problems) is in this category. Many adolescents
who identify as heterosexual are being abused by individuals who are assuming
they are homosexually oriented, and their abuse is implicated in their
high attempted suicide rates compared to non-abused heterosexual identified
teens: 20.5% (8.6% for suicide attempts resulting in medical attention)
versus 5.7% (1.7% for suicide attempts resulting in medical attention)
for adolescents not targeted for anti-gay abuse. For GLB adolescents, however,
their attempted suicide rates did not vary on the basis of being targeted
for anti-gay abuse (about one-third of self-identified GLB teens) or not
targeted for anti-gay abuse (two-thirds of self-identified GLB teens) probably
because they are remaining in the closet. The attempted suicide rates of
the abused GLB teens was 20.3% (9.6% for suicide attempts resulting in
medical attention), while non-abused GLB teens had an attempted suicide
rate of 19.1% (7.8% for suicide attempts resulting in medical attention).
The implications of this information is monumental, given that The
Homosexuality Factor is implicated in about 30% of adolescent suicide
attempts and about 40% of the suicide attempts resulting in medical attention.
The greater proportion of the more serious suicide attempts occurring in
this latter category also strongly suggests that the most serious
results of suicide attempts - DEATHS - may have an even greater over-representation
by teens for whom The Homosexuality Factor applies. It is
possible that 50 to 70 percent of teen suicide have been in this
category.
Research Results Needed: To determine the total for "The Homosexuality Factor" in adolescent suicide problems. Doing this would require "suicide attempt" information about the "not sure" group representing about 4% of sample. It is possible that the "not sure" group - with doubts about their sexual orientation - may have elevated levels of suicide problem, and some of them would surely be in the group targeted for "anti-homosexuality" abuse, thus increasing the size of this "at risk" category. The same may apply for heterosexual students targeted for anti-gay/lesbian abuses. This Information was eventually obtained. See Tables of Results.
| Wisconsin 2007, 2009 & 2011 Youth Risk Behavior Surveys: Grades 9 to 12 - Sexual Behavior Related Suicidality Results |
|||
| Categories | Students Reporting Same-Sex Sex |
Students Reporting Only Opposite- Sex Sex | Odds Ratio * |
| Felt
so sad or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a
row during the past 12 months that they stopped doing some usual
activities |
49%* |
25% | OR: 2.5 |
| Seriously considered attempting suicide during the past 12 months |
42% |
15% | OR: 3.7 |
| Planned a Suicide during the past 12 months |
33% |
11% |
OR: 3.6 |
| Actually attempted suicide one or more times during the past 12 months |
28% |
7% | OR: 4.8 |
| Made
a suicide attempt during the past 12 months that resulted in an
injury, poisoning, or overdose that had to be treated by a doctor
or nurse |
13% |
2% |
OR: 5.4 |
|
Data Source: Mohr & Husain (2012)
|
|||
| Wisconsin 2007, 2009 & 2011 Youth Risk Behavior Surveys: Grades 9 to 12 - Sexual Identity Related Suicidality Results |
||||
| Categories |
Hetero- sexual |
Gay / Lesbian |
Bisexual |
Unsure |
| Felt
so sad or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a
row during the past 12 months that they stopped doing some usual
activities: Incidence |
20%* |
46% |
60% |
44% |
| Odds Ratios, With Control Variables ** GL, B or U vs. Heterosexual |
- |
3.7 |
5.1 |
2.9 |
| Actually attempted suicide one or more times during the past 12 months: Incidence |
5%* |
29% |
31% |
24% |
| Odds Ratios, With Control Variables ** GL, B or U vs. Heterosexual |
- |
7.6 |
8.3 |
5.2 |
Data Source: Mohr & Husain (2012)
**Odds Ratios: Controlled for difference related to grade and sex. |
||||
Mohr A, Husain A (2012). The Youth Risk Behavior Survey and Sexual Minority Youth in Wisconsin 2007-2011. Slide Presentation. Wisconsin Department of Health Services. Population Health Institute, University of Wisconsin. PDF Download. Download Page. Note: 2011 Wisconsin YRBS results also given separately. Some 2007 to 2011 YRBS results given for the City of Milwaukee. At Download Page, see also: "Full Report Presentation" & Webinar Presentation 1 & 2.
| Wisconsin 2007 & 2009 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 'Sexual Orientation' Related Results |
|||
| Categories | Students Reporting Same-Sex Sex |
Students Reporting Only Opposite- Sex Sex | Risk Ratio Odds Ratio p |
| Felt
so sad or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a
row during the past 12 months that they stopped doing some usual
activities |
46% |
25% | RR: 1.8 OR: 2.6 p < 0.01 |
| Seriously considered attempting suicide during the past 12 months |
41% |
16% | RR: 2.6 OR: 3.6 p < 0.01 |
| Actually attempted suicide one or more times during the past 12 months |
25% |
7% | RR: 3.6 OR: 4.4 p < 0.01 |
| Made
a suicide attempt during the past 12 months that resulted in an
injury, poisoning, or overdose that had to be treated by a doctor
or nurse |
12% |
2% |
RR: 6.0 OR: 6.7 p < 0.01 |
|
Data Source: Gasiorowicz et al. (2010). "The 2009 YRBS sample of 2,430 includes 138 same-sex, 1,255 het-sex and 1,027 no-sex students. There are also 10 missing data points for students who did not respond to the respective question. Same-sex respondents comprise 10% (n=138) of the sexually active respondents, an increase from 8% found in the YRBS 2007 analysis." Many "At Risk" behaviors are given but they are not in this data table. |
|||
Gasiorowicz M, Karki C, Herrmann M, Hollander G (2010). Health disparities experienced by youth engaging in same-sex sexual behavior in Wisconsin: 2007/2009 Wisconsin Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results Combined. PPT Presentation.
| Wisconsin 2009 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 'Sexual Orientation' Related Results |
|||
| Categories | Students Reporting Same-Sex Sex: n = 138 |
Students Reporting Only Opposite- Sex Sex, n = 1,255 | Risk Ratio Odds Ratio p |
| Felt so sad or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a row during the past 12 months that they stopped doing some usual activities |
46.6% |
24.1% | RR: 1.9 OR: 2.7 p < 0.01 |
| Seriously considered attempting suicide during the past 12 months |
39.7% |
14.4% | RR: 2.8 OR: 3.9 p < 0.01 |
| Made a plan about how they would attempt suicide during the past 12 months |
32.2% |
10.6% | RR: 3.0 OR: 4.0 p < 0.01 |
| Actually attempted suicide one or more times during the past 12 months |
24.8% |
5.7% | RR: 4.4 RR: 5.5 p < 0.01 |
| Made a suicide attempt during the past 12 months that resulted in an injury, poisoning, or overdose that had to be treated by a doctor or nurse |
10.0% |
1.6% |
RR: 6.3 RR: 6.8 p < 0.05 |
|
Data Source: Karki et al. (2010). "The 2009 YRBS sample of 2,430 includes 138 same-sex, 1,255 het-sex and 1,027 no-sex students. There are also 10 missing data points for students who did not respond to the respective question. Same-sex respondents comprise 10% (n=138) of the sexually active respondents, an increase from 8% found in the YRBS 2007 analysis." Many "At Risk" behaviors are given but they are not in this data table. |
|||
Karki C, Gasiorowicz M, Hollander G (2010). Risk
Behaviors and Health Conditions of Youth Engaging in Same-Sex Sexual
Behaviors: Analysis of the 2009 Wisconsin Youth Risk Behavior Survey
(YRBS). Wisconsin: Wisconsin Department of Health and Family Services. PDF.
Benditt L, Engel E, Gavin M, Stransky E (2009). Addressing Health Disparities Affecting Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) Youth and Adults in Wisconsin. Workshop in Public Affairs. Prepared for the Wisconsin Department of Health Services, HIV/AIDS Program, Division of Public Health. Reports suicidality results (controlling for many variables) for GLB students compared to heterosexual students in the Wisconsin 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. The odds for GLB high school students having attempted suicide in the past year were 3.9-times greater than for heterosexual students. PDF Download.
| Wisconsin 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 'Sexual Orientation' Related Results |
|||
| Categories | Students Reporting Same-Sex Sex |
Students Reporting Only Opposite- Sex Sex | Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Have any long-term emotional or mental health problems like depression, anxiety, ADD/ADHD, eating disorders, or cutting |
38.3% | 17.9% | RR: 2.1 OR: 2.8 |
| Felt so sad or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a row during the past 12 months that they stopped doing some usual activities |
47.2% |
25.7% | RR: 1.9 OR: 2.6 |
| Seriously considered attempting suicide during the past 12 months |
41.4% |
16.6% | RR: 2.5 OR: 3.5 |
| Made a plan about how they would attempt suicide during the past 12 months |
31.1% |
10.8% | RR: 2.9 OR: 3.7 |
| Actually attempted suicide one or more times during the past 12 months |
25.2% |
7.5% | RR: 3.3 RR: 4.2 |
| Made a suicide attempt during the past 12 months that resulted in an injury, poisoning, or overdose that had to be treated by a doctor or nurse |
14.9% |
2.5% |
RR: 6.0 RR: 6.8 |
|
Data Source: Wisconsin Division of Public Health (2009). "The 2007 YRBS sample of 2,078 includes 111 same-sex, 1,181 het-sex, and 786 no-sex students. Same-sex respondents comprise 8% of students who have had sexual contact." Many "At Risk" behaviors are given but they are not in this data table. |
|||
Wisconsin Division of Public Health (2009). Wisconsin Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) 2007: Risk Behaviors and Factors of Youth Engaging in Same-Sex Sexual Behaviors. PDF.
