| Home Page |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
"Attempted Suicide" Results For Homosexually Oriented Males & Females: More Than 140 Studies! At Another Website (Includes Transgender Study Results) |
|
Male Suicide Problems (Part 2 of 6: Internet Links - B) |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
See "Attempted Suicide" Results For Homosexually Oriented Males & Females: More Than 140 Studies! See: More Than 250 Full Text Papers and Documents Related to GLBT Suicidality. |
|
|
Those who were bullied, harassed, assaulted, or expelled because they were transgender or gender non-conforming in school also reported significantly elevated levels of suicide attempts (51% compared with 41% of our sample as a whole). Most notably, suicide attempt rates rise dramatically when teachers were the reported perpetrators: 59% for those harassed or bullied by teachers, 76% among those who were physically assaulted by teachers and 69% among those who were sexually assaulted by teachers. These numbers speak to the urgency of ending violence and harassment of transgender students by both their peers and their teachers. Education and income both correlate with suicide rates, with those earning $10,000 annually or less at extremely high risk (54%), while those making more than $100,000 are at comparatively lower risk (26%), while still astronomically higher than the general population. Those who have not completed college attempted suicide at higher rates (48% among those with no high school degree, 49% for those with a high school degree only, and 48% for those with some college education) while those have completed college (33%) or graduate school (31%) have significantly lower rates.
In August, 1999, a 31-year-old female informant who moved to Georgia
in 1998 wrote the following to the author of this webpage: "In case you're wondering why I am intrigued by this subject
matter - I, myself, have lost 3 male friends to suicide and personally
contemplated the act seriously after the death of my best friend in 1994.
Mike K. (CA, grew up upstate NY) was 22, a Navy Seal.. his folks refused
to even consider the possibility of his homosexual tendencies. John V.
(St. Louis, MO) was 26, "out," and an active member in a local gay group...
John F. was 25, an accomplished artist/carpenter... (OH when he died, originally
from upstate NY) It was suspected that John loved Sean and had been rejected
by him... - An American Grade 9 boy commits suicide at school. Only two
individuals knew he was gay and they did not reveal the boy's secret: Dead
Gay Kids Don't Talk, but.... Adolescent Sexual Orientation and Suicide Risk: Evidence From a National Study (Full Text). - AMA Hopes to Reduce Suicide Among Gay Youth (2001). - Miguel's Story
(2000, Must Scroll): "I met Miguel when he was seventeen years old and
shortly after his third suicide attempt. His story is all too familiar
amongst gay and lesbian youth that find themselves in a world of
exclusion, heartless ridicule and vicious abuse..." - Victimization for sexual orientation increases suicidal behavior in college students (2007, PDF).
Rev.
Peter Lau (Sacramento):
"And simply because he discovered that he was a homosexual person, he committed
suicide. I believe he's an Asian. Knowing that, coming from an Asian background,
I understand the kind of pressure that this kind of -- I would say, something
unbelievable, unbelievable that something like this can happen to him and
he just cannot accept that. And then I believe later I read similar news
like that as another young person committed suicide because of that. Then
I began to say to God that there must be another way to deal with this.
We cannot just let people commit suicide because they discover that they
are homosexual people." - Some of the people FUAH has supported and worked with: a mother whose lesbian daughter committed suicide.
Suicide
of a Washington bisexual youth, May, 1995. - Gay
suicide after becoming part of a gay community (1995). - At
the age of 17, Tom Beddingfield attempted suicide soon after his
boyfriend had committed suicide (1998). - Young,
gay and scared to death at school (CNN, 1999). - 2007 National School Climate Survey: Nearly 9 out of 10 LGBT Students Harassed. - Gay teens 'terrorized' in Canada's schools (2009). - Homosexual Teen Suicide (2007). - Searching for a Way Out: Stopping Gay Teen Suicide (1995).
Coming Out in Middle School
(2009): A middle-school counselor in Maine summed up the view of many
educators I spoke to when she conceded that her school was “totally
unprepared” for openly gay students. “We always knew middle school was
a time when kids struggle with their identity,” she told me, “but it
was easy to let anti-gay language slide because it’s so imbedded in
middle-school culture and because we didn’t have students who were out
to us or their classmates. Now we do, so we’re playing catch up to try
to keep them safe.” ... The challenging school experience of so many
gay and lesbian students — and the suicides last spring of a sixth
grader in Massachusetts and a fifth grader in Georgia, both of whom
were relentlessly bullied at school for appearing gay — reinforces the
longtime narrative of gay youth in crisis. Studies in the ’80s and ’90s
found gay teenagers to be at a significantly higher risk for
depression, substance abuse and suicide than their heterosexual peers.
[Comment: Same for studies from 2000 to 2009.)
Release
of 2003 National School Climate Survey Sheds New Light on the Experiences
of LGBT Students in America’s Schools: "At the same time, more
than 4 out of 5 lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) students
report being verbally, sexually or physically harassed at school because
of their sexual orientation. “This year’s findings clearly demonstrate
that despite modest measurable gains, violence, bias and harassment of
LGBT students continues to be the rule, not the exception, in America’s
schools,” said GLSEN Executive Director Kevin Jennings. “This research
reveals what must be inherent to so many educators and parents: harassment
has a negative impact on LGBT students’ academic performance and college
ambitions. To ignore these numbers is an irresponsible message to all students
that any promise of equal access to education remains forged and fictitious.”- Grading
Our Schools - homophobia (Last Article). (Related
Information) - GLSEN's
2005 National School Climate Survey Sheds New Light on Experiences of
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) Students: "75.4%
of students heard derogatory remarks such as "faggot" or "dyke"
frequently or often at school, and nearly nine out of ten (89.2%)
reported hearing "that's so gay" or "you're so gay" - meaning stupid or
worthless- frequently or often." - The Experiences of Lesbian, Gay,
Bisexual and Transgender Middle School Students: Findings from the 2007
National School Climate Survey. Research Brief. - 2007 National School Climate Survey: Nearly 9 out of 10 LGBT Students Harassed. - From: "Growing
Up Gay: Are Schools Doing Enough to Support Gay Students?": "Eight
U.S. school districts received the highest grade of "A"... More than twenty
of the 42 large U.S. school districts received failing grades." What is
an "A"? "Everything is relative," Cimino told the Herald. "If you're
going to put it on a normal scale of what we should have, we're a D-. But
when we're compared to what's going on in other school districts, we're
an A." - 2009 National School Climate Survey. - GLSEN Article on Demographic and Ecological Factors Contributing to Hostile School Climate for Gay Youth Published. - Silence
is the Voice of Complicity: Addressing Homophobia in Schools (Abstract). - GLSEN's Anti-Bullying Resources. - GLSEN" Safe Space Kit: What you can do to make your school safe for LGBT youth. - GLSEN" Tools to Develop and Implement a Safe Schools Campaign: Launch and sustain effective campaigns. - GLSEN's Jump-Start Guide for Gay-Straight Alliances: Download guides for students and gay-straight alliances/gsa. - The 2001 National
School Climate Survey by the Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network Summary (PDF
Download).
Teen
turns to suicide to end nonstop torment (Robbie Kirkland, 1998). - The
Robbie Kirkland Suicide Story. - Robbie
Kirkland "Remember Me!" - Robbie Kirkland Memorial. - Robbie's Story: How A Fragile 14-Year-Old Boy Was Crushed In His Struggle To Accept Being Gay. - A Mother Speaks Out.
Just
the facts: on gay, lesbian, and bisexual students and schools [a place
of abuse] made available by GLSTN (1987-1995). - A
16-year-old Miami Gay school dropout: "I would go to gay bars because it
was the only place I could find community. I was feeling stupid and with
no future. I did a lot of drugs. I tried to commit suicide twice." (1997)
The
first openly gay (newly graduated) police officer in Philadelphia - Thomas
G. Kalt Jr. - commits suicide (January, 1998) at the age of 26 (1999, Must Scroll).
- Death of Philadelphia Policeman Spurs Coverage of the Blue Closet (1999).- Philadelphia: First Gay Cop Recruit is Suicide (1999).
From the Past:
Sandy Tipper, the author of Exodus: Coming out as a faith journey,
reports on his two suicide attempts: religious beliefs are implicated.
-
The
well known gay author and activist, Larry Kramer, attempted suicide in
1953 when he was at Yale University. - The
founder of the Metropolitan Community Church, Troy Perry, attempted suicide
after being deserted by his lover. (Alternate Link, Related
Information: 1, 2, 3) - Brian
McNaught, the godfather of gay sensitivity training, attempted suicide:
"For over thirty years, McNaught has drawn on personal experiences —
including a failed suicide attempt, coming out to his parents and
co-workers, and being fired for being gay — in order to help audiences
understand what it's like to grow up gay." (2007, 2010 Update).
-
Suicide
Attempters & Completers were not uncommon for GB male students at Harvard
University. Examples given. - American
born film director reports having been thrown out of house at age 18, working
as a prostitute throughout the U.S., "and ended up in a psychiatric ward
after a suicide attempt N/A." - George
Whitmore: Whitmore wrote of his own three attempts at suicide,
the first when he was only seventeen. In one attempt, he overdosed on drugs
prescribed to "calm" him. Suicide was something, he says, that he applied
himself to "with dedication... Like so many others. I was doing everything
I could not to come to terms with an identity. I'd been carefully taught
to abhor." Drugs,
suicide attempts, and risky sex (N/A).
Utah: - "I
am glad to hear that Earl Cherry and Jeana Berube will be making a video
to help prevent youth suicides in Utah." - (Salt Lake Tribune,
June 7, 1998) - "But unlike KUED's local program on the problem a while
back, this video will hopefully address the suicide risk for gay and bisexual
youth - the highest for all risk groups." - Jacob
Orosco commits suicide. - Matis
wrote in his suicide note, which was read at the memorial, that he first
realized he was gay at age 7 (2001). - "I
could be your son": Letter by gay youth in Salt Lake Tribune -
reporting more than 4 suicide attempts (1996). - Despite
small introads of tolerance, harassment of young gays and lesbians continues
in public high schools (1997). - Advocates see rise in gay suicide
(2010): As the number of suicides among lesbian, gay, bisexual and
transgender populations continues to increase across the nation,
concern among the Utah LGBT community has begun to push the issue into
the spotlight. - Mesa vigil aims to prevent suicides of gay Mormons (2010).
USA
Mormon Church / University History - An ongoing problem. From the
1997
lecture, "Private
Pain, Public Purges: A History of Homosexuality at Brigham Young University,"
delivered by Connell O'Donovan in 1997 at the University of California,
Santa Cruz. "In this 1975 article, McQueen reported that five Gay men he
had known at BYU had gotten caught in the Purge of '75, were coerced into
therapy, expelled from BYU, outed by church officials, and then excommunicated.
Rather than face the bigotry of family, friends, church, and state, each
one committed suicide.[17] Another man who was caught in that purge remembers
that a BYU professor shot and killed himself that year after being entrapped
at a local off campus restroom.[18] Local police and other agencies as
well got involved in the purge as it spilled over into 1976. Another male
student, after being arrested at a highway reststop (known affectionately
as the Blow-n-Go), took a bottle of aspirin to kill himself. He was taken
to Utah Valley Hospital where the medical personnel there recognized the
suicide attempt and contacted BYU Security immediately. BYU Security, who
had a file on him because of his arrest at the rest stop, then outed the
man to his bishop and wife. - Legacies,
a documentary by Sean Weakland (1997): "We had several people who
committed suicide during the therapy. We had three different people who
hung themselves in the Harris Fine Arts Center on BYU campus. In Mormon
theology, you will be eternally punished for committing suicide. If you
die as a homosexual, you will be punished all the worse."
Gay
Mormon hoped suicide would help change church (February, 2000):
"In the note Matis urges his parents to use his death to teach other church
members and church leaders 'the true nature of homosexuality.' ...'I implore
the students at BYU to re-assess their homophobic feelings. Seek to understand
first before you make comments. We have the same needs as you. We desire
to love and be loved. We desire to live our lives with happiness. We are
not a threat to you or your families. We are your sons, daughters, brothers,
sisters, neighbors, co-workers and friends, and most importantly, we are
all children of God,' he wrote in the letter to the Daily Universe." -
Affirmation
- Virtual Memorial for Gay Mormon Suicides. - Queer
Mormons - Between a Rock and a Hard Place (2007). - Todd Ransom: Mormon family breaks silence about gay man’s suicide (2010).
Aaron's
Story (Alternate Link): "Back at Church,
the word got out that I was homosexual. I was not longer allowed to be
around children, prepare sacraments, or pray though I had done nothing
wrong. People became scared of me, and longtime friends refused to associate
any longer. The psychiatrist at this point told me to try electroshock
therapy. He said in severe cases it was the only way. I refused. The Church
excommunicated me at this point. Even though they knew I had done nothing
sexual, they put me on trial and questioned me. I was shocked—they probed
me with sexual questions of things I had never heard of. I was kicked out
forever with a letter and warning that said I was outside the Church's
reach. Because I once held the priesthood, I now was a candidate for Outer
Darkness. I then came out, 7 years ago. I am so glad I have. My life is
so much better than ever before. I no longer struggle with my sexuality
because I know who I am. Sadly, a friend who was in the same exgay program
committed suicide after 2 years of electroshock. He had burns on his arms
where they would shock him for showing sexual response to pictures. They
even had him get married and have children to prove his straightness. Instead,
he was visiting parks and alleys for sex. He injected himself with drugs
and left behind two beautiful young daughters. I could have been him."
Living Outside the Lines: A Story of Personal Discovery and Self-Acceptance (2004, Alternate Link):
"John's suicide brought clarity to my life and convinced me that it was
time to stop waffling. How many more Johns were out there? How many
Janes? I knew there were others in the world just like me who struggled
to fit in but did not know how to. They needed to know that they were
not the only ones. I had an ethical responsibility to come out and to
live my life openly. If John had known there were others like him,
perhaps he would have opted to talk instead of taking his life. It was
too late for John but I could do something for others, starting with
myself. I was afraid, but my fear was irrelevant. I had to move
forward, come out of the closet, and make a difference in the world."
A Three-Part Examination of GLB Suicide Problems by Outlines Magazine (1997): Suicide
A Community Epidemic, A Community Solution. Part One: Death and
dropout of gay and lesbian teens blights America's school system. -
High
School Confidential. Part Two: Suicide and Depression Among High
School Age Gay and Lesbian Youth. - Part
Three: The Grown Ups.
In
the case of Jamie Nabozny, now 21, the epithets began in 7th grade and
escalated into a daily routine of homophobic abuse that led him to attempt
suicide twice and to drop out of high school in his junior year.
(Gay Student Wins Sexual Harassment Case With NASP Support.) - Nabozny v. Podlesny - U.S. Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit (1996):
"Toward the end of the school year, the harassment against Nabozny
intensified to the point that a district attorney purportedly advised
Nabozny to take time off from school. Nabozny took one and a half weeks
off from school. When he returned, the harassment resumed, driving
Nabozny to attempt suicide. After a stint in a hospital, Nabozny
finished his eighth grade year in a Catholic school..." - Who's at Risk? Gay and Lesbian Youth. - Gay and lesbian youth at risk (1997).
The American Midwest (1998):
A live-in observer the the GLB youth situation reports
on an "at least bisexual" male youth who committed suicide after being
placed in jail. Another youth "asphyxiated himself with a car in the garage"
after it was believed that he had become "comfortable with his sexuality,"
which included having visited a local gay group.
Texas:
Gay
Youth at Risk: "At
five years old, I knew I was sexually attracted to men. I internalized
all of the negative images surrounding homosexuality; at 18, I attempted
suicide in my parent's home. Right after that I left. I still carry the
wound; no one should have to believe like I did that they are the only
one in the world." - Texas
Suicide-Prevention Panel Makes Recommendations N/A: "The commission
urged... special programs to reach out to groups often overlooked in suicide
prevention programs, including the elderly, ethnic minorities, youths,
gays, lesbians and the homeless." A suicide Prevention Tookit (PDF Download):
"Within the larger community many populations exist that may be at
special risk for suicide, such as women in certain age groups, men, the
elderly, people from different ethnic groups,
gay/bisexual/lesbian/transgendered people, and youth." - Gay Houston Teenager Driven to Suicide By Bullies (2010).
Success Stories - McAllen, Texas (2003):
"In May of 2002, a letter arrived at the ACLU from McAllen, Texas, a
small town near the Mexican border. Crystal Mendoza and Orlando Campa,
two high school students, needed help. Students in their school had
been harassed for years, and school leaders did nothing to stop it.
Then that spring a gay student committed suicide because he couldn't
take it anymore. For the first time ever, classmates at the school got
together to talk about the harassment and other LGBT concerns..." - Point Foundation grants scholarships to 30 lgbt students
(2006): Jacob Weldon: Jacob grew up in Port Neches, TX, a the
conservative Bible Belt town in the heart of southeast Texas. After
coming out, Jacob experienced a world of backlash from family and
friends that led him down a self-destructive road, concluding with a
suicide attempt. Finding strength in his Christian faith, Jacob
found the strength to accept himself. Jacob will attend Columbia
University to pursue an individualized program in Human Rights Advocacy
and Law.
Colorado: Suicide Risks for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender teens
(Youth Risk Behavior Survey): LGBQ teenagers are at significantly
greater risk for suicide attempts than heterosexual teens. In Boulder
County, 44% of LGBQ youth said they’d attempted suicide, compared to
13.5% of heterosexual youth. - Suicide-prevention effort focuses on gays. - Suicides of bullied gay kids in other states jolt Colorado educators to action (2010). - Suicides and school safety for LGBT youth (2010). - Colorado Anti-Violence Program Newsletter:
Working to eliminate violence within and against the lesbian, gay,
bisexual, transgender and queer communities of Colorado.
Preventing Suicide inColorado: Progress Achieved & Goals for the Future
(2009): There are some Colorado data available regarding
sexual-minority youth. In a 2003 youth risk behavioral survey conducted
among high school students in the Boulder Valley and St. Vrain Valley
school districts, 44% of sexual-minority respondents reported having
attempted suicide, compared to 13.5% of their heterosexual
counterparts. More recently, an analysis of data on adolescents served
by the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender Community of Colorado’s
Rainbow Alley program found that suicide risk factors included
hopelessness, victimizationby bullies, methamphetamine use and homelessness.
New Mexico: - New Mexico’s Progress in Collecting Sexual Orientation Health Data and Its Implications for Addressing Health Disparities (2010): Suicide and Depression (2006):
Compared to straight adults, LGB adults, 18 years and older, were much
more likely to have thought about or attempted suicide. Nearly five
times the percentage of LGB adults had thought about suicide and over
three times the percentage have attempted suicide. Similarly, nearly
three times the percentage of LGB adults reported depression than
straight adults (43.0% vs. 17.2%). - Focus on Gay Teen Suicides
(2010): Hard data about New Mexico gay and lesbian youths who attempt
or consider suicide is scarce, but some data is available about gay
adults. A New Mexico Department of Health report published in April
found that one in four gay, lesbian and bisexual adults reported having
attempted suicide, compared with only one in 20 straight adults.
New
York: Much of my church work was near New York City, and on Times Square
I found my first friendships with a variety of gay males - all of whom
are gone now due to suicide, hate crimes and AIDS. (From: Celebrating
Howard's Lifetime of Ministry; My Life Began with Stonewall and PLGC N/A
(Alternate
Link) by the Rev. Howard Warren (1999). Must scroll to locate reference).
- In
the Closet or Out on the Edge: Teens at Greater Suicide Risk (1999): "James,
a bisexual teen, says he’s tried to kill himself twice. Every day at school,
he is taunted with "fag," "gay," "queer" and other names too ugly to mention."
- Predicting the Suicide Attempts of Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Youth (2005, PDF Download). - Tyler Clementi, Other Gay Suicide Victims Remembered At New York Vigil (2010): NYU students and local politicians gathered to send message that bullying can kill. - Mental Health of New York City Youth
(2008): Teens who identify as lesbian, gay, or bisexual, or who are
questioning their sexual identity have much higher rates of suicidal
thoughts and behaviors.
2005 New York City Youth Risk Behavior Survey:
In the past 12 months, compared to heterosexual youth, the odds of
having attempted suicide were greater for Gay, Bisexual and Unsure male
students: 6.2, 12.8, 6.9, respectively, or 9.0 for the combined 3
groups (3.4, with control variables). For Lesbian, Bisexual and Unsure
females, the odds were 0.9, 5.3, 2.4, respectively, or 3.7 for the
combined 3 groups (2.5, with control variables). - Gay High Schools Offer a Haven From Bullies (2008): But the schools in Milwaukee and New York also reawaken the debate over school segregation
Rhode Island: - Gay R.I. Student In Apparent Suicide (2010). - School
Shouldn't Hurt: Lifting the Burden from Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and
Transgendered Youth: A report of the Rhode Island Task Force on Gay,
Lesbian,Bisexual and Transgendered Youth (1996).
Rhode Island Department of Education (RIDE, 2008). "Band-Aids
Don’t Cut It" - Rhode Island Develops First Statewide Plan for Lesbian,
Gay, Bisexual, Queer, and Questioning (LGBTQQ) Youth. PDF. - Rhode Island Departments of Health and Elementary & Secondary Education (2009). Sexual Orientation and Health Risks Among Rhode Island Public High School Students in 2007. PDF. - Jiang Y, Perry DK, Hesser JE (2010). Adolescent suicide and health risk behaviors: Rhode Island's 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. American Journal of Preventative Medicine, 38(5): 551-5. Abstract.
Pennsylvania:
"In a May 31 article distributed by Knight-Ridder, Wilkes-Barre (Penn.)