2007 Wisconsin Youth Risk Behavior Survey (Word Download):
Sexual minority students were 3.7 times more at risk for having
attempted suicide in the past 12 months, compared to heterosexual
students. - Risk Behaviors and Factors of Youth Engaging in Same-Sex Sexual Behaviors (PDF Download):
One in four same-sex youth (7.5% het-sex youth) had a suicide attempt
in the previous 12 months. More than one in seven (15%) same-sex had a
suicide attempt in the previous 12 months serious enough that it
required medical attention, compared to 2.5% of het-sex youth, a
six-fold difference...
| Sexual Violence | ||||||||||
| Sex | Grade | Table Total | ||||||||
| Female | Male | 9th | 10th | 11th | 12th | |||||
| Have
you ever been threatened or hurt because someone thought you were gay, lesbian or bisexual |
Yes | 8 | 9 | 8 | 9 | 9 | 7 | 8 | ||
| No | 90 | 89 | 89 | 89 | 88 | 90 | 89 | |||
| Not sure | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 3 | |||
Information was not reported about the possible higher risk for suicide attempts of students who responded affirmatively to the question:
Have you ever been threatened or hurt because someone thought you were gay, lesbian, or bisexual?
| Sexual Violence | ||||||||||
| Sex | Grade | Table Total | ||||||||
| Female | Male | 9th | 10th | 11th | 12th | |||||
| Have
you ever been threatened or hurt because someone thought you were gay, lesbian or bisexual |
Yes | 3 | 6 | 4 | 5 | 3 | 6 | 4 | ||
| No | 95 | 90 | 93 | 93 | 94 | 89 | 93 | |||
| Not sure | 2 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 5 | 3 | |||
From PDF file "Weapons and Violence": As might be expected, there were also significant relationships between threats and feelings of safety. Students who reported feeling 'always' or 'usually' safe were significantly less likely to have reported being threatened or injured with a weapon on school property in the past 12 months. Similarly, students who felt unsafe at school were significantly more likely to have been hurt or threatened because someone thought they were gay, lesbian, or bisexual and to have been threatened or hurt because of their race. Similar patterns were found between having been threatened or injured with a weapon in the past 12 months and having been threatened or hurt because of one's race or perceived sexuality... Male students were twice as likely to report that they had been threatened or hurt because someone thought they were gay. lesbian, or bisexual.... However there were no significant differences between grade levels in the percentages of students reporting that they were threatened or hurt because of their race or because someone thought they were gay, lesbian, or bisexual.
Information was not reported about the possible higher risk for suicide attempts of students who responded affirmatively to the question:
Have you ever been threatened or hurt because someone thought you were gay, lesbian, or bisexual?
| Sexual Violence | ||||||||||
| Sex | Grade | Table Total | ||||||||
| Female | Male | 9th | 10th | 11th | 12th | |||||
| Have
you ever been threatened or hurt because someone thought you were gay, lesbian or bisexual |
Yes | 3 | 6 | 7 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | ||
| No | 91 | 88 | 85 | 93 | 90 | 91 | 90 | |||
| Not sure | 6 | 6 | 7 | 4 | 7 | 6 | 6 | |||
3% of females and 6% of males answered "yes", for a total of 4% of students. Some information related to this group of students is available in the Weapons and Violence N/A (Archive Link) section. Example: "Twenty-three percent of those who don't feel safe on the way to or from school [3% of students] reported having been threatened or hurt because someone thought they were gay, lesbian, or bisexual, compared to only four percent of those who "always" or "usually" felt safe [64% of students].
The Safe
Schools Coalition of WA - Trainer's Manual N/A (Archive Link) reports (at the end of the document)
that "sexual minority youth" in the 1997 Wisconsin survey were at higher
risk for "suicide attempts serious enough to have required treatment by
a health care professional." but this is not possible given that "sexual
orientation" information was not solicited. The information they may have
encountered could only apply the the group targeted for abuse resulting
from the assumption that they were gay, lesbian, or bisexual.
Students harassed on the basis of assumed homosexual orientation were reported to be, compared to students not harassed in such ways, more at risk for many behaviors such as:
1. Seriously Considered Suicide in Past 12 Months: 51.7% vs 23.4% .
2. Attempted Suicide and Had to Be Treated by Doctor or Nurse in Past 12 Months: 13.3% vs 3.3%.
3. Have Missed at Least One Day of School Because I Felt Unsafe in Past 30 Days: 16.7% vs 2.3%.
4. Usually Do Not Feel Safe From Physical Harm on My Way To or From School: 2.1% vs 13.3%.
5. Have Used Cocaine (powder, crack, or freebase) Ever: 23.3% vs 6.9%.
6. Have Been Pregnant or Gotten Someone Pregnant Ever: 15.0% vs 4.7%.
Data Source
(with more results): Eighty-Three
Thousand Youth, Table 5: http://www.safeschools-wa.org/quant_mh.html
N/A (Archive Link). See: - http://www.safeschools-wa.org/ N/A
(Archive Link, New Website) - http://www.safeschools-wa.org/83000youth.pdf N/A
(PDF Download of Document, Archive Link, New Link)
One question, however, asked the students whether they had been harassed in the previous 30 days and, if so, why. Two percent of the respondents said they had been because they were perceived to be gay, lesbian, or bisexual. These students were four times more likely to say that they attempted suicide than were their non-harassed peers (21% vs. 5%). Among those perceived to be gay, lesbian, or bisexual, harassed males were six times more likely than their non-harassed counterparts to attempt suicide (17% vs. 3%) while females were four times more likely (28% vs. 7%).The question asked (#24): - In the past 30 days, what were you harassed about? (If more than one reason, what was the most upsetting or offensive to you?)
Possible Answers: a. I was not harassed; b. Race or national origin; c. Unwanted sexual attention or comments; d. Perceived sexual orientation (gay/ lesbian/ bisexual); e. Physical disability; f. Other not listed; g. Don't know why I was harassed.
Note:
The question specified a "in the past 30 days" time frame - which would
predictable produce a lower incidence than not specifying a time frame
- as was done in the Seattle (1995) survey which produced an incidence
level of about 8%. Therefore, the Wisconsin group would likely represent
a majority of the adolescents regularly subjected to such abuse, as opposed
to maybe only occasionally and therefore more likely to have in the more
distant past, or more than 30 days before the survey questionnaire was
completed.
A more comprehensive
report on the data is located on a
separate web page. Table 1 (of 3) reproduced below:
|
Result Summary For Males & Females (Grades 9 to 12): Harassment Based on Perceived Homosexual Orientation of Individuals: Associations with Depression & Suicide Behaviors. |



| Oregon Healthy Teens Grade 11 Survey: 2006, 2007, 2008, Combined Attempted Suicide: Gay & Lesbian - Bisexual Adolescents |
|||
| Categories |
Gay / Lesbian |
Bisexual |
Hetero- sexual |
| Males, N = 15,537. % of Male Population |
183 1.18% |
278 1.79% |
15,076 97.03% |
| Females, N = 16,315 % of Female Population |
118 0.72% |
834 5.11% |
15,363 94.16% |
| Males & Females, N = 31,852 % of Male/Female Population |
301 0.94% |
1,112 3.49% |
30,439 95.56% |
| Attempted Suicide One or More Times: N, % Incidence |
59 19.60% |
245 22.03% |
1,280 4.21% |
| Odds Ratios (ORs), Calculated by Webpage Author Using Given Data |
4.2<5.6<7.4 95% CI |
5.5<6.4<7.5 95% CI |
Reference Category |
Data Source: Hatzenbuehler (2011)
|
|||
New York City 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey *
"Attempted Suicide" Results: GLBU vs. Heterosexual
Categories
Males
Females
%
G,B,U
vs %
Hetero
Odds
Ratios:
Unad-
justed 1
Odds
Ratios:
Adjusted 1
%
L,B,U
vs %
Hetero
Odds
Ratios:
Unad-
justed 1
Odds
Ratios:
Adjusted 1
Gay & Lesbian
? vs
?
6.2
(1.7-22.7)
?
? vs
?
0.9
(0.3-2.6)
?
Bisexual
Male & Female
? vs
?
12.8
(6.5-25.3)
?
? vs
?
5.3
(2.9-9.8)
?
Unsure
Male & Female
? vs
?
6.8
(3.3-13.9)
?
? vs
?
2.4
(1.1-5.4)
?
GBU (Male)
LBU (Female)
? vs
?
9.0
(5.3-15.3)
3.44
(1.88-6.32)
? vs
?