Times Leader staff writer Bob Nocek profiled a self-identified "gay jock
teen" in Pennsylvania. The piece begins: "His parents had finally gone
to sleep, and now it was time for Greg Congdon to die... For the second
time in barely more than a month, Greg Congdon, 17 years old, wanted to
end his life... After that attempt, Greg admitted to the emergency room
doctor that he was gay, and subsequently told his parents, who were supportive,
but things at school were more difficult." (From: 2) Greg
Congdon: a Leader for our Times. (Alternate
Link) Select: "misc news, 06/22/99:
(15K)". Must scroll to locate reference.) - Death
without justice: after their teen son committed suicide in a panic,
Pennsylvania parents sued the police who'd threatened to out him. The
resulting court case is a landmark for gay and lesbian privacy rights (2001, Related).
Illinois
- Chicago: - Task force talks suicide prevention [for GLBTQ youth] (2010). -
Suicide
A Community Epidemic, A Community Solution - Part One: Death and dropout
of gay and lesbian teens blights America's school system . - Letter
from Asian American 17-year-old coming out (1998): "Denying who I am was the
worst form of torture. I thought if I came out I'd lose my parents, friends,
everything. I constantly thought of suicide. Hiding almost destroyed me." - Stigma and suicidality: Prevalence and patterns among Latino gay men in Chicago and San Francisco
(2005): The sample consisted of 200 Latino gay men (n=100 in Chicago,
n=100 in San Francisco), recruited through respondent-driven sampling,
who completed a Computer Assisted Self Interviewing survey (CASI).
Results show a high percentage of both recent suicidal ideation and
lifetime suicide attempts. One out of three men reported at least one
previous lifetime suicide attempt...
Chicago Stands Up Against Anti-Gay Bullying & LGBT Suicide
(2010): The Trevor Project, which runs the nation's only 24-hour
suicide and crisis prevention helpline for LGBTQ youth
(1-866-4-U-TREVOR or 1-866-488-7386), has been reaching out to
the Chicago community to help in its mission. They are doing this by
establishing the Chicago Ambassadors of The Trevor Project, ...
volunteer organization that seeks to aid in crisis and suicide
prevention among LGBTQ youth by establishing a vibrant presence in the
Chicago Area, leveraging the community's unique history of diversity
and legislative development concerning civil rights and education. I am
honored to be part of the group helping to organize the Chicago
Ambassadors. The group is hosting its first official Chicago event next
week... Chicagoans respond to gay teen suicide issue with videos (2010): Lakeview GLBT Community Center hosts recording session as part of "It Gets Better Project."
Sullivan, Shannon (2007). Chicago Public High Schools: Differential Risk Factors for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual Identified Students: 2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results. Chicago: The Illinois Safe Schools Alliance. PDF. - Sullivan, Shannon (2007b). Chicago Public High Schools: Differential Risk Factors for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual Identified Students: 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results. Chicago: The Illinois Safe Schools Alliance. PDF. Results are those given by .... Horn SS, Szalacha LA (2007). Chicago Public Schools Youth Risk Behavior Survey 2005: Executive Summary. Chicago: Board of Education of the City of Chicago. PDF. - 2005 GLB suicidality results in: Illinois Department of Public Health (2010). 2009 Suicide Prevention Report. Chicago: Illinois Department of Public Health. PDF. - 2009 GLBU suicidality data: Smith TL, Syeinhuasen G, Carland J (2010). Risk Behaviors Among Illinois and Chicago High School Students by Sexual Orientation [2009 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results]. Presentation: Adolescent Health Disparities Summit, Springfield, IL, October 26, 2010. PDF: PPT.
Ohio:
"For defying gender norms so blatantly she paid the price at school. Classmates
taunted and ridiculed her. The problems grew worse when she entered 8th
grade. Life became miserable for her. 'It wasn't just guys, it was girls
too that were harassing her,' said her mother. Nicole kept her problems
to herself. Even school officials were unaware of the severity of the situation.
On 13 Oct 98 Nicole could take it no longer. She killed herself using her
father's .22 rifle. (From: Gender-Questioning
Teen Suicide in Cleveland. (Alternate
Link) Select: "gender questioning teen suicide, 03/28/99") - A
Commission on Youth and Suicide? Will GLB issues be included? (1998)"According
to an article in the Akron Beacon Journal (February 15, 1998), Ford said
that the inclusion of gay and lesbian youth is in response to the ABJ's
recent Suffering in Silence series about glbt youth in the Akron-Canton
area, many of whom tried to commit suicide. To date, the bill has bipartisan
support with approximately 25 co-sponsors." - The
Robbie Kirkland Pages - Ohio Paper Tells Tragic Story of Gay Teen Suicide (1998, Must Scroll). - A
[gender nonconformable] teen-age girl's battle for acceptance ends in suicide,
Deaths of 4 bullied teenagers at Ohio school produce lawsuits, soul-searching (2010): Eric Mohat was flamboyant and loud and preferred to wear pink most of the time. When he didn’t get the lead soprano part in the choir his freshman year, he was indignant, his mother says... Mohat’s family and friends say he wasn’t gay, but people thought he was... Bullies once knocked a pile of books out of his hands on the stairs, saying, “‘Pick up your books, faggot,’” says Dan Hughes, a friend of Eric’s. Kids would flick him in the head or call him names, says 20-year-old Drew Juratovac, a former student. One time, a boy called Mohat a “homo,” and Juratovac told him to leave Mohat alone... Eric Mohat shot himself on March 29, 2007, two weeks before a choir trip to Hawaii.His parents asked the coroner to call it “bullicide.” --- “Meredith ended up coming out that she was a lesbian,” he says. “I think much of that sparked a lot of the bullying from a lot of the other girls in school, ‘cause she didn’t fit in.” Her best friend, Kevin Simon, doesn’t believe that bullying played a role in Rezak’s death. She had serious issues at home that were unrelated to school, he says.
Oklahoma: - Another Tragic LGBT-Bullying Related Suicide: Zach Harrington, 19, of Norman
(2010): There has been another tragic suicide of a teenager, who was
bullied for being gay. Zach Harrington killed himself a week
after witnessing a "toxic" city council meeting in Norman, Oklahoma,
where "concerned citizens" gathered en masse to hurl their hatred and
homophobia, decrying LGBT persons as deviant, sinful, damned, etc. etc.
etc.
Indiana: - Indiana teen’s suicide thought to be result of anti-gay bullying
(2010): “Some people at school called him names,” Hughes said, saying
most of those names questioned Lucas’ sexual orientation, and that
Lucas, for the most part, did little to defend himself. - Teacher suspended for running pro-gay editorial in school paper (2007).
Safe Education Environment for Gays and Lesbians: A Plan to Implement GLBT Youth Education in Schools
(2008, Melanie Pasillas, Honors Thesis, Ball State University, Muncie,
Indiana): The purpose ofthis thesis project is to develop an
implementation plan in order to complete the final steps in the process
ofcreating the new program SEEGL, an educational program aimed at
combating GLBT youth suicide. The program implementation framework,
described in Netting, Kettner, and McMurty's (2008) textbook Social
Work Macro Practice, will be applied. Before the discussion ofthe
implementation plan, the problem ofGLBT suicide will be identified, the
need for the program will be assessed, and the details ofthe program
will be explained.
Wisconsin: - Film showing students effects of bullying gay peers follows student who had tried suicide
(2010): Jamie Nabozny's teenage years were hell: He was called nasty
names, was beaten so badly he wound up in the hospital, ran away from
home and even tried to kill himself. All because he was gay. When
officials at his Ashland, Wis., middle school and high school refused
to do anything about the bullying, Nabozny sued the school district —
and won. His case is the subject of a new film from the Montgomery,
Ala.-based Southern Poverty Law Center and will be viewed by school
children across the country. - Gay Wis. teen victim of suicide (2010): Cody J. Barker, 17, of Shiocton, Wis., took his life on Sept. 13... Maria
Peeples, Barker’s peer mentor through GSA for Safe Schools, said he was
a passionate activist for all students, especially those, “targeted or
ostracized for their sexual orientation or their gender identity and
expression. … He really cared about making schools a safe place for
students. That wasn’t always his own experience with school.”
A teen book burns at the stake:
A Christian group hopes to set fire to library copies of Francesca Lia
Block's novel about a gay boy coming of age (2009): Francesca Lia
Block, an award-winning author of young-adult books (the "Weetzie Bat"
series among them), has known for a while now that one of her novels,
"Baby Be-Bop" is at the center of a controversy in West Bend, Wis. A
few days ago, she found out that it might be burned at the stake. "Baby
Be-Bop" is on a list of titles that a local group calling itself the
West Bend Citizens for Safe Libraries objects to seeing in the public
library. Wisconsin Professor in Trouble for Sending Anti-Gay E-Mail to Student (2010). Wisconsin Teacher’s Anti-Homophobia Class Horrifies Christian Right (2009).
Wisconsin colleges join push to end bullying of gay students
(2010): Dozens of students and staff at the University of
Wisconsin-Whitewater held a rally Friday after an assault on campus in
which a student wearing a shirt with the slogan "Legalize Gay" was
punched in the face. Students at Carthage College held a similar vigil
last week, invoking the name of an Appleton gay teen who committed
suicide last month after he experienced harassment at school. - Parade Commodore to 14-year-old Girl: “Go To A Country Where They Hang People Like You” (2010).
2007 Wisconsin Youth Risk Behavior Survey (Word Download N/A): Sexual minority students were 3.7 times more at risk for having attempted suicide in the past 12 months, compared to heterosexual students. - Risk Behaviors and Factors of Youth Engaging in Same-Sex Sexual Behaviors (PDF Download): One in four same-sex youth (7.5% het-sex youth) had a suicide attempt in the previous 12 months. More than one in seven (15%) same-sex had a suicide attempt in the previous 12 months serious enough that it required medical attention, compared to 2.5% of het-sex youth, a six-fold difference...
Benditt L, Engel E, Gavin M, Stransky E (2009). Addressing Health Disparities Affecting Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) Youth and Adults in Wisconsin. Workshop in Public Affairs. Prepared for the Wisconsin Department of Health Services, HIV/AIDS Program, Division of Public Health. Reports suicidality results (controlling for many variables) for GLB students compared to heterosexual students in the Wisconsin 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. The odds for GLB high school students having attempted suicide in the past year were 3.9-times greater than for heterosexual students. PDF Download.
California:
"Spahr
had hoped that Robin Reed, a sophomore at Petaluma High School, would be
the last gay teen suicide in town. He believes, however, that two other
gay teens have since killed themselves." (From: Teen's
fate ignited activist (1999, Must Scroll). - Honoring
Robin Reed, a 15-Year Old Suicide (2002). - Gay
Teens in School Focus of Weekly Newsmagazine Segment (1998). Slurs like "faggot,"
"dyke" or "That's so gay," are sometimes not readily addressed or put a
halt to, said Highlands Elementary teacher Eric Heins. "Sometimes I've
heard students say that teachers just seem to ignore them (slurs) or pretend
not to hear." Lauren, a San Leandro High School dropout... has also
contemplated, and attempted, suicide. - Bay
Area gay man's suicide may be basis of TV movie (1998). - Décès
mystérieux de deux lesbiennes en Californie. - Family Rejection as a Predictor of Negative Health Outcomes in White and Latino Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Young Adults (2009). - Mourning at Howard
(2010): Former [lesbian] student commits suicide, seemingly related to
sexuality, though father says she was not bullied directly.