3.7
(2.4-5.9)
2.45
(1.31-4.56)
GLBU 2
Males & Females
Combined
Attempted Suicide Incidences
31% (GLBU) vs 8% (Heterosexual)
OR: 5.2
* "Responses from 8080 adolescents 14 years and older, who attended NYC
public high schools, were included in the analyses.The sample, which
was weighted to be representative of the total NYC public high school
population, was 51.0% female and primarily nonwhite (40.1% Hispanic,
36.0% black, 16.0% Asian/other, and 7.9% white)." Counts/Percentages
for Heterosexual, Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Unsure student populations
are not given. Counts/Percentages for Heterosexual, Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Unsure student "At Risk" behaviors are not given.
Note: Olshen et al. (2007)
conclude with: "Similar to prior studies (10-13) we found that
adolescent boys and girls who identified as gay, lesbian, bisexual, or
unsure vs those who identified as heterosexual were 3.4 and 2.5 times,
respectively, as likely to report at least 1 suicide attempt." This
statement is incorrect. For an analysis of the greater likelihood to
have attempted suicide, only the following "demongraphic" variables
should be used: Age or Grade Level (that are somewhat similar), and
Race/Ethnicity for the Male and the Female Analyses, carried out
separately. The above cited Odds Ratios "3.4 and 2.5" represent GBU & LBU remaining as Independent Predictors for "Attempting Suicide" after
controlling for numerous variables (The Infamous Battle of the
Variables!), many also being significant independent predictors after
controlling for all other variables, including "Sexual Orientation".
The Odds for GBU & LBU students being more at risk for Attempting
Suicide, compared to Heterosexual students would likely be 9 and 3.7 as
deternibed from the weighted counts.
2.
The noted percentages are given by NYC Health (2008).
They are likely based on weighted counts, meaning that they
reflect the accurate incidence percentages that would be expected to be
given in such a publication. On the basis of the percentages given, the
OR was calculated by the Webpage author and appears to be the weighted average of the Male and Female ORs given by Olshen et al. (2007). See Below the tabulated results from the data supplied by NYC Health (2008).
| New York City 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Grades 9 - 12 "Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Unsure" Suicidality Results |
|||
| Categories | GLBU Students |
Heterosexual Students | Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Felt so sad or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a row during the past 12 months that they stopped doing some usual activities |
55% |
31% | RR: 1.8 OR: 2.7 |
| Seriously considered attempting suicide during the past 12 months |
37% |
14% | RR: 2.6 OR: 3.6 |
| Made a plan about how they would attempt suicide during the past 12 months |
29% |
10% | RR: 2.9 OR: 3.7 |
| Actually attempted suicide one or more times during the past 12 months |
31% |
8% | RR: 3.9 RR: 5.2 |
| Made a suicide attempt during the past 12 months that resulted in an injury, poisoning, or overdose that had to be treated by a doctor or nurse |
9% |
2% |
RR: 4.5 RR: 4.8 |
|
Data Source: NYC Health (2008). "The 2009 YRBS sample of 2,430 includes 138 same-sex, 1,255 het-sex and 1,027 no-sex students. There are also 10 missing data points for students who did not respond to the respective question. Same-sex respondents comprise 10% (n=138) of the sexually active respondents, an increase from 8% found in the YRBS 2007 analysis." Many "At Risk" behaviors are given but they are not in this data table. |
|||
Olshen E, McVeigh KH, Wunsch-Hitzig RA, Rickert VI (2007). Dating violence, sexual assault, and suicide attempts among urban [New York City] teenagers. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 161(6): 539-45. Abstract. PDF. In the past 12 months, compared to heterosexual youth, the odds of
having attempted suicide were greater for Gay, Bisexual and Unsure male
students: 6.2, 12.8, 6.9, respectively, or 9.0 for the combined 3
groups (3.4, adjusted with control variables).
The study below
reveals that, given the YRBS combined data sets - 2005 & 2007 - a
more detailed anaysis of the New York City GLBU adolescent "At Risk"
situation can be done, including for those who report having engaged in
same-sex-sex but identify as heterosexual:
San Francisco 2009 Youth Risk Behavior Surveys
High Schools & Middle Schools
Suicidality Results: GLBU vs. Heterosexual
Categories
High Schools 1
Middle Schools 2
GLBU
Hetero-
sexual
Risk Ratio
Odds Ratio 3
GLBU
Hetero-
sexual
Risk Ratio
Odds Ratio 3
Seriously
Considered Suicide
38%
10%
RR: 3.8
OR: 5.5
56%
21%
RR: 2.7
OR: 4.8
Made Suicide
Plan
31%
10%
RR: 3.1
OR: 4.0
43%
14%
RR: 3.1
OR: 4.6
Attempted
Suicde
23%
8%
RR: 2.9
OR: 3.4
34%
7%
RR: 4.9
OR: 6.8
1. YRBS
completed by 2,145 high schools (9-12) students and the results are
representative all of all SFUSD HS students. GLBU = 10% = >
1,500 students in the school system.
2. YRBS completed by
2,417 middle schools (6 - 8) students and the results are
representative all of all SFUSD MS students. GLBU = 12% = about 1,200
students in the school system.
3. RRs & ORs Calculated by Webpage Author wWith the Given Data and Using 2-way Contingency Table Analysis. Given the N's involved, the statistical significances would be about p < 0.001.
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2003, 05, 07, 09, 2011 Boulder County, Colorado - Suicidality Related Variables |
|||||
| Risk Behaviors Statistical Significance, p < 0.05 - No Overlapping CIs (Confidence Intervals) |
Incidence %, GLBU (Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Unsure) vs. Incidence % Heterosexual. Risk Ratio [__] * - Odds Ratio (__) * |
||||
| 2003 |
2005 |
2007 |
2009 | 2011 |
|
| Felt sad or hopeless almost every day for 2 weeks or more during the 12 months preceding the survey |
49.5% vs 24.2% [2.0] (3.1) |
53.7% vs. 22.8% [2.4] (3.9) |
53.2% vs. 25.4% [2.1] (3.3) |
52.2% vs 22.3% [2.3] (3.8) | 55.1% vs. 22.3% [2.5] (4.3) |
| Seriously considered attempting suicide one or more times during the 12 months preceding the survey |
63.3% vs. 16.8% [3.8] (8.5) |
45.9% vs. 15.0% [3.1] (4.8) |
45.7% vs. 14.3% [3.2] (5.0) |
35.3% vs. 11.1% [3.2] (4.4) | 43.9% vs. 11.3% [3.9] (6.1) |
| Planned Suicide, Past 12 Months |
Not Given |
Not Given |
Not Given |
28.9% vs. 9.2% [3.1] (4.0) | 41.4% vs. 13.4% [3.1] (4.6) |
| Attempted suicide one or more times during the 12 months preceding the survey | 44.0% vs. 13.5% [3.3] (5.0) |
23.6% vs. 6.3% [3.7] (4.6) |
23.0% vs. 7.2% [3.2] (3.8) |
20.3% vs. 4.2% [4.8] (5.8) | 31.8% vs. 4.2% [7.6] (10.6) |
| Suicide attempt resulted in medical treatment | Not Given |
Not Given |
Not Given |
4.1% vs. 1.8% [2.3] (2.3) | 12.4% vs. 1.7% [7.3] (8.2) |
| Intentionally Self-Injured |
Not Given |
55.4% vs. 17.2% [3.2] (6.0) |
38.9% vs. 17.6% [2.2] (3.0) |
51.0% vs. 16.1% [3.2] (5.4) | 61.1% vs. 17..1% [3.6] (7.6) |
| Data Sources: 2003 YRBS Results. - 2005 YRBS Results. - 2007 YRBS Results. 2009 YRBS Results. 2011 YRBS Results. * RRs & ORs Calculated by Webpage Author Using: 2-way Contingency Table Analysis. |
|||||
Boulder County Public Health (2012). 2011 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Boulder & St. Vrain School Districts. PDF Download. Download Page.
Boulder County Public Health (2010). 2009 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Boulder & St. Vrain School
Districts. PDF Download. Download Page. PDF Download. Download Page. Archive Link.
Boulder County Public Health (2008). 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Boulder & St. Vrain School Districts. PDF Download. Download Page. PDF Download. Download Page. Additional Information: PDF Download. Archive Link.
Boulder County Public Health (2006). 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Boulder & St. Vrain School Districts. PDF Download. Download Page. PDF Download. Download Page. Archive Link.
Boulder County Public Health (2005). '2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: Boulder & St. Vrain School Districts' Section 2: Results by Sexual Orientation (countywide data). Download Page. Downloads: http://www.co.boulder.co.us/health/HP/pdfs/SVVSDSection2.pdf - http://www.co.boulder.co.us/health/commhlth/safeZone/pdf/YRBSlgYouth.pdf . Boulder County Public Health (2004). The Results... 2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Boulder County, Colorado: Section 2… Results by Sexual Orientation (countywide data). PDF N/A. Download Page N/A Archive Link. or Boulder County Public Health (2004). The Results... 2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Boulder County, Colorado. PDF N/A New Link. New Download Page. Download Page N/A Archive Link. Access Page N/A Archive Link.