Teen Line Reaches Out To LGBT Youth (PDF):
"California children are inheriting a society more multicultural and
multiracial than ever before witnessed in modern history. With
these gifts of diversity, there sometimes comes ugly intolerance of
differences. Gay and lesbian youth are often at higher risk for
emotional problems, abuse, and neglect – not because of their sexual
orientation but because of such intolerance, ignorance, and some
people’s inability to accept individual differences. LGBTQ youth face
great difficulties growing up in a society where homophobia and
heterosexism run rampant. Many may feel isolated at home and within
their communities." - Another dead gay designer (2004). - Seth Walsh, California Teen Who Endured Gay Taunts, Commits Suicide (2010). - Prop. 8 Can Cause Gay Suicide, Columbia Prof Testifies (2010). - Mormon church in California faces new criticism on gay stance after suicide of Marie Osmond's son (2010).
San Francisco Middle / High School Studies (2008, 2009): - One-Third of Gay Middle Schoolers In S.F. Have Attempted Suicide, Study Claims (2010): According to recent studies, 34 percent of gay middle schoolers, and 23 percent of high schoolers had attempted suicide in the last year alone... 34 percent of middle schoolers identifying as lesbian, gay, or bisexual (LGB) had attempted suicide in the last year -- compared to 7 percent of hetero kids. Forty-three percent of LGB students had made a suicide plan; 56 percent had seriously considered suicide. In high school, the numbers go down -- a bit. Twenty-three percent had attempted suicide in the past year, compared to 31 percent who'd made a plan, and 38 percent who'd seriously considered suicide. While the San Francisco school district was the first in the country to establish support services for LGBTQ youth 20 years ago, it seems anti-gay slurs are rampant within the city's schools: 84 percent of middle schoolers had heard slurs like "fag," "dyke," or "that's so gay," thrown around, while only 59 percent had ever heard teachers or staff stop students from making those remarks... As far as experiencing actual violence, queer kids are more likely to get in fights. Forty-six percent of gay high schoolers had been in a fight, while only 20 percent of hetero kids had in the past year. Things get even worse for transgender kids: 56 percent report being in a physical fight. Gay kids were also astronomically more likely to smoke cigarettes, drink alcohol, or use cocaine, inhalants, or marijuana. - Supporting gay youth is a core San Francisco value (2010, Same data reported, with additional information). - LGBTQ Student health (PPT): Contains suicidality results.
Louisiana: Sadly, Gay Anti-Discrimination Laws Are Needed in Louisiana: "Sen. Lynn Dean, R-Braithwaite, had told a Senate committee of personal knowledge of a number of gays who committed suicide."
Massachusetts:
From The
Unofficial Site of the... Massachusetts Governor's Commission on Gay &
Lesbian Youth - Availability of all related Reports/Documents, many
with suicidality information. - Massachusetts
Governor's Commission on Gay & Lesbian Youth: Publications & Reports of the Commission. - The "suicide"
section in Prevention
of Health Problems Among Gay & Lesbian Youth: Making Health & Human
Services Accessible and Effective for Gay & Lesbian Youth
(August,
1994). - Countering the Backlash Against Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and
Transgender Students, Families, and Staff in Minnesota Schools: A
Primer on the Minnesota Family Institute’s Anti-LGBT Agenda for Public
EducationPlus: Steps Toward Stopping the Backlash (2005, PDF Download). - Study Says Perils of Adolescence Greater for Gay Teens (1998). - Massachusetts Study Shows High Suicide Rate for Gay Students (2001). - The Friends of GLBT Youth
(2007): Youth in schools with a Gay-Straight Alliance have decreased
victimization at school and fewer suicide attempts. These are
allvictories that should make anyone in Massachusetts proud.
"% Attempted Suicide in The Past Year" Results, Massachusetts Youth Risk Behavior Surveys: % GLB vs. % Others, 2005 (24.8% vs. 5.7%, 4.4-times greater), 2007 (29.1% vs. 6.4%, 4.5-times greater), 2009 (24.7% vs. 5.6%, 4.4-times greater). - Another 11-Year-Old Commits Suicide: Anti-Gay Taunts Cited (2009). - Transgender Identified In Mass: About A Third Thought About Suicide In Past 12 Months (2009): [The study] found that about 31 percent of transgender respondents said they have considered attempting suicide in the past year, compared to just 2 percent for heterosexual residents, 4 percent for gay and lesbian residents and 7 percent for bisexual residents.
Suicide Prevention in Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) Communities (2010). - State House Vigil Remembers LGBT Suicide Victims (2010). - In Response to the LGBT Youth Suicide Crisis… (2010). - Where’s the gay anti-bullying reform in our schools? (2010) - Massachusetts Anti-Bullying Bill Fails to Adequately Protect LGBT Students, According to Joint Statement by National and Local LGBT Organizations (2010).
Minnesota:
- Gay
youth at higher risk of suicide (1997). - Study
Confirms High Suicide Risk in Gay Youth (1998). - Youth at risk - statistics of suicide risks among gay teenagers (1997). - The relationship between suicide risk and sexual orientation: results of a population-based study (1998, Full Text). - Minnesota's GLBT Students. - Suicidality among Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Youth: The Role of Protective Factors (2006).
Gay student suicides underscore problem of LGBT bullying
(2010): As one Minnesota school district continues to mourn the
suicides of three LGBT students within the last year, another gay
teenager some 600 miles away killed himself. Billy Lucas, 15, took his
own life inside his family’s barn in Greenburg, Ind., on Sept. 9. His
and the other suicides point not only to bullying as a lingering issue
facing many LGBT youth, but also to a culture that continues to condone
anti-gay harassment and discrimination in schools across the country... The controversy surrounding the recent suicides in Minnesota and Indiana coincide with the release of GLSEN’s biennial National School Climate Survey,
which paints a sobering picture of LGBT students’ safety nationwide.
The survey of more than 7,000 students reported nearly nine out of 10
respondents experienced some form of harassment. Specifically, 61
percent of students felt unsafe at school due to their sexual
orientation-nearly 40 percent of respondents felt the same way due to
their gender expression. More than 84 percent of students were verbally
harassed andnearly 19 percent of respondents reported being physically assaulted because of their sexual orientation.
Suicide surge: Schools confront anti-gay bullying
(2010): The district - Minnesota's largest - serves nearly 40,000
students in 13 towns. The school board adopted the neutrality policy in
2009 as a balancing act, trying not to offend either liberal or
conservative families. Rebecca Dearing, 17, a junior who belongs to the
gay-straight alliance at the district's Champlin Park High School, said
the neutrality policy caused teachers to shy away from halting anti-gay
harassment - sometimes leaving her gay friends feeling vulnerable to
the point where they don't come to school.
Yet Another Gay Teen Lost to Bullying Suicide - in Minnesota (2010). - Three LGBT students in one district attempt suicide (2010). - Mother of suicide victim speaks out on bullying at Anoka-Hennepin (2010). - String of Teen Suicides Linked to Gay Bullying at Minnesota School (2010). - Recent teen suicides make strong case for Minnesota Safe Schools Bill (2010). - Anti-bullying bill to be filed in special session (2010).
Nebraska: - Stopping Gay Suicide Hurts Traditional Values
(2006): Bear in mind that gay teenagers have an enormously high rate of
attempting and committing suicide, many times higher than the rest of
the teenage population, for obvious reasons. Preventing this from
happening, helping those kids handle their difficulties in a healthy
way, is clearly a good thing to any sane human being. But according to
these bigots, helping gay teenagers avoid suicide "undermines
traditional values." Only if those values are vile and barbaric, of
course.- Gay Teen Suicide is Not the Enemy (2006).
Washington:
- Safe
Schools Coalition of Washington: Suicide.
- A
summary of Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results relating to GLB adolescent
suicide problems (available as PDF Download): Seattle, Massachusetts,
Vermont, Minnesota. - Gabi Clayton's Resources - GLBT Suicide.
Victimization of College Students Up Suicide Risk
(2007): New research indicates that being victimized because of sexual
orientation is a chief risk factor for suicidal behavior among gay,
lesbian and bisexual college students... “A lot of people stop thinking
about sexual orientation related victimization and suicide as a problem
beyond the K-12 school years,” she said. “But suicide doesn’t stop
after high school. I thought I wouldn’t find very much victimization in
Seattle, and I certainly wasn’t expecting these kinds of numbers.” The
study was provoked by a question from a 15-year-old gay male while
Murphy was working on an internship as a school psychologist at a high
school. The youth, who was suicidal and using drugs, asked her, “Does
it get better in college”” She didn’t know.
Oregon: - Suicide Awareness Week, My Struggle, My Story
(2009). I struggled with this identity for a number of years and
shortly after coming out turned to self-harm to deal with the rough
emotions that I was going through. I have never really spoken openly
about my experimentation with self harm and have a difficult time
reflecting on these experiences because of the stigma that is placed on
youth who think about or attempt suicide. During high school my Mom
tried varies means to “turn” me straight. After each of these episodes
(once even consisted of an exorcism) I would hide in my room or run to
the field behind our house and cut my thighs or wrists. I would use the
pain to help deal with the ostracism that I was facing within my own
family. Eventually I tried suicide by swallowing pills with my best
friend (we had made a pact to commit suicide together) and only
survived because I didn’t understand the strengths of medicines and
thought twenty pills would be enough for both of us. Luckily I found
the Trevor Project before ever wanting to commit suicide again. Their
volunteers gave me the help I needed at a time that I needed it the
most. I found local resources and now am a volunteer for The Trevor
Projects Youth Advisory Council.
Washington, DC: - Gay students more likely to consider suicide: study. Survey shows D.C. gay youth face bullying, harassment (2008). "30.6 percent of gay teens considered suicide in the previous year,
28.9 percent made a plan to commit suicide and 32.6 percent attempted
suicide. That compares to 13.8 percent, 12.1 percent and 8.6 percent
respectively in those same categories for their straight counterparts. DC 2007 High School YRBS: Baseline Findings for GLBQ Items (PDF Download N/A: removed from website) - Serious Issues for Gay Teens Emerge in Youth Risk Behavior Survey 2008, Related data given). - Gay man’s death ruled suicide
(2010): The D.C. Medical Examiner’s office disclosed Monday that Mark
Gower, the 26-year-old gay man found dead in his apartment in the
city’s Mount Pleasant neighborhood last month, took his own life...
Gower, a native of Oregon, worked as an employee of the Sephora
cosmetics store in Reston, Va. and was a part-time dancer at Secrets, a
D.C. gay nightclub.
Virginia / West Virginia: - Out Of The Closet And Out Of The Family: - At
the hospital a doctor observes the following after a closeted lesbian youth
had attempted suicide: "He looked at his parents with hatred in his eyes
'my sister who I love could have died today. You sound as If you would
rather her be dead than gay.'" The doctor then told his "significant other"
about the event who, in turn, recalled his own problems as a youth: "Before
long I was at the top of a huge hill, and instantly I knew that I no longer
wanted to live. I pressed the gas as hard as I could. I saw where there
was a sloping hill on the side of the road and steered the car off the
road. When I saw a large tree in the cars pathway I closed my eyes and
felt at peace for the first time in years." - Suicide of two young girls highlights the hurdles faced by gay youth. - Interview with Openly Gay Candidate for West Virginia Senate, Scott Regan- Funds Needed Now
(2010): West Virginia is a breeding ground for gay hate, pursued with a
vigor that is reminiscent of a corporate mission statement; it is
taught via religious ideology with crime perpetuated as a result.
New Virginia Governor Quietly Removes Gays From Anti-Discrimination Policy (2010). - WVU promotes fairness as host and co-sponsor of statewide conference, film screenings
(2010): The recent suicide of a gay college student in New Jersey
following his public humiliation reinforces the immediate need to
examine our common sense of justice, decency and fairness, said
Jennifer McIntosh, executive officer for the President’s Office for
Social Justice at West Virginia University... Fairness West Virginia,
an advocacy organization that works for the fair treatment and civil
rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender West Virginians, is
organizing and sponsoring the conference. This will be the
organization’s first statewide leadership conference. - GLSEN - gay activist group - targets 60 Virginia middle schools
(2010): Should we allow gay advocacy groups to access our children
through public schools to persuade them to make a choice concerning
their sexuality during the teen years? I say no. But don't just take it
from a mom like me. Read what the foremost lesbian thinker of our time
- Camille Paglia - has written..
Georgia: Youth Suicide Prevention (From Atlanta's YouthPride.org): For many years, we have known that young people, particularly GLBTQ youth, are at an increased risk of committing suicide... A Gay Teen Suicide Note
(Must Scroll). Introduction to Suicide Note: "The following suicide
note was written by Steven, a gay 16-year-old high school student.
After he wrote this note he attempted suicide by taking an overdose of
medication. He survived. He was hospitalized, treated, and not long
after his suicide attempt, moved with his family to another state.
Steven was suffering from severe depression when he wrote this note.
Anyone who was mistreated, bullied, threatened, and emotionally
tortured like Steven could very easily become severely depressed - and
suicidal. The note has been left intact, complete with misspellings,
grammatical errors, and profanity, except for inserting "[name
removed]" in the place of some names. Steven's suicide note is
extremely disquieting to read. And it is one more reminder of the
outrageous bullying LGBTQ youth endure."
Black Church Summit Takes Stand Against Anti-Gay Discrimination:
"Another example of changing attitudes and principled stands among the
participating clergy was Rev. Ken Samuel, pastor at the Victory for the
World church in Stone Mountain, Georgia. Samuel also used to condemn
homosexuality from the pulpit, but he says that he changed his views as
he recalled a childhood friend who committed suicide because he felt
ostracized by his church for his homosexuality. When Samuel began to
preach against anti-gay discrimination, he lost about half of the 5,000
members of his mega-church, but he stood his ground."
North Carolina: Bad Days For Gay Teenagers:
"Someone I know committed suicide this past Father's Day. His dad had
kicked him out of the house because he was gay. He was just a kid, a
teenage boy, on the way to becoming a young man. He liked horror and
action movies. He moved around and lived with friends. He worked
various low-income jobs to get by. On Father's Day, he decided there
was no place for him in this world, so he killed himself." - Homophobic Language and Verbal Harassment in North Carolina High Schools (2006, Report).
South Carolina: Principal Censors Pro-Gay School Paper (2008).
Michigan:
Pastor Youngchild (MCC
Church, Battle Creek, Michigan) reports on his experiences with
being contacted by GLB youth in a
letter ot the Battle Creek Inquirer (Aug. 22, 1999): "...within
the first 6 months alone of SOCMCC's existence, 5 different teenagers put
out the effort, borne of desperation, to contact me and discuss their feelings...
their experiences of discovering their gay or lesbian or bisexual orientation...
and most pointedly their experiences of hatred and even violence being
directed at and against them in our Battle Creek Public School system,
not only by a number of students but even by some teachers, simply for
being "queer." Five kids in our first 6 months, after 15 years of
silence in my previous ministry, because we appeared safe enough to them
to seek out. Three of those teens had attempted suicide. One
of them had tried three times.
God gave me a gay son . . . and I did not always think it a blessing
(2004): So on this Saturday morning Mark realized nothing really
mattered anymore. It could only get worse. And while it frightened him
-- having considered it for quite a long time -- he also knew how he
could fix it. The only way to confront this demon was to end it all.
Nobody would understand it anyway. He didn't understand it. But he knew
he was gay, and he knew being gay was an abomination. So he would put
an end to his agony. Suicide, he had decided, would be less painful to
his family than revealing to them who he really was... Mark defied all
the popular stereotypes I believed about what being gay means. I was
sure I could recognize a gay person a mile off. But my son was just too
masculine. He never displayed the effeminate traits that I was certain
a homosexual male would exhibit... Nothing during Mark's childhood
indicated any sign of homosexuality. There was none of the verbal
violence many young gay people endure from earliest childhood; no
derisive jeering, no "faggot" or "queer" talk. He was seemingly happy,
well-adjusted and "straight."... Not only was I unaware, but my
pontificating moral certitude had actually been adding to his anguish.
Iwas unwittingly encouraging my son toward suicide.
Florida: - School Can't Tolerate Gay Tolerance Club (2007).
Depression, isolation, rejection lead many gay youths to attempt suicide
(2009): Switchboard of Miami, Miami-Dade's crisis center, launched a
gay suicide hotline in 2005. It became the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and
Transgender Suicide Hotline in 2006. Between July 1, 2007, and June 30,
2008, Switchboard took about 400 calls from people identifying
themselves as gay, including 56 that counselors declared ''crisis
calls,'' or people at immediate risk. It's not just young gay people
contemplating suicide, said Ed Straub Jr., a Switchboard board member
who founded the hotline. ''In the first year of our program, . . . 52
percent of the people calling the Switchboard were between the ages 35
and 59,'' he said. Both gay men and lesbians are at risk.
''Absolutely,'' Straub said. ``In fact, women are twice as likely to
consider suicide as men, even though the number of male suicides is
higher.'' The gay hotline has a $30,000 annual budget, with funding
from groups including Dade Community Foundation and private donors.
''We try to spend half or a third of that in advertising,'' Straub
said. ``We advertise mostly in the local gay press. That increases the
call volume back to Switchboard.'' Straub became involved with suicide prevention after three friends killed themselves in 2004.
``I'm like a lightning rod. People come to me. I come to the bars. We
talk at cocktail parties. On Lincoln Road. People want to open up about
it. It's amazing how many people are touched by suicide.'' Straub said
he has observed three factors that often contribute to gay suicide
attempts: • Financial and health-related issues. • Drug and alcohol
use. • Loneliness or feeling unable to achieve life goals.
Alaska: Alaska Suicide Follow-back Study Final Report: Study period September 1, 2003 to August 31, 2006 - 426 suicides (PDF Download): "4% were involved in a homosexual relationship." Note: Most homosexual people may not be in relationships.
Guam:
Pinhey
TK, Millman SR (2004).
Asian/Pacific
Islander Adolescent Sexual Orientation
and
Suicide Risk in Guam. American Journal of Public Health,
94(7): 1204-1206.
(Abstract)
Full Text:
PDF
Download.
The Odds
for GB Males Attempting Suicide in the Past year is About Five Times
Greater than Odds For Other Males. Estimated by Web Page
Author: Risk Ratio = 3.2 - 43.5% of GB males attempted
suicide,
versus 13.5% for other males. For all Males: 14.5%.
3.5% of
674 males studied = GB Males. A profile of Suicide on Guam (2009): GLB youth mentioned.
Hawaii:
- Island
Voices: Gay Youth Still at Risk - by Kauanoe Bombard (1998).
Canada:
Reaching
Out: A Report on Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Issues in Canada. Prepared
for the United Church of Canada, EGALE. "As a society, we have
been slowly killing these children over a period of years. With their suicides,
they are simply finishing the job we started." - In
Canada, a bright and diligent 14-year-old student leapt to his death from
a bridge (2002). He left a seven-page suicide note saying he was killing himself
because his classmates tormented him by calling him "gay" or "faggot". - Gay teens 'terrorized' in Canada's schools (2009).
Egale Canada. (2009). Youth speak up about homophobia and transphobia. PDF
Download. Summary:
A recent national survey on homophobia in Canadian schools conducted by
Egale Canada (2009) found that schools can be a hostile environment for
sexual minority youth. The survey involved almost 1700 students from
across Canada. Among the findings: • Almost three quarters (73%) of
LGBTQ students felt unsafe in at least one place at school (i.e.,
change rooms, washrooms, hallways). • Over a quarter (28.5%) of LGBTQ
students said that they had skipped school because they felt unsafe
compared to 8.4% of non-LGBTQ students. • Over three quarters (76.7%)
of students heard homophobic expressions like “that’s so gay” every day
at school. • About half (50.6%) of LGBTQ students agreed or somewhat
agreed with the statement “It is hard for me to feel accepted at my
school” compared to 19.3% of non-LGBTQ students. • Six out of ten LGBTQ
students said that they had been verbally harassed about their sexual
orientation. • One in four LGB students reported that they had been
physically harassed about their sexual orientation (EgaleCanada, 2009).
Western
Canada:- "..the
life I lived as a gay man was too disappointing and held too much tragedy.
Of my six other friends, two died of AIDS related illnesses, one of suicide,
and another attempted suicide." (1989) - Suicide
of an Alberta gay teenager (1994). - Canada:
Generally homonegative environments (including in schools) are described
leading to many problems for GLBT adolescents, including suicidal problems.
- Social
Determinants of Suicide Attempts in a Cohort of Young Men Who Have Sex
With Men (PDF Download).(Related Published Paper: Correlates of suicide attempts in an open cohort of young men who have sex with men.)
Calgary,
Canada (From the files of Pierre Tremblay): Five parents
of male adolescents who had committed suicide (within about a one-year
period) were part of a group - SPAN - concerned about the youth suicide
problem. Two youngest boys (about age 13) had a history of gender nonconformity
and related peer problems. One hung himself in jail after having been arrested,
and after having become a clone who was not feminine-like; his mother
reported that he had been in the "feminine" category since a very young
age. A CTV's W-5 program reported that the other suicide victim was deemed
"a sissy" by peers and was treated accordingly. A 17-year-old male
suicide victim was discovered to be homosexually oriented from a female
friend, and he was definitely a Save-The-World
kid given the information supplied by his mother. The fourth was Bobby
Steele, and Information was not solicited or received on the fifth
suicide victim. Near the end of 1996, I learned about the suicide of a
male youth soon after he had made contact with a GLB youth group
(A related
Article, but Bobby's name is not mentioned.). In 1997, I met a 20-year-old
gay male who had just come out and was seeking a relationship with someone.