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2003 Boulder, Colorado - Part 1 |
|||
| Risk Behavior |
GLB / Unsure (95% CI) |
Hetero- sexual (95% CI) |
Total (95% CI) |
| Felt sad or hopeless almost every day for 2 weeks or more during the 12 months preceding the survey |
49.5% (43.8-55.2) |
24.1% (23.0-25.2) |
25.5% (24.4-26.6) |
| Seriously considered attempting suicide one or more times during the 12 months preceding the survey |
63.3% (57.9-68.7) |
16.8% (15.9-17.8) |
19.5% (18.5-20.5) |
| Attempted suicide one or more times during the 12 months preceding the survey |
44.0% (38.3-49.7) |
13.5% (12.6-14.4) |
15.2% (14.3-16.2) |
| Harassed
because someone thought they were gay, lesbian, or bisexual at school
(or on the way to or from school) during the 12 months preceding the
survey |
33.3% (27.8-38.7) |
4.9% (4.3-5.5) |
6.5% (5.9-7.2) |
| Harassed because of race or ethnic origin at school (or on the way to or from school) during the 12 months preceding the survey |
22.4% (17.8-27.0) |
6.1% (5.5-6.8) |
7.1% (6.4-7.7) |
| Harassed at school (or on the way to or from school) during the 12 months preceding the survey |
59.9% (54.3-65.6) |
30.9% (29.7-32.1) |
32.6% (31.4-33.7) |
| Smoked cigarettes on school property One or more times during the 30 days preceding the survey |
29.1% (24.2-34.1) |
7.7% (7.0-8.4) |
8.9% (8.2-9.6) |
| Drank alcohol on school property One or more times during the 30 days preceding the survey |
22.9% (18.3-27.5) |
4.9% (4.4-5.4) |
5.9% (5.4-6.5) |
| Used marijuana on school property One or more times during the 30 days preceding the survey |
20.8% (16.5-25.1) |
6.3% (5.7-6.9) |
7.1% (6.5-7.7) |
| Alcohol or drugs at last intercourse among currently sexually active students |
48.2% (40.4-55.9) |
20.6% (18.5-22.7) |
23.2% (21.1-25.3) |
| Ever tried any form of cocaine (e.g., “powder,” “crack,” or “freebase”) |
28.9% (23.9-33.8) |
9.0% (8.3-9.7) |
10.1% (9.4-10.9) |
| Ever sniffed glue or breathed the contents of aerosol spray cans or inhaled any paints or sprays to get high |
34.4% (28.8-40.0) |
9.1% (8.4-9.8) |
10.6% (9.8-11.3) |
| Ever used ecstasy |
27.3% (22.3-32.3) |
5.3% (4.8-5.8) |
6.5% (5.9-7.1) |
| Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2003 Boulder, Colorado - Part 2 |
|||
| Risk Behavior | GLB / Unsure (95% CI) |
Hetero- sexual (95% CI) |
Total (95% CI) |
| Ever forced to have sexual intercourse |
35.1% (29.7-40.5) |
4.2% (3.7-4.7) |
6.0% (5.4-6.6) |
| Ever touched sexually when they did not want to be touched other than forced sexual intercourse |
53.4% (47.7-59.0) |
16.6% (15.7-17.6) |
18.7% (17.7-19.7) |
| Hurt by boyfriend/girlfriend: Hit, slapped, or physically hurt on purpose during the 12 months preceding the survey |
20.5% (16.1-24.9) |
6.4% (5.8-7.0) |
7.2% (6.6-7.9) |
| Ever had sexual intercourse |
57.7% (51.9-63.5) |
32.9% (31.7-34.0) |
34.3% (33.2-35.4) |
| Currently sexually active: one or more times during the 30 days preceding the survey |
43.6% (37.9-49.2) |
24.1% (23.0-25.1) |
25.2% (24.1-26.2) |
| Four or more sex partners during lifetime |
32.0% (26.8-37.2) |
7.4% (6.7-8.0) |
8.7% (8.0-9.4) |
| Have been pregnant or gotten someone pregnant |
11.2% (7.6-14.7) |
1.9% (1.6-2.3) |
2.4% (2.0-2.8) |
| First sexual intercourse at 13 years of age or younger |
28.5% (23.5-33.5) |
6.7% (6.0-7.3) |
7.9% |
| Felt too unsafe to go to school on one or more of the 30 days preceding the survey |
22.9% (18.0-27.8) |
3.0% (2.5-3.4) |
4.1% (3.6-4.6) |
| Feel unsafe or afraid at school most or all of the time |
10.1% (7.6-12.6) |
1.3% (1.0-1.7) |
1.8% (1.5-2.2) |
| Carried a weapon on one or more of the 30 days preceding the survey |
32.1% (26.7-37.4) |
12.8% (11.9-13.6) |
13.8% (12.9-14.7) |
| Carried a gun on one or more of the 30 days preceding the survey |
11.6% (7.9-15.2) |
3.0% (2.6-3.5) |
3.5% (3.0-4.0) |
| In a physical fight one or more times during the 12 months preceding the survey |
44.3% (38.7-49.8) |
24.2% (23.1-25.3) |
25.3% (24.2-26.4) |
| In a physical fight on school property one or more times during the 12 months preceding the survey |
23.1% (18.0-28.3) |
11.3% (10.4-12.1) |
11.9% (11.1-12.8) |
| Carried a weapon on school property on one or more of the 30 days preceding the survey |
22.3% (17.6-27.0) |
5.0% (4.4-5.5) |
5.9% (5.3-6.5) |
| Threatened or injured with a weapon on school property one or more times in the past 12 months |
16.0% (11.9-20.1) |
4.6% (4.1-5.2) |
5.3% (4.7-5.8) |
| Smoked cigarettes or cigars or used chewing tobacco on one or more of the 30 days preceding the survey |
54.4% (48.8-60.1) |
28.8% (27.7-30.0) |
30.3% (29.1-31.4) |
| Illinois Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2011 |
|||
| Categories | GLBU | Heterosexual |
Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Depression, Past Year |
47.2% |
26.0% |
RR: 1.8 OR: 2.5 |
| Suicidal Thoughts, Past Year |
31.5% |
12.7% |
RR: 2.5 OR: 3.2 |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
21.3% |
6.6% |
RR: 3.2 OR: 3.8 |
Data Source: Steinhausen et al. (2012).
|
|||
| Illinois Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2009 |
|||
| Categories | GLBU | Heterosexual |
Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Depression, Past Year |
54.7% |
25.5% |
RR: 2.1 OR: 3.5 |
| Suicidal Thoughts, Past Year |
41.8% |
12.8% |
RR: 3.3 OR: 4.9 |
| Making a Suicide Plan, Past Year |
31.0% |
10.0% |
RR: 3.1 OR: 4.0 |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
29.7% |
7.2% |
RR: 4.1 OR: 5.4 |
| Harassed Because Assumed to be GLB, Past Year |
29.0% |
6.5% |
RR: 4.5 OR: 5.9 |
Data Source: Smith et al. (2010).
|
|||
| Illinois Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2009 |
|||
| Categories | GLB or Had Same-Sex Sex - 8.8% |
Heterosexual No Same-Sex Sex - ? % Maybe 90% |
Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Depression, Past Year |
54.3% |
25.5% |
RR: 2.1 OR: 3.3 |
| Suicidal Thoughts, Past Year |
45.8% |
13.5% |
RR: 3.4 OR: 5.4 |
| Making a Suicide Plan, Past Year |
35.3% |
10.5% |
RR: 3.4 OR: 4.7 |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
33.6% |
6.5% |
RR: 5.2 OR: 7.3 |
Data Source: Illinois Department of Public Health (2010).
|
|||
"[D]data from the 2009 and 2011 combined Chicago Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) was also utilized... In the YRBS [2009 & 2011, combined], 26.3% of LGBT students reported attempting suicide in the past 12 months, compared to 12.7% of heterosexual students.' Mustanski et al. (2012): pp. 6 & 9.
Mustanski BS, Clifford A, Bigelow L, Andrews K, Birkett MA, Ashbeck A, Fisher K (2012). A Healthy Chicago for LGBT Youth: An IMPACT Program White Paper on Health Disparities in Chicago’s LGBT Youth. Chicago, IL: The IMPACT Program at Northwestern University. Download Page.
| Chicago Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2005 |
|||||
| Categories | Gay Lesbian 1.6% |
Bi- sexual 2.5% |
GLB 4.1% * |
Hetero- sexual 93.4% |
Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Depression, Past Year |
53.8% |
57.9% |
56.3% |
27.8% |
RR: 2.0 OR: 3.2 |
| Making a Suicide Plan, Past Year |
33.3% |
35.0% |
34.2% |
9.7% |
RR: 3.5 OR: 4.8 |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
27.3% |
33.3% |
30.0% |
7.5% |
RR: 4.0 OR: 5.3 |
| Being Threatened at School, Past Year |
16.7% |
20.0% |
18.7% |
8.1% |
RR: 2.3 OR: 2.6 |
| Treated for Fight Related Injury, Past Year |
23.1% |
10.5% |
15.4% |
4.2% |
RR: 3.7 OR: 4.2 |
| Sexual Assault, Past Year |
16.7% |
36.8% |
29.0% |
8.0% |
RR: 3.6 OR: 4.7 |
Data Source: Sullivan (2007b)
|
|||||
Sullivan, Shannon (2007b). Chicago
Public High Schools: Differential Risk Factors for Lesbian, Gay,
Bisexual Identified Students: 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results. Chicago: The Illinois Safe Schools Alliance. PDF. Gay/Lesbian & Bisexual population percentages given by Horn & Szalacha (2007).
Horn SS, Szalacha LA (2007).
Chicago Public Schools Youth Risk Behavior Survey 2005: Executive
Summary. Chicago: Board of Education of the City of Chicago. PDF.
"The majority of students in the sample identified as Heterosexual (93.4%) with a minority of students identifying as Lesbian or Gay (1.6%), Bisexual (2.5%), or unsure
of their sexual identity (2.5%)..."
"As with sexual identity, the majority of students in the sample engaged in sexual activity with opposite-sex peers (95.2%), with small numbers of students reporting exclusively same-sex sexual behavior (2.5%) and sexual behavior with members of both sexes (2.3%). Of the students who reported behavior other than heterosexual sex, females (3.8%) were more likely to have sexual partners of both sexes, while males (3.7%) were more likely to report exclusively same-sex sexual behavior than females. The number of students reporting exclusively same-sex behavior or bisexual behavior increased with age."
| Chicago Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results: 2003 |
||||
| Categories | GLB + Same-Sex Sex - 8.5% |
GLB 6.3% |
All Others 93.7% |
Risk Ratio Odds Ratio |
| Depression, Past Year |
Not Given |
53% |
31% |
RR: 1.7 OR: 2.5 |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
Not Given |
32% |
11% |
RR: 2.9 OR: 3.8 |
| Missing School Because They Felt Unsafe. Past Year |
Not Given |
33% |
11% |
RR: 3.0 OR: 4.0 |
| Being in a Fight at School, Past Year |
Not Given |
32% |
17% |
RR: 1.9 OR: 2.3 |
| Sexual Assault, Past Year |
Not Given |
26% |
8% |
RR: 3.3 OR: 4.0 |
Data Source: Sullivan (2007a)
|
||||
Sullivan, Shannon (2007). Chicago Public High Schools: Differential Risk Factors for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual Identified Students: 2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results. Chicago: The Illinois Safe Schools Alliance. PDF.
A 2002 Re-Evaluation of Massachusetts 1995/97 & Vermont 1995/97 Youth Risk Behavior Surveys: Bisexually Active Adolescents Most At Risk.
Robin L, Brener ND, Donahue SF, Hack T, Hale K, Goodenow C (2002). Associations between health risk behaviors and opposite-, same-, and both-sex sexual partners in representative samples of Vermont and Massachusetts high school. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 156(4): 349-55. (PubMed Abstract) (Full Text)
From this paper, the results of 4 surveys are given: 2 from Vermont, and 2 from Massachusetts. The two surveys from Vermont (1995 & 1997 Youth Risk Behavior Survey) were combined to form one data set, and the two survey from Massachusetts (1995 & 1997 Youth Risk Behavior Survey) were combined to form another data set, and results were presented for "Vermont Students" and "Massachusetts Students" from Grades 9 to 12 (High School) as follows for having attempted suicide in the past year:
Percent Attempting Suicide "In the Past Year" (In square brackets [--]: % with suicide attempt associated with having received medical care) for students in 3 categories: (1) Those reporting only opposite sex sexual partners, (2) those reporting only same-sex sexual partner, and (3) those reporting sexual partners of both sexes:
Vermont Students
Those With Only Opposite-Sex Sex
Partners (n = 6873) - % attempting suicide = 11.9% [4.5%]
Those With Only Same-Sex Sex partners
(n = 249) - % attempting suicide = 16.5% [5.6%]
Those With Sex Partners of Both
Sexes (n = 336) - % attempting suicide = 43.5% [26.8%]
Massachusetts Students
Those With Only Opposite-Sex Sex
Partners (n = 3948) - % attempting suicide = 12.4% [4.5%]
Those With Only Same-Sex Sex partners
(n = 106) - % attempting suicide = 18.5% [7.8%]
Those With Sex Partners of Both
Sexes (n = 122) - % attempting suicide = 52.2% [31.6%]
Notes:
1. The above excludes students who
are not reporting having had sexual intercourse in their lifetime. Suicide
attempts incidences are lower for students who are not sexually active.
2. There are more student who are
bisexually active than students who are only homosexually active - in terms
of having sexual partners.
3. Bisexually active students are
at the greatest risk for having attempted suicide in the past year. They
are also at greater relative risk for suicide attempts associated with
having received medical care. Generally, these would be the most serious
suicide attempts, but not always.
4. Bisexually active students are
also more at risk for a number of other problems. See Abstract.
The information presented above is
from Table 2, page 252.
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Self-Identification American States That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * Gay / Lesbian vs. Heterosexual Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
|||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
Gay / Lesbian (n = 133, 1.3%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 9,801, 93.5%) |
Gay / Lesbian (n = 186, 1.2%) vs. Heterosexual (n =9,513, 93.3%) |
Gay / Lesbian (n = 196, 1.2%) vs. Heterosexual (n =15,780, 93.6%) |
Gay / Lesbian (n = 91, 1.7%) vs. Heterosexual (n =4,836, 90.7%) | Vermont Gay / Lesbian (n = 264, 1.0%) vs. Heterosexual (n =21,466, 93.0%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
10.9% RR: 3.2, OR: 4.5 |
10.1% RR: 2.9, OR: 3.7 |
13.2% RR: 3.3, OR: 5.0 |
9.9% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.3 | N/A |
|
Planned |
8.5% RR: 4.3, OR: 6.3 |
15.7% RR: 2.6, OR: 3.3 |
10.7% RR: 3.5, OR: 4.9 |
9.6% RR: 1.6, OR: 1.8 | 31.7% vs. 8.0% RR: 4.0, OR: 5.3 |
|
Suicide |
5.7% RR: 4.7, OR: 6.1 |
5.1% RR: 4.4, OR: 5.3 |
6.4% RR: 5.2, OR: 7.2 |
6.3% RR: 4.1, OR: 5.2 | 25.4% vs. 3.8% RR: 6.7, OR: 8.6 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
1.5% RR: 8.6, OR: 9.7 |
|
2.2% RR: 6.9, OR: 7.9 |
3.9% RR: 4.3, OR: 4.7 | 13.4% vs. 1.1% RR: 12.2, OR: 13.9 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
|||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Self-Identification American States That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * Bisexual vs. Heterosexual Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
|||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
Bisexual (n = 396, 3.8%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 9,801, 93.5%) |
Bisexual (n = 432, 3.4%) vs. Heterosexual (n =9,513, 93.3%) |
Bisexual (n = 536, 3.2%) vs. Heterosexual (n =15,780, 93.6%) |
Bisexual (n = 287, 5.2%) vs. Heterosexual (n =4,836, 90.7%) | Vermont Bisexual (n = 941, 3.7%) vs. Heterosexual (n =21,466, 93.0%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
10.9% RR: 4.2, OR: 7.0 |
10.1% RR: 3.6, OR: 5.1 |
13.2% RR: 3.5, OR: 5.6 |
9.9% RR: 4.1, OR: 6.1 | N/A |
|
Planned |
8.5% RR: 4.0, OR: 5.5 |
15.7% RR: 2.4, OR: 3.1 |
10.7% RR: 3.4, OR: 4.8 |
9.6% RR: 3.7, OR: 5.2 | 37.7% vs. 8.0% RR: 4.7, OR: 7.0 |
|
Suicide |
5.7% RR: 5.2, OR: 6.9 |
5.1% RR: 4.0, OR: 4.8 |
6.4% RR: 4.4, OR: 5.7 |
6.3% RR: 5.1, OR: 7.0 | 26.7% vs. 3.8% RR: 7.0, OR: 9.2 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
1.5% RR: 7.5, OR: 8.4 |
0.9% RR: 17.7, OR: 20.8 |
2.2% RR: 5.1, OR: 5.6 |
3.9% RR: 2.6, OR: 2.8 | 10.8% vs. 1.1% RR: 9.8, OR: 10.9 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
|||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Self-Identification American States That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * "Not Sure" vs. Heterosexual Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
|||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
"Not Sure" (n = 136, 1.3%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 9,801, 93.5%) |
"Not Sure" (n = 324, 2.1%) vs. Heterosexual (n =9,513, 93.3%) |
"Not Sure" (n = 377, 2.1%) vs. Heterosexual (n =15,780, 93.6%) |
"Not Sure" (n = 137, 2.5%) vs. Heterosexual (n =4,836, 90.7%) | Vermont "Not Sure" (n = 610, 2.3%) vs. Heterosexual (n =21,466, 93.0%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
10.9% RR: 3.7, OR: 5.5 |
10.1% RR: 2.7, OR: 3.4 |
13.2% RR: 2.2, OR: 2.7 |
9.9% RR: 1.9, OR: 2.1 | N/A |
|
Planned |
8.5% RR: 3.5, OR: 4.6 |
15.7% RR: 2.0, OR: 2.5 |
10.7% RR: 2.3, OR: 2.7 |
9.6% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.3 | 22.4% vs. 8.0% RR: 2.8, OR: 3.3 |
|
Suicide |
5.7% RR: 4.7, OR: 6.0 |
5.1% RR: 4.1, OR: 4.9 |
6.4% RR: 3.3, OR: 3.9 |
6.3% RR: 2.6, OR: 3.8 | 16.6% vs. 3.8% RR: 4.4, OR: 5.0 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
1.5% RR: 8.0, OR: 8.9 |
0.9% RR: 18.7, OR: 22.2 |
2.2% RR: 4.6, OR: 5.0 |
3.9% RR: 1.4, OR: 1.5 ns | 10.8% vs. 1.1% RR: 7.6, OR: 8.2 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
|||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Self-Identification American Cities That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * Gay / Lesbian vs. Heterosexual Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
Gay / Lesbian (n = 79, 1.1%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 6,792, 93.4%) |
Gay / Lesbian (n = 102, 2.6%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 3,534, 90.5%) |
Gay / Lesbian (n = 468, 1.4%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 24,553, 91.2%) | San Francisco Gay / Lesbian (n = 121, 1.4%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 7,546, 90.3%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
11.7% RR: 1.7, OR: 1.9 ns |
11.9% RR: 2.5, OR: 3.2 |
11.8% RR: 2.5, OR: 3.1 | 18.8% vs.