He met a gay male, became lovers, and they moved to a location a few hundred
miles from Calgary. When he returned, he reported that his boyfriend had
attempted to kill him, after he had expressed a desire to end the relationship.
He had done this by driving his vehicle into an 80-foot ravine, but both
survived. If they had died, however, it may have resulted in the belief
that they committed suicide. In August 1998, I learned about a 35-year-old
Vancouver gay male (schizophrenic, but did not apparently have suicidal
problems) who committed suicide by exiting from a 8th-floor window. A number
of factors may have been implicated in this suicide, including the end
of a relationship with another gay male (I have known for 12 years) about
a month before the suicide, but he was not HIV-positive. I recently learned
that he had gone to a hospital about two hours before his death but a lack
of space precluded his admission.
From
Lloydminster, Alberta, via Edmonton's
GLB Times. Ten magazine: Often enough someone knows about the homosexual
orientation of a suicide victim:
"Dear Editor... That first night of my stay in North Battleford, I was
stunned to learn that I was only the second of six SUICIDE/ATTEMPTS for
Lloydminster. It was disconcerting to find that two were successful, one
of them being a guy I had slept with on a regular basis." Information supplied
about another suicide known to him: "While I recovered, another young man
took his own life just ten days ago. It would seem that his farewell note
said it all too clearly for him "that there was nothing gay about being
GAY!" - Being
Gay in Rural Alberta: "I would still be drinking a lot. I would
very much be avoiding (the issue)," he says, stating in all seriousness
that, "Suicide was an option."
Ontario: - Keeping Our Children Safe: Adolescent Suicide and Sexual Orientation (In: Homosexuality and the Catholic High School: A compilation of newsletters with new material, 2001, Aternate Link):
The high rate of suicide among homosexual adolescents and youth is a
phenomenon which has only recently been studied... Unlike their
heterosexual peers, most gay teens have neither social approval, family
support, positive role models, nor safe social opportunities to assist
them in their maturational struggle... The response awaiting a gay teen
in the schools and community is no better than in the family... The
studies show (9), (10) that the gay teens that have the highest risk
for suicidal actions are those whom because of appearance or mannerisms
are early suspected of being homosexual or who at an early age reveal
their sexual orientation... Still for school aged children emerging in
awareness of their homosexual orientation, homophobia is the context at
home and in school within which feelings of self worth, morality and
affection are formed. For a gay student homophobia in an educational
setting is proof that school is not a safe place to demonstrate a
positive sense of self and form affectionate relationships, as do other
students. The result is isolation, despair, arrested emotional growth,
loss of faith, and for somesuicide.
British
Columbia: - BC
Teen Suicide Aftermath: Conflict Ensues Over Prevention N/A.
- B.C. Study
Shows Gay Youth Face High Suicide Risk (June 14, 1999, Alternate Link). - Study: Lesbian Teens More Likely To Attempt Suicide (2006, Alternate Link):
(Vancouver, British Columbia) A study of teenagers in British Columbia
schools has found that lesbian teens are far more likely to attempt
suicide than gay teens or heterosexual teens. The survey was conducted
by the McCreary Center Society an organization that advocates for young
people in the province. The researchers report that 38 per cent of
teenage lesbians and 30.4 per cent of bisexual girls said they had
attempted suicide in the previous year, compared to 8.2 per cent of
heterosexual girls. They also found that 8.8 per cent of gay
teens, 2.8 per cent of bisexual boys [Correction, 12.8%, See: B.C. researcher says American group distorting her research on teen (2006)] and 3.3 per cent of heterosexual boys said they had attempted suicide. - Focus on the Family distorts work of University of British Columbia researcher. - Sexual Orientation, Risk and Resilience Study (2005, Alternate Link). - Proposed Framework for GLBT Youth Suicide and Abuse Prevention (2005, PDF Download).
British Columbia's 2008 Adolescent Health Survey (PDF Download,
6 megs): "86% of students identified as heterosexual, 7% as mostly
heterosexual, 2% as bisexual, and less than 1% as either mostly
homosexual or homosexual (gay or lesbian). The remaining 4% were “not
sure.” ... Those at greater risk of having attempted suicide: ...
Aboriginal youth (11% vs. 4% non-Aboriginal), lesbian, gay and bisexual
youth (28% vs. 4% heterosexual: 7-times the risk), obese youth (10% vs. 4% healthy
weight) and youth with a health condition or disability (16% vs. 4%
without a disability)... physically abused (15% vs. 3%) or sexually
abused (22% vs. 4%). - Students Plan Cross-Dressing Protest of Homophobic School District
(2010): Students at a school in British Columbia feel that homophobia
from parents and the school district is behind the decision to cancel
or reschedule several events aimed at promoting tolerance, so they've
decided to cross-dress on Friday in protest. - One In 10 Students Gay
(2007): A Kelowna organization says Central Okanagan schools are unsafe
for gay students and has the numbers to back up its claim. The Indigo
Spirit of Awareness Society (ISAS) says up to 10 per cent of the
Central Okanagan student population is either gay, lesbian or bisexual
and that many of those students do not feel safe in their schools.
Child Death Review Unit, BC Coroners Service (2008). "Looking
for Something to Look Forward to" (a B.C. youth who died by suicide)
... A Five-Year Retrospective Review of Child and Youth Suicide in B.C.
: In the five-year period between January 1, 2003, and December 31,
2007, 81 children and youth died by suicide in British Columbia. When
this project was initiated, 66 of these cases were closed and 15
remained open and under investigation. The Child Death Review Unit’s
review of the 66 closed cases resulted in the following findings: •
Older youth (age 17–18 years), males, Aboriginal children and youth,
and gay, lesbian and bisexual children and youth, as well as those who
were questioning their sexuality, were at increased risk of suicide... Sexual orientation:
Four children and youth identified as gay, lesbian or bisexual. Three
other children and youth had been questioning their sexual orientation
in the months prior to death.
Maritime
Provinces: - High
school confidential: Gays and lesbians in Nova Scotia high schools (1991).
- New
Brunswick teachers have decided to fight homophobia in the province's schools (2001). - Nova Scotia Strategic Framework to Address Suicide (2006, GLBT Issues Noted).
Quebec:
- Déficiente,
la prévention du suicide chez les gais: "Si l'on souhaite
un jour franchement s'attaquer à la question du suicide au Québec,
il faudra commencer par cerner l'une de ses cibles les plus vulnérables,
les homosexuels." Préfère-t-on
encore les voir morts ? ou Le suicide chez les jeunes qui vivent l'homosexualité.
- Le
suicide chez les gais et lesbiennes Suicide-Action Montréal s'implique
davantage. - Le
phénomène du suicide au Québec et l'homosexualité:
"On ne peut parler d’homosexualité sans mentionner l’homophobie.
On sait maintenant avec certitude que le fait d’avoir à vivre le
harcèlement répété des homophobes à
leur endroit est une cause très importante de tentative de suicide,
chez les jeunes garçons en particulier. L’homophobie est très
répandue : un autre problème de société." -
L’urgence d’agir: La prévention du suicide chez les personnes homosexuelles:
Une question de santé mentale: Rapport d’un groupe de réflexion
initié par Gai Écoute (PDF
Download)
Quebec
was the first major jurisdiction in North America (province, state, or
country) to include "sexual orientation in their charter of rights (1977).
Homophobia and related abuses remain rampant, however, as reported in Quand
l'autre en soi grandit: les difficultés à vivre l'homosexualité
à l'adolescence - Bill Ryan et Jean-Yves Frappier (L'adolescence:
une réalité méconnue). French Canadian GLBT adolescents
have all the problems of their English counterparts, including attending
highly homo-negative schools where administrations have gone as far as
stating: "We do not want any homosexuals here!" "Peu après, une
travailleuse sociale contactée par Pierre et sa famille recevra
le même type de réponse de la part de la direction de l'école:
"On ne veut pas d'homosexuels ici!" Quebec and Alberta have a history of
having the highest youth suicide rates in Canada. - Suicide
an ongoing issue in the gay community. - L’homosexualité
vue par les Québécoises et les Québécois:
Les trois quarts de la population se disent ouverts et tolérants.
- Suicide
and GLB Youth - A document prepared by Project 10 of Montreal exploring
the psycho-social and counselling issues related to suicide among gay,
lesbian and bisexual youth N/A (PDF Download Available).
Avril
2002 (Must Scroll): "Un
sondage en ligne réalisé par Citegay.com propose quelques
données chiffrées sur la perception de l'homosexualité
durant l'adolescence. Sur 6308 votes, 5,8% considèrent que la perception
de leur homosexualité les ont amené à tenter de se
suicider, 10,4% disent avoir envisagé le suicide. La perception
de leur homosexualité fut une cause de souffrance pour 54,1% ( soit
3410 personnes). Pour seulement 12,6% de personnes participant au sondage,
elle fut source d'épanouissement. Pour 10,7 %, la perception de
leur homosexualité durant leur adolescence leur fut indifférente...
Qui oserait dire que l'homosexualité ne pose pas problème
chez les jeunes, et qu'une "homosexualité" traitée à
l'école n'est pas une urgence sociale?" - Adolescence
et homosexualité: souffrance, tabou social et inertie éducative:
"...ton homosexualité...a été une cause
de souffrance: 53.4%"
Mort
ou Fif: Contexte et mobiles de tentatives de suicide chez les adolescents
et jeunes hommes homosexuels ou identifiés comme tels. Excerpts:
Nicolas
était depuis des années la cible de propos blessants et homophobes...
- Les
adolescents homosexuels: profils et scénarios: Deux profils.
- Dans
« Mort ou fif » (« fif » est l'équivalent
de « pédé » en québécois), après
avoir recueilli des témoignages de jeunes homosexuels qui parlent
de leurs tentatives de suicide, le chercheur québécois Michel
Dorais analyse le motif et le contexte de ces actes de désespoir.
- Homsexualité
et Suicide: Michel Dorais: Mort ou fif: La face cachée du suicide
chez les garçons. - État de la question et pistes de
prévention: Synthèse de la journée d’étude
organisée le 17 juillet 2001 (PDF
Download) (Related Information): Les jeunes gays et le suicide, Michel Dorais. - Mort
ou fif (Must Scroll): "Tous les jeunes qui découvrent leur homosexualité
ne font pas une tentative de suicide. Mais cette circonstance multiplie
par 16 le risque de passage à l’acte. Il n’y a rien d’étonnant
à cela, tant la stigmatisation sociale est encore forte concernant
cette orientation sexuelle. Chaque année, des dizaines de jeunes
continuent de mourir parce qu’ils se croient seuls au monde ou monstrueux
et sont victimes de l’intolérance, de l’incompréhension et,
pour tout dire, de la bêtise de leurs contemporains..."