12.1% RR: 1.5, OR: 1.7 ns |
|
Planned |
10.7% RR: 1.9, OR: 2.1 |
9.4% RR: 2.0, OR: 2.2 |
10.0% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.4 | 20.6% vs. 11.9% RR: 1.7, OR: 1.9 |
|
Suicide |
8.9% RR: 3.8, OR: 5.3 |
9.6% RR: 3.4, OR: 4.5 |
7.2% RR: 3.0, OR: 3.5 | 15.1% vs. 7.3% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.3 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
3.0% RR: 5.2, OR: 6.0 |
3.4% RR: 2.9, OR: 3.1 |
2.1% RR: 3.7, OR: 3.9 | 7.0% vs. 2.2% RR: 3.2, OR: 3.3 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Self-Identification American Cities That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * Bisexual vs. Heterosexual Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
Bisexual (n = 215, 2.9%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 6,792, 93.4%) |
Bisexual (n = 148, 3.7%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 3,534, 90.5%) |
Bisexual (n = 1,353, 4.3%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 24,553, 91.2%) | San Francisco Bisexual (n = 296, 3.7%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 7,546, 90.3%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
11.7% RR: 3.5, OR: 5.2 |
11.9% RR: 3.0, OR: 4.1 |
11.8% RR: 3.4, OR: 5.1 | 38.8% vs.
12.1% RR: 3.2, OR: 4.6 |
|
Planned |
10.7% RR: 3.2, OR: 4.4 |
9.4% RR: 3.2, OR: 4.1 |
10.0% RR: 3.5, OR: 4.8 | 35.8% vs. 11.9% RR: 3.0, OR: 4.1 |
|
Suicide |
8.9% RR: 3.2, OR: 4.2 |
9.6% RR: 2.7, OR: 3.4 |
7.2% RR: 4.2, OR: 5.7 | 24.7% vs. 7.3% RR: 3.4, OR: 4.2 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
3.0% RR: 4.3, OR: 4.8 |
3.4% RR: 3.3, OR: 3.6 |
2.1% RR: 3.9, OR: 4.2 | 12.1% vs. 2.2% RR: 5.5, OR: 6.1 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Self-Identification American Cities That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * "Not Sure" vs. Heterosexual Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
"Not Sure" (n = 184, 2.5%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 6,792, 93.4%) |
"Not Sure" (n = 115, 3.2%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 3,534, 90.5%) |
"Not Sure" (n = 786, 3.2%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 24,553, 91.2%) | San Francisco "Not Sure" (n = 368, 4.7%) vs. Heterosexual (n = 7,546, 90.3%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
11.7% RR: 1.7, OR: 1.9 |
11.9% RR: 1.8, OR: 2.0 |
11.8% RR: 2.2, OR: 2.7 | 17.5% vs.
12.1% RR: 1.4, OR: 1.5 |
|
Planned |
10.7% RR: 1.9, OR: 2.1 |
9.4% RR: 2.2, OR: 2.5 |
10.0% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.3 | 17.8% vs. 11.9% RR: 1.5, OR: 1.6 |
|
Suicide |
8.9% RR: 2.4, OR: 2.8 |
9.6% RR: 1.9, OR: 2.1 |
7.2% RR: 2.5, OR: 2.9 | 13.0% vs. 7.3% RR: 1.8, OR: 1.9 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
3.0% RR: 3.4, OR: 3.7 |
3.4% RR: 2.0, OR: 2.1 ns |
2.1% RR: 3.2, OR: 3.3 | 4.4% vs. 2.2% RR: 2.0, OR: 2.0 ns |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Sex of Sex Partner(s) American States That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * "Only Same-Sex Sex Partner(s)" (OSSSP) vs. "Only Opposite-Sex Sex Partner(s)" (OOSSP) Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
|||||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
OSSSP (n = 104, 2.5%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,229, 52.9%) |
Del. OSSSP (n = 100, 1.0%) vs. OOSSP (n = 5,497, 53.6%) |
Maine OSSSP (n = 137, 2.4%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,668, 51.7%) |
Mass. OSSSP (n = 340, 2.1%) vs. OOSSP (n = 8,634, 53.3%) |
OSSSP (n = 159, 2.7%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,915, 56.0%) |
OSSSP (n = 246, 0.7%) vs. OOSSP (n = 13,638, 39.0%) | Wis. OSSSP (n = 82, 1.9%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,436, 54.7%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
14.4% RR: 1.5, OR: 1.7 ns |
27.8% vs.
13.7% RR: 2.0, OR: 2.4 |
19.7% vs.
15.9% RR: 1.2, OR: 1.3 ns |
25.3% vs.
16.4% RR: 1.5, OR: 1.7 |
12.4% RR: 1.6, OR: 1.7 |
---% RR: ---, OR: --- | 30.8% vs.
15.6% RR: 2.0, OR: 2.4 |
|
Planned |
9.8% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.4 |
28.2% vs.
10.6% RR: 2.7, OR: 3.3 |
16.9% vs.
14.3% RR: 1.2, OR: 1.2 ns |
19.2% vs.
13.2% RR: 1.4, OR: 1.6 |
10.9% RR: 1.8, OR: 2.0 |
14.1% RR: 2.3, OR: 2.9 | 24.9% vs. 10.7% RR: 2.3, OR: 2.8 |
|
Suicide |
8.2% RR: 2.4, OR: 2.7 |
19.0% vs.
8.0% RR: 2.4, OR: 2.7 |
13.1% vs.
7.7% RR: 1.7, OR: 1.8 ns |
21.1% vs.
8.5% RR: 2.5, OR: 2.9 |
8.2% RR: 2.0, OR: 2.2 |
8.3% RR: 2.5, OR: 2.8 | 19.8% vs. 6.7% RR: 2.9, OR: 3.4 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
3.0% RR: 1.1, OR: 1.1 ns |
8.4% vs.
2.6% RR: 3.2, OR: 3.4 |
4.2% vs.
2.7% RR: 1.6, OR: 1.6 ns |
8.5% vs.
3.1% RR: 2.7, OR: 2.9 |
3.6% RR: 3.2, OR: 3.5 |
2.9% RR: 3.2, OR: 3.4 | 8.1% vs. 2.1% RR: 3.9, OR: 4.1 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
|||||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Sex of Sex Partner(s) American States That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * "Both-Sex Sex Partners" (BSSP) vs. "Only Opposite-Sex Sex Partner(s)" (OOSSP) Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
|||||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
BSSP (n = 215, 4.8%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,229, 52.9%) |
Del. BSSP (n = 293, 2.8%) vs. OOSSP (n = 5,497, 53.6%) |
Maine BSSP (n = 178, 3.0%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,668, 51.7%) |
Mass. BSSP (n = 563, 3.4%) vs. OOSSP (n = 8,634, 53.3%) |
BSSP (n = 258, 4.9%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,915, 56.0%) |
BSSP (n = 827, 2.0%) vs. OOSSP (n = 13,638, 39.0%) | Wis. BSSP (n = 167, 3.6%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,436, 54.7%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
14.4% RR: 3.0, OR: 4.5 |
44.7% vs.
13.7% RR: 3.3, OR: 5.1 |
44.3% vs.
15.9% RR: 2.8, OR: 4.2 |
46.4% vs.
16.4% RR: 2.8, OR: 4.4 |
12.4% RR: 3.1, OR: 4.3 |
---% RR: ---, OR: --- | 45.6% vs.
15.6% RR: 2.9, OR: 4.5 |
|
Planned |
9.8% RR: 3.8, OR: 5.4 |
35.3% vs.
10.6% RR: 3.3, OR: 4.6 |
35.4% vs.
14.3% RR: 2.5, OR: 3.3 |
37.9% vs.
13.2% RR: 2.9, OR: 4.0 |
10.9% RR: 3.3, OR: 4.6 |
14.1% RR: 3.2, OR: 5.1 | 35.2% vs. 10.7% RR: 3.3, OR: 4.5 |
|
Suicide |
8.2% RR: 3.6, OR: 4.7 |
35.7% vs.
8.0% RR: 3.5, OR: 6.4 |
28.9% vs.
7.7% RR: 3.7, OR: 4.9 |
30.7% vs.