Le
rejet social tue parfois (2001): Conférence sur le suicide et les
jeunes hommes, le mercredi 14 février, au Grand Salon du pavillon
Maurice-Pollack. "La conférence du Groupe de prévention du
suicide, intitulée: ""Quand t'es seul au monde": rejet social et
suicide chez les jeunes hommes"..." - Masculinisme
et suicide chez les hommes (2003). - Suicide:
"J'entends montrer dans ce bref article que les jeunes qui vivent l'homosexualité
présentent de multiples facteurs de risque en ce qui concerne le
suicide. Bien sûr, cela ne signifie pas que tous les jeunes qui vivent
l'homosexualité ou qui s'identifient comme étant homosexuels
deviennent tous suicidaires, mais que cette population présente
des caractéristiques reconnues pour accroître la vulnérabilité
personnelle et sociale..."
Pas facile d'afficher son homosexualité sans choquer:
Quelque temps plus tard, il tenta de s'enlever la vie en bouchant le
tuyau d'échappement de sa voiture. "L'intervenante a
rappelé trois fois pour me garder éveillé. Une
fois à l'hôpital, on m'a dit que si les secours
étaient arrivés 15 minutes plus tard, c'était
fini", confie Marc. Marie-Line St-Arnaud, directrice
générale de Suicide Alerte, confirme que le rejet et les
pressions sociales rendent les homosexuels plus vulnérables aux
tentatives de suicide. "Il y a plus de détresse et les
homosexuels sont confrontés à de nombreux
stéréotypes et préjugés. Nous tenterons de
l'aider dans l'immédiat, mais la personne devra aller chercher
de l'aide", dit-elle...
Le
phénomène du suicide chez les jeunes hommes: "L'auteure
traite ce délicat sujet en exploitant des entrevues de trois jeunes
hommes dont deux sont homosexuels. On pourrait s'étonner de l'insistance
mise sur l'homosexualité comme facteur déterminant. En fait,
ces propos rejoignent des études qui montrent que les homosexuels,
les victimes d'agressions sexuelles et les autochtones sont les principaux
candidats au suicide..." - Suicide chez les jeunes homosexuels : Le cercle vicieux. - Comment les parents peuvent contribuer à la prévention
du suicide et à la lutte contre l’homophobie auprès de
leur enfant et dans leur milieu (PDF).
From
"Index N/A"
- L'hebdo gai du Québec - October, 98 - Two suicide related articles:
La
corde au cou and L’homosexualité:
facteur de risque, oui ou non? Cases are noted to reveal
that French Canadian gay boys are also attempting suicide for reasons related
to their sexual orientation: lack of self-acceptance to abuse by others.
One - Pierre - totaled a car in his attempt to kill himself by driving
a car at 140 k/hr down a 150-feet embankment and a seat belt was not being
used in the hope that death would result. Projet 10 - reports dealing with
10 to 15 suicide attempters per year, while a youth group - Jeunesse
Lambda - somewhat minimized the problem. In an inadvertent way, however,
the youth group had presented Pierre (suicide attempt described above)
with a situation which precipitated his decision to kill himself. [In Calgary,
in 1996 or 1997 - a male had attended a GLB youth group once and, soon
after, committed suicide.] - Carrefour
Intervention Suicide (Québec): - La
problématique du suicide dans les populations gaie, lesbienne et
bisexuelle.
Le
suicide et l'homosexualité. - Le
suicide chez les jeunes hommes homosexuels (2001, Alternate Link). - Le
suicide chez les gais et lesbiennes. - Le
suicide chez les jeunes gais: Gai Écoute à l’origine de la
première recherche québécoise portant sur le suicide
chez les jeunes gais et bisexuels. - Une
réalité à reconnaître: le suicide chez les jeunes
gais. - Vous
(Claude Charron) avez fait un reportage percutant sur le suicide chez les
jeunes gais.Et vous êtes associé à l’organisme Gai
Ecoute. C’est important pour vous? - Histoire
de vie: "Je voudrais tellement être comme tout le monde, avoir
femme et enfants, mais les hommes m'attirent...Au début de la vingtaine,
des pro-blèmes de santé mentale se révèlent
de plus en plus chez Denis. Il devient étrange et imprévisible.
Les membres de sa famille sont inquiets, on le sent souffrir beaucoup moralement.
Durant deux ou trois ans, ses proches le voient dégringoler, jusqu'au
jour où il devra être hospitalisé en psychiatrie. Là,
on conclut à un diagnostic de schizophrénie. À partir
du début de la vingtaine et jusqu'à sa mort, Denis sera épisodiquement
suivi en psychiatrie. Régulièrement, il devra faire de nouveaux
séjours à l'hôpital psychiatrique...La confusion sur
son orientation sexuelle : un obstacle à la « normalité
» de Denis... Pour Denis, vivre une vie « normale »,
c'est entretenir des rapports amoureux avec une personne de l'autre sexe.
Au-dedans de lui-même, il n'en est pas moins confronté à
la réalité complexe et ambivalente de sa libido. Son orientation
sexuelle est confuse. Tout comme il a aimé avoir des relations hétérosexuelles,
les hommes l'attirent et l'excitent... Deux ou trois ans avant de se suicider,
il forme un couple avec un jeune homme et il fréquente des bars
gais. À ses proches, il révèle alors clairement ses
tendances. Cette expérience de vie commune se termine au bout de
quelques mois. Selon sa famille, « ...c'était difficile à
vivre pour Denis d'être ainsi tiraillé sexuellement et de
ne pas répondre aux normes de la société ».
Le
suicide chez les gais; la
Cohorte Oméga signale de nouvelles statistiques qui soulèvent
des inquiétudes: "La haute prévalence des idées
suicidaires et des tentatives de suicide chez les hommes gais montréalais
ainsi que les liens observés entre ces événements
et l'acceptation personnelle et sociale de leur orientation sexuelle, soulignent
l'urgence d'inclure ces préoccupations de façon formelle
aux priorités de santé», termine le communiqué."
- Forte
tendance suicidaire chez les homosexuels: (Must Scroll) Pas moins
de 36% des hommes homosexuels participant à un vaste ensemble de
recherches sur le sida ont déjà tenté de s'enlever
la vie, révèle la première étude québécoise
qui établit des liens évidents entre l'homosexualité
et l'incidence du suicide... Plus encore, près de 72% des participants
ont pensé au moins une fois en finir avec la vie, révèle
l'étude." - Suicide
et coming-out chez les gais et bisexuels montréalais. Ya-t-il
un lien? "Parmi nos participants [Cohorte Oméga], 71,3 %
déclarent qu’il leur est arrivé au moins une fois d’avoir
des idées suicidaires (23,5 %, une seule fois et 47,8 %, plus
d’une fois). L’âge moyen à ce premier événement
est de 19 ans (18,7 ans) alors que chez ceux qui rapportent avoir songé
à se suicider plus d’une fois, l’âge moyen au dernier événement
est de 30 ans (29,9 ans)." - Taux
record de tentatives de suicide chez les homosexuels.
L'affaire
Pinard: "Le 15 mars 2000, monsieur Daniel Pinard... faisait publiquement
son ''coming-out'' à l'émission Les Francs Tireurs... révélant
son homosexualité, et ceci, à titre de porte-parole pour
le mouvement Gai-Écoute qui tente de sensibiliser la population
au phénomène grandissant du suicide chez les jeunes gais.
Il y dénonçait la méchanceté gratuite de certains
humoristes québécois, ne se contentant pas de rire des minorités,
mais pointant directement du doigt des personnalités connues. -
Demystifying Homosexuality in Schools in the Chaudière-Appalachia
Region: An Aid to Intervention, 1997 (PDF
Download) (Download Page)
Special Issue on "Sexual
Orientation" in "Vis-à-vie" by the Quebec Association of Suicidology
is now available online. La
revue le Vis-à-vie, vol. 10 nº 2, 2000: Le thème
de ce numéro est « Suicide et orientations sexuelles »:
Un
double tabou. - Orientations
homosexuelles ou bisexuelles chez les jeunes présentant des problèmes
suicidaires: recherche, problématique et propositions. - La
honte d'être. - Mort
ou fif, différence assassinée. - Événements
suicidaires chez les hommes gais. - Gai
écoute, 20 ans d'espoir. - Suicide-Action
Montréal et Gai écoute : un projet conjoint de formation
et de sensibilisation. - L'intervention
dans Chaudière-Appalaches. - Histoire
de vie. Note: The English version of "Orientations homosexuelles
ou bisexuelles chez les jeunes présentant des problèmes suicidaires:
recherche, problématique et propositions" by Pierre Tremblay and
Richard Ramsay is available as "Suicidal
problems of youth with homosexual or bisexual orientations: research, problems,
and proposals.
Le
suicide des jeunes à orientation sexuelle non conventionnelle... -
L'amour
entre femmes dans l'Église catholique
par Débora et Judith, aux Éditions AdA Inc.: "On y retrouve
également des témoignages et des statistiques qu'on ose à
peine dévoiler concernant le suicide de trop nombreux gais et lesbiennes." - L’émergence des réalités
homosexuelles. Séminaire sur les chartes et les
différentes formes de discrimination Juges de la Cour du
Québec. Présentation de Laurent McCutcheon 17 septembre
2007. PDF., New Link
Documents
PDF: - Impact
du «Projet 10» sur le mieux-être sexuel de jeunes gais
et bisexuels. - Faire
les premiers pas - Un livret pour les jeunes gais, lesbiennes et biseuxuels
N/A. - Jeunes
gais/ lesbiennes 14-17 ans - Modèle d'intervention de groupe (ville
de Québec). - Le
suicide et l'orientation sexuelle. Document de Projet 10 Montréal
sur les aspects psychosociaux du suicide chez les jeunes gais, lesbiennes
et bisexuel(les). - Le
livre Blanc: La prévention du suicide. - Le
Suicide: Ce que vous devez savoir (PDF Document).
Australia / New Zealand:
Panel Presentation by Phong Nguyen (2004, PDF, Must Scroll: 'Living and Loving in Diversity' Conference Proceedings) First of all I would like to pay tribute the first people of the land and I also would like to pay tribute as a social worker in the Vietnamese community for many years and I think I’m also aware of other communities as well in multicultural communities. Today I would like to, before I say my words, I would like to pay tribute to all the young people who have died, committed suicide because of who they were. Unfortunately in some cases the only time they can say who they were was through a note after they have died and to say that they are who they were - Gay or Lesbian - and so I’d like to pay tribute to them and I think we should at conferences like this going forward to have a minute of silence to pay tribute to those young who have died becausethe only way they can show their truth, who they are, their identity is through death so I would like to pay tribute to that.
Bisexuals
at high risk for mental health problems and suicide: Homosexuals
have poorer mental health than heterosexuals. Study: "Sexual orientation
and mental health: results from a community survey of young and middle-aged
adults." Full
Text. - PubMed
Abstract. Study results used as part of a presentation of 'higher risk"
status for individuals not belonging to socially constructed categories... People in 'No Man's Land':
Link
to PowerPoint Presentation. - Towards a sociocultural analysis of youth
suicide: Researching the everyday narratives of urban and regional communities
(PDF
Download, Must Scroll, Archive Link):
For example, the study will explore the nature of beliefs produced
through living with youth unemployment, a difficult home life or being
gay in an urban/rural community... Research suggests that young
gay/lesbian/bisexual people experience homophobia and marginalisation,
both of whichare associated with increased risk of suicide attempts(Nicholas and Howard 1998).