8.5% RR: 3.6, OR: 4.8 |
8.2% RR: 3.6, OR: 4.8 |
8.3% RR: 4.9, OR: 7.6 | 27.7% vs. 6.7% RR: 4.1, OR: 5.3 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
3.0% RR: 4.3, OR: 4.7 |
15.6% vs.
2.6% RR: 6.0, OR: 6.0 |
15.9% vs.
2.7% RR: 5.9, OR: 6.8 |
13.5% vs.
3.1% RR: 4.3, OR: 4.9 |
3.6% RR: 2.3, OR: 2.4 ns |
2.9% RR: 7.5, OR: 9.4 | 14.7% vs. 2.1% RR: 7.0, OR: 8.0 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
|||||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Sex of Sex Partner(s) American Cities That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * "Only Same-Sex Sex Partner(s)" (OSSSP) vs. "Only Opposite-Sex Sex Partner(s)" (OOSSP) Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
|||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
OSSSP (n = 183, 2.7%) vs. OOSSP (n = 3,834, 57.3%) |
Chicago OSSSP (n = 119, 3.2%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,195, 56.5%) |
Milwaukee OSSSP (n = 133, 3.9%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,145, 60.9%) |
New York OSSSP (n = 743, 2.5%) vs. OOSSP (n = 13,815, 49.3%) |
OSSSP (n = 83, 1.7%) vs. OOSSP (n = 1,904, 37.2%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
11.7% RR: 1.5, OR: 1.6 |
27.5% vs.
12.8% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.6 |
17.3% vs.
11.8% RR: 1.5, OR: 1.6 |
27.5% vs.
14.3% RR: 1.9, OR: 2.3 |
23.6% RR: 1.9, OR: 2.7 |
|
Planned |
11.1% RR: 1.8, OR: 1.9 |
11.4% vs.
10.5% RR: 1.1, OR: 1.1 ns |
19.4% vs.
10.5% RR: 1.8, OR: 2.0 |
19.2% vs.
12.1% RR: 1.61, OR: 1/7 |
18.7% RR: 1.7, OR: 2.0 |
|
Suicide |
9.6% RR: 2.4, OR: 2.8 |
23.3% vs.
11.2% RR: 2.1, OR: 2.4 |
15.8% vs.
10.6% RR: 1.5, OR: 1.6 |
18.7% vs.
9.6% RR: 1.9, OR: 2.2 |
14.4% RR: 1.8, OR: 2.1 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
3.3% RR: 2.4, OR: 2.5 ns |
6.5% vs.
4.3% RR: 1.5, OR:1.5 ns |
5.3% vs.
4.2% RR: 1.3, OR: 1.3 ns |
6.6% vs.
2.7% RR: 2.4, OR: 2.5 |
4.6% RR: 1.4, OR: 1.6 ns |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
|||||
|
Youth Risk Behaviour Survey Results Based on Sex of Sex Partner(s) American Cities That Solicited Related Data in 2001-2009 Surveys, Combined * "Both-Sex Sex Partner(s)" (BSSP) vs. "Only Opposite-Sex Sex Partner(s)" (OOSSP) Incidences: Males & Females, Combined |
|||||
|
/ Suicide Behaviour Category |
BSSP (n = 193, 2.8%) vs. OOSSP (n = 3,834, 57.3%) |
Chicago BSSP (n = 129, 3.1%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,195, 56.5%) |
Milwaukee BSSP (n = 189, 4.9%) vs. OOSSP (n = 2,145, 60.9%) |
New York BSSP (n = 1,169,4.0%) vs. OOSSP (n = 13,815, 49.3%) |
BSSP (n = 100, 1.9%) vs. OOSSP (n = 1,904, 37.2%) |
|
Seriously Considered |
11.7% RR: 3.3, OR: 4.7 |
36.0% vs.
12.8% RR: 2.8, OR: 3.8 |
47.9% vs.
11.8% RR: 4.1, OR: 6.9 |
36.5% vs.
14.3% RR: 2.5, OR: 3.4 |
23.6% RR: 2.4, OR: 4.2 |
|
Planned |
11.1% RR: 2.5, OR: 3.1 |
26.3% vs.
10.5% RR: 2.5, OR: 3.0 |
36.9% vs.
10.5% RR: 3.5, OR: 5.0 |
33.5% vs.
12.1% RR: 2.8, OR: 3.7 |
18.7% RR: 2.6, OR: 4.1 |
|
Suicide |
9.6% RR: 2.9, OR: 3.6 |
20.2% vs.
11.2% RR: 1.8, OR: 2.0 ns |
43.7% vs.
10.6% RR: 4.1, OR: 6.5 |
27.7% vs.
9.6% RR: 2.9, OR: 3.6 |
14.4% RR: 3.0, OR: 4.5 |
|
Attempt(s) & Medical Care |
3.3% RR: 5.3, OR: 6.3 |
7.4% vs.
4.3% RR: 1.7, OR:1.8 ns |
14.2% vs.
4.2% RR: 3.4, OR: 3.8 |
9.8% vs.
2.7% RR: 3.6, OR: 3.9 |
4.6% RR: 4.4, OR: 5.3 |
| Data Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2011) * Combined Surveys: 2001, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009 Basic RRs (Risk Ratios) & ORs (Odds Ratios): Calculated from Given Percentages at: http://statpages.org/ctab2x2.html RR & OR Statistical Significance Determination: If the Given 95% Confidence Intervals - Not Shown - for Two Compared Incidences do not Overlap. Not Statistically Significant RR & OR Indicated with "ns". |
|||||
Therefore, the data soliciting method used by researchers may make the difference between a study reporting that a certain type of "taboo" behavior is 'non-existent' in a human group (asking men "face-to-face" if they have has sex with children, or even asking men related questions on the telephone), and another study reporting related data. A major research question must therefore focus on the reliability of research studies reporting the extent of "taboo" behaviors in society, especially for the studies reporting the percentages of teenage or adult males homosexually active with (1) older males (may be intergenerational), (2) plus/minus same-age males, (3) younger males (may be intergenerational), and pre-puberty males (may be pedophilia). All such activities are "taboo" and the "taboo" degree will vary depending one one's immediate environment - such as one's culture ot subculture - and life circumstances), noting here that homosexuality was decreed to reflect "mental disorder" in North America until 1973-4. Homosexual behavior also has a history of being illegal, and the illegality of such activities still exists in about 22 American states. The decriminalization of male homo-sex behaviors only began after 1960 in North America.
On the basis of the "admission" results related to men sexually interested in children in the Bagley et al. (1994) study, the demographic part of the study (Bagley & Tremblay, 1998; available on the Internet by 1996) was predicted to most likely have decent reliability with respect to its effectiveness at soliciting less taboo information, such as men reporting being either homosexual or bisexual (Many males in these categories are still guarded with respect the ones to whom such 'identity" information will be revealed.), and with respect to men reporting being homosexually active (having sex at least once with a male in the last six month). These men may quite reluctant to let anyone know about such activities, although their male sexual partner(s) may "know," but they may have been in the "anonymous" category, and their reluctance may be great if these homo-active males are married to a female and are fathers. See Bagley & Tremblay (1996) for the results indicating that about 10% of males (both on the basis of self-identification and of being currently homosexually active) may be deemed homosexual or bisexual. The study results also challenged the 1-3 percent estimates of recent studies done using face-to-face interviews; they were deemed to produce highly unreliable "male sexuality" estimates in the [gross] "underestimate" category ranging from about 400% for homosexual behavior and up to 800% for self-identification as homosexual or bisexual. In this respect, Bagley & Tremblay stated: "Studies producing 200 to 800 percent underestimates for male homosexual realities should be unacceptable as social science research" (Bagley & Tremblay, 1998, Journal of Homosexuality, 36(2), p. 14).
Abstract Access: Access to the abstract may be made via the Science Magazine web site (http://www.sciencemag.org), but registering at the site is required - free. Use this URL (http://intl.sciencemag.org/) for faster access in these countries: Australia, Brazil, China, France, Germany, Hong Kong, Israel, Japan, The Netherlands, Russia, Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, and the UK. A document delivery service is also a available and a fee is charged to access the full text of the article. When in the site, use this link to immediately access the abstract. (http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/280/5365/867) or (http://www.intl.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/280/5365/867) if you are at the international web site. (PubMed abstract, Full Text.)
Research Highlights:
Sample: A random survey of 1672 males (number used for analysis) aged 15- to 19-years old living at a fixed address in the continental United States from February to November, 1995.
Study: Subjects were asked a number of questions, including questions relating to same-sex activity and illicit drug use. This was done using a pencil and paper method, and also via computer, supplemented by a verbal rendition of the questionnaire heard through headphones.
Results: The difference in "the effectiveness" of the two method for collecting sensitive data was remarkable. For example, "no male who was behind in school reported any of the six male-male sexual behaviors when completing the paper SAQ. In the audio-CASI condition, 6.2%...(answered affirmatively on one or more of these questions). As a group, however, there was a "fourfold" increase (400%) in males reporting homosexual activity when the computer-audio system was used: from a 1.5% to 5.5% positive response rate; the homosexual behavior with the greatest reporting difference (eightfold, adjusted) was to the question "Ever had receptive anal sex with another male (his penis in your rectum or butt)": 0.1% to 0.8%. For illicit behaviors such as "ever shared needle," the difference was about tenfold (adjusted): from 0.1% to 1.1%. For "ever taken street drug using a needle: from 1.4% to 5.2% - a fourfold increase.
Discussion: .It was noted that differences in response response rates generally did not occur with the two data intake methods when soliciting information not deemed to be illicit or taboo, thus leading to the conclusion that, at least for adolescent males 15- to 19-years of age, something 'special' occurs in their mind (in terms of withholding taboo information) when it is requested asked for this information via a paper-and-pencil questionnaire, and the difference is most significant for males behind in their grade level. The implications are that these boys - in addition to being like other boys in terms of withholding sensitive information - may also have difficulty reading and this problem would be overcome with the audio part of the computer-based data soliciting method. Furthermore, using expressions like "having a penis in your butt" is also a way to solicit information in a most non-ambiguous ways; males are not likely to misinterpret the question.
THE GREAT IMPLICATIONS FOR THE CDC's YOUTH RISK BEHAVIOR SURVEYS (YRBS) and THE RELATED PUBLISHED 1998 ANALYSES CONFIRMING THAT SELF-IDENTIFIED GAY/BISEXUAL MALE YOUTH or MALE YOUTH REPORTING BEING HOMOSEXUALLY ACTIVE are AT (STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANT) GREATER RISK FOR A NUMBER OF PROBLEMS, INCLUDING SUICIDE ATTEMPTS:
The YRBS are pencil-and-paper questionnaires, meaning that they it would be one of the least effective method to use (the worst probably being face-to-face interviews) for identifying adolescent males who have been engaging in illicit activities (such as street drug use) and highly taboo (possibly illegal) behaviors such as homosexual activity. On the basis of the Turner et al. (1998) study summarized above, an informed conclusion would be that the Youth Risk Behavior Surveys are grossly underestimating male (and possibly female) homosexual activity in adolescence. Therefore the result reported by Faulkner & Cranston (1998) for the Massachusetts' 1993 YRBS study (homosexual activity reported by 3.5% of male and female adolescents (106/3054) and by Durant et al. (1998) for 1995 Vermont YRBS study: 8.7% of males reporting homosexual activity) would be underestimates. If, for example, the 4-times underreporting factor from the Turner et al. (1998) study is used, the "2.6%" estimate for boys being homosexually active in Massachusetts would lead to the informed speculation that about 10.4% of adolescent boys (age 15 to 19) are homosexually active in Massachusetts, but most (75%) did not identify this fact on the pencil-and-paper questionnaire given to them for the YRBS study. This "10.4%", however, is higher that the 5.5% estimate reported by Turner et al. (1998), and also higher than the How could this be? There are many factors which can influence study results such as, for example, the fact that the Vermont study is a school sample and the Turner et al. study is a random sample requiring living at a fixed address. Gay adolescents, however, are at risk for being street youth and they may also be living with a man who, when contacted by the ones doing a random survey, may not revealed that the requested adolescent male was residing in his home. Such life situations, if they applied to some of the surveyed households, would lead to underestimates of homosexually active males in the adolescent population. On the other hand, a similar "underestimate" would also apply to school samples given that homosexually oriented youth are at greater risk for not being at school - thus increasing the likelihood of not being present the day the survey was administered, thus resulting in an underestimate for school samples.
There are many factors which will affect estimates for homosexually active male adolescents, and others which will affect estimates of homosexual- and bisexual-identified males. Furthermore, all such samples have been used for statistical analyses to establish, for example, that gay/bisexual male adolescents are significantly more at risk for suicide attempts than their heterosexual-identified counterparts. The Remafedi et al. (1998) study, for example, left out male adolescents "not sure about their sexual orientation" from the analysis. Therefore, although it could be said that 2% of gay/bisexual males with a lifetime attempted suicide rate of 28% would not account for 30% of the male youth attempted suicide problem, the "2%" would represent a small subset of the estimated 10 to 12 percent of homosexually oriented males who, let's say by the age of 18 to 27 (average age of 22.7 years, as reported by Bagley & Tremblay, 1997), would then account for about 25% of the males who reported self-harm activities in their lifetime, and 62.5% of males reporting a deliberate attempt at self-killing. A number of reasons account for the great differences between the spectacular Bagley & Tremblay (1997) "suicide attempt" results and the more modest results resulting from studies of adolescent male:
1. In studies of adolescent male samples where "being homosexually active" is used as the study's sampling and analysis criteria, males who are not homosexually active but already self-identify as gay or bisexual (and are having related problems, such as attempting suicide), are either excluded from the sample or they are placed in the "heterosexual" group simply because they report having had "sexual intercourse" with a female and not with a male.To date, the Bagley & Tremblay (1997) results form the best estimate of the proportion of North American adolescent male suicide attempter who are homosexually oriented (62.5%), and the study also replicated the Bell & Weinberg (1978) suicide attempt relative risk factor for homosexual males compared to heterosexual males. This estimate was obtained using a stratified random sampling process and "being homosexually oriented" was determined on the basis of subjects being either currently homosexually active (in the past six months) and/or by self-identifying as "homosexual" or bisexual", with an approximate 80% overlap for the two categories. A suicide attempt was defined to be "an attempt at self-killing," which may be different than the "suicide attempt" criteria used in adolescent samples. Often enough, self-harm activities (which are not be attempts at self-killing) are listed as suicide attempts - even by adolescents. Furthermore, the Bagley & Tremblay study used computer technology (the same as the Turner et al. (1998) study, but not including the audio via headphones) was used to solicit relevant "taboo" information from subjects, meaning that the likelihood of not identifying "homosexually oriented males" was reduced, thus improving the reliability of results.2. In studies of adolescent male samples where "self-identifying as homosexual/gay or bisexual" is used as the study's sampling and analysis criteria , males not in this category - but are homosexually active - and may later keep on being homosexually active with or without self-identification as homosexual/gay or bisexual and report that they were having serious problems (even including suicide attempts), will either be left out of the analysis or be placed in the "heterosexual-identified" category because they identified as heterosexual at the time. This would happen because these boys are desperately attempting to make themselves believe they were not homosexual or even bisexual, in spite of the behavioral evidence. Many men in many cultures are homosexually active, but only in dominant "insertive" ways; they behave sexually with a male as they would with a female, and identify as 100% heterosexual. In other words, their definition of homosexual or bisexual is not the one assumed by researchers. Another example of this happens when boys have somehow accepted the common belief that homosexuals are only men who have sex with boys; they therefore cannot report identifying to be homosexual. Boys who also commonly believe that gay (or homosexual) boys are effeminate will not report being homosexual (or even bisexual, meaning that they are effeminate only a part of the time) even if they are having sex with other boys and even men.
3. Adolescent male samples studied may have an average age of 15 or 16 year if the sample ranges from grade 8 or 9 to grade 12, meaning that about half of the gay/bisexual males who attempt suicide during their adolescent lives have not yet done so. Only a study of older males, such as the one carried out by Bagley & Tremblay (1997) (but even better studies may be designed), will render a decent 'picture' - or estimate - of what was the "suicide attempt" situation was during adolescence for homosexually oriented males compared to heterosexual males; the Bagley & Tremblay 1997 results also includes a few years into into young adulthood (to the age when they participated in the study: 18- to 27-years, average = 22.7 years, therefore an average of 3 years beyond adolescence) for most of the sampled males..
The Turner et al. (1998) study therefore serves as a serious caveat for all pencil-and-paper surveys involving the request for "homosexuality" information from adolescent (and probably young adult male) subjects studied and the subsequent analysis of the "at risk" status of homosexually oriented adolescent males compared to their heterosexual counterparts:
The "at risk" male adolescent population being identified may only represent about 25% of the targeted population which could have been identified had a better data-soliciting/intake method had been used. The additional caveat is that, no matter what method is used to solicit "homosexuality" information from adolescent males (and probably young adult males), the ones responding affirmatively to the requested "homosexuality" information will always represent an underestimate of "homosexually oriented" males in the study sample (Bagley & Tremblay, 1996).Bagley C, Wood M, Young L (1994). Victim to abuser: mental health and behavioral sequels of child sexual abuse in a community survey of young adult males.Child Abuse & Neglect, 18(8), 683-97. A PubMed "abstract".
SUMMARY OF HOMOPHOBIA-RELATED SUICIDALITY FROM THE 1995 SEATTLE PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDY OF ADOLESCENTS
The
development of this GBLT information web-pages was made possible through
the collaboration of Richard Ramsay (Professor, Faculty of Social Work,
University of Calgary) and Pierre Tremblay (independent researcher, writer,
and GLBT children/youth advocate) who both recognize that often needed
social changes occur as the result of knowledge availability and dissemination.
Graphics
are compliments of Websight West. The Synergy Centre donated computer/Internet
time to facilitate the construction of this GLBT information site.
![]() |
![]() |
The
information made available on this web-page does not represent all the
relevant information available on the Internet, nor in professional journals
and in other publications. Nonetheless, a wealth of information on GLB
suicide problems has been made available.
This
web-page was constructed to supply a spectrum of information to individuals
who may be seeking to understand one or more of the many gay, lesbian,
bisexual, and transgender issues.
| Home Page |
| Visitor Numbers |
|
|