Don't
Ask, Don't Tell: Hidden in the Crowd: The Need for Documenting Links between
Sexuality and Suicidal Behaviours among Young People, 2003 (PDF
Download, Alternate Link, Alternate Link) - Gay
and Lesbian Suicide (including youth suicide). - Rural
suicide and same-sex attracted youth: issues, interventions and implications
for rural counsellors (2003, PDF
Download, Alternate Link) (HTML
Copy) Rural and Remote Health (online), 2003: no. 222. Abstract:
"Recent research into same-sex attracted youth (SSAY) suicide and rural
youth suicide suggests there may be an association between the two. A literature
review explores this proposal. While contributing issues to rural SSAY
suicide, such as homophobia, isolation, availability of information, and
acknowledgement of issues are discussed, little hard evidence is found
to support the the rural and SSAY suicide connection. Further and on-going
research is recommended into this under-represented topic."
Australian
Government rejects anti-suicide poster: it presents being young &
gay/lesbian too positively N/A (Must scroll to locate information). - 'Out
of line' Judy sets back suicide prevention 50 years [for GLB youth]
(Not Available: A 1997 News item from Australian
Democrats). Youth and Sexuality Final Report available as Word
or Text Zip file at Freedom
Centre site: 'Here for Life' Youth Sexuality Project Executive Summary (Zip Word File N/A) and Final Report (Zip Word File N/A) Download Page (Gone Forever? Why?). - Health
and Support for Australian Gay Males. - Spirituality,
Sexuality & Suicide - bringing God & Spirituality out of the closet:
"Suicide? Well there's plenty of surveys and statistics about this and
the work of dozens of organisations trying to research, understand
and prevent it, like SPA and this conference. Remarkably though, few organisations
have included the gay population in their research, even though this sector
is one in which suicide ideation is often part of the gauntlet which
the young gay person may often face in their rocky process of coming out
as someone whose sexuality flies in the face of the heterosexist model
of the rest of the world around them."
Youth
suicide strategy evaluated (Sydney Star Observer, Issue 533) by By Sarah
Bacon (2002):"... the only project funded by the Strategy which dealt
specifically with gay and lesbian youth suicide issues was the Here For
Life Youth Sexuality Project (WA AIDS Council in conjunction with the Gay
and Lesbian Counselling Service) which received $250,000. Graham
Brown, the health promotion officer on the Here For Life Project, says
the project "went really well" considering the number of challenges - such
as political battles and homophobic backlash - they had to overcome. -
Australia's
Valuing Young Lives: Evaluation of the National Youth Suicide Prevention
Strategy (2000, As One PDF File). - Issues Paper: Mental health issues
for GLBTI Victorians (PDF
Download N/A: Brown, R., Perlesz, A., & Proctor, K., ‘Mental Health Issues for GLBTI Victorians,’
in What’s the Difference? Health Issues of Major Concern to Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex (GLBTI) Victorians.
Melbourne, Victoria (PDF Download, Download Page). Research Report prepared by the Ministerial
Advisory Committee on Gay and Lesbian Health. Published by Rural and
Regional Health and Aged Care Services Division Victorian Government
Department of Human Services)... Reaction to MACGLH discussion papers by Transgender Victoria (2002).
Suicide
Prevention Australia 8th Annual Conference 2001 - A Human Odyssey (6 -
9 April 2001) - Session (1) "Suicide in the Gay & Lesbian Community"
- Jonathan Nicholas: The Reach Out Program, Sydney - (90 minute workshop):
The incidences of suicide in the gay and lesbian community are dramatically
high. Many do not have expertise in counselling in this area. The first
in-depth Australian research into completed suicide within this community
sampling more than 400 people to the age of 30 has just been completed
with some dramatic findings. This workshop is a must for anyone working
with young people. - Self Harm and Suicide Risk for Same-Sex Attracted
Young People: A Family Perspective (Australian e-Journal for the Advancement
of Mental Health (AeJAMH), Vol. 1, Issue 1, 2002: PDF
Download, Alternate Link).
Self
Harm and Suicide Risk for Same-Sex Attracted Young People: A Family Perspective
(Australian e-Journal for the Advancement of Mental Health (AeJAMH), Vol.
1, Issue 1, 2002: PDF
Download). - Suicide
Prevention Australia 8th Annual Conference 2001 - A Human Odyssey (6 -
9 April 2001): Session (1) "Suicide in the Gay &
Lesbian Community" - Jonathan Nicholas: The Reach Out Program, Sydney -
(90 minute workshop): The incidences of suicide in the gay and lesbian
community are dramatically high. Many do not have expertise in counselling
in this area. The first in-depth Australian research into completed
suicide within this community sampling more than 400 people to the age
of 30 has just been completed with some dramatic findings. This workshop
is a must for anyone working with young people. - Nicholas J, Howard J (2001). Same-Sex Attracted Youth Suicide: Why are we still talking about it?
Presented at the Suicide Prevention Australia National Conference,
Sydney, April. The PowerPoint presentation was made available to the
authors by John Howard. Study results also presented a 2006 Suicide
Prevention Day Forum. PDF.
Fergusson DM, Horwood LJ, Ridder EM, Beautrais AL (2005). Sexual orientation and mental health in a birth cohort of young adults. Psychological Medicine, 35: 971-981 (PDF Download, Download Page):
"Cohort members with a predominantly homosexual orientation had rates
of mental disorder and suicidal behaviours that were between 1.5 to 12
times higher than for those with an exclusively heterosexual
orientation. These associations persisted after adjustment for
confounding. The associations between sexual orientation and mental
health were more marked for males than females."
Suicide
and Self-harm (2002): "Suicide is a tragedy
which occurs all too often and which can prevented. This book examines
Australia's suicide rate and focuses on the groups most at risk - young
people; middle-aged men; Aboriginal people; gays and lesbians; people from
rural and remote communities; and the elderly. This book also explores
the risk factors and warning signs for people who self-harm, and for those
who attempt suicide; the myths of suicide; treatments for depression; understanding
suicide and developing prevention strategies; and how to deal with the
grief of losing someone who has taken their own life." - Jorm AF, Korten AE, Rodgers
B, Jacomb PA, Christensen H (2002).
Sexual orientation and mental
health: results from a community survey of young and middle-aged adults.
British Journal of Psychiatry. 180: 423-7.
PubMed
Abstract.
Australian study: "A community survey
of 4824 adults was carried out in Canberra, Australia... Results: The
bisexual group was highest on measures of anxiety, depression and
negative affect, with the homosexual group falling between the other
two groups. Both the bisexual and homosexual groups were high on
suicidality. Bisexuals also had more current adverse life events,
greater childhood adversity, less positive support from family, more
negative support from friends and a higher frequency of financial
problems. Homosexuals reported greater childhood adversity and less
positive support from family. Full Text.
Tasmania:
- Release
on Tas gay suicide study - 2.5 times more likely to be suicide
attempters (1998). - Gay
Youth Study: Government response Essential (Tasmania) N/A. - Under
21: Youth Suicide. - I
remember wanting to die and wanting others to feel the depth of my suffering
and hopelessness: Sticks and Stones May Break Bones, But Names Hurt Even
More (1999).
Outlinks
- Rural GLB Youth Network: - Summary:
Sexuality & Suicide: An Investigation of Health Compromising and Suicidal
Behaviours among Gay and Bisexual Male Youth
in Tasmania. - An Investigation of Health compromising and Suicidal
Behaviours among Gay and Bisexual Male Youth in Tasmania, Kent Fordham,
1998: "Following an earlier study which found that 10% a sample of rural
14-18 year olds report same sex attractions, a study in 1998 of a sample
of rural, regional and some urban 14-18 year old same sex attracted youth
by Lynne Hillier and Jenny Walsh from the Australian Research Centre in
Sex, Health and Society at La Trobe University found that 46% reported
verbal and physical abuse 70% of which occurred at school. 11% reported
IV drug use compared to 1% of all young people. They also report higher
rates of drinking and marijuana and heroin use. Only 5% of same sex attracted
youth sought help from counsellors and 14% from teachers." - Outlink
National Gay and Lesbian Rural Youth Project. - "Rural
youth suicide: the issue of male homosexuality" by Edward Green (Social
Change in Rural Australia, 1996).
Sexuality & Suicide (K.Fordham, Sexuality and Suicide: An Investigation of Health
Compromising and Suicidal Behaviours among Gay and Bisexual Male Youth
in Tasmania, Division of Community and Rural Health, Faculty of
Medicine, University of Tasmania, September 1998, pp. 1-78.
) Study Summary: The gay and bisexual men had seriously considered suicide at twice the
rate of the heterosexual men, and were more likely to have run away from
home, been arrested, been involved in prostitution, to have driven
while under the influence of alcohol and to have had a greater number of
sexual partners in the six months preceding the survey. The gay and
bisexual men generally reported lower levels of substance use than the
heterosexual sample, although the rates were higher than expected in
both groups. Twice as many gay and bisexual men were in a relationship compared with
the heterosexual men. They were twice as likely to live alone and half
as likely to be living with their parents. Consistently higher rates of health risk behaviours and
psychosocial stressors were measured among those gay and bisexual men
who had seriously considered suicide (suicide ideators), compared to
their gay and bisexual counterparts who had not considered attempting
suicide (non- suicide ideators). They were more likely to have run away
from home, engaged in high levels of teenage sexual activity, had unsafe
sex and been involved in prostitution. They were also more likely to
have regularly been in fights, been arrested, argued with parents and
teachers, lost friends as a result of coming out, been sexually abused
and been the victim of homophobic violence. The suicide ideators
consumed cigarettes, alcohol, marijuana and other illegal drugs more
than the non- suicide ideators. Compared to gay and bisexual non- suicide ideators, suicide
ideators had a later age of first awareness of same-sex attractions, and
a younger age of both self-labelling as gay or bisexual and first
same-sex sexual experience. Overall, the gay and bisexual men demonstrated a higher
prevalence of suicide risk factors than the heterosexual men.
Furthermore, the gay and bisexual men who considered suicide showed
higher rates of suicide risk factors than those who had not.
Rural gays in misery: Report. "Their misery often led them to alcohol
and drugs and even suicide." (Information was once available at the Reach
Out web site. Must register and use site's search engine). - Working
it Out - "Working It Out" Committee: Adressing Sexuality Issues. - Rural
youth suicide: convention, context and cure:
Speech by Chris Sidoti,
Human Rights Commissioner to the Australian College of Health Service
Executives
(SA) Seminar, Adelaide, 14 October 1999. - Rural suicide and same-sex
attracted youth: issues, interventions and implications for rural
counsellors (2003, PDF).
Tasmania: ...a
16 year old man, Captain of his Launceston high school, killed himself
last week after being constantly harassed for being gay (Sept. 1999).
He died because this society did everything it could to encouraged his
death and nothing to stop it. It instilled in him a deep and abiding sense
of shame and worthlessness. It filled his peers with a profound ill-will,
armed them with the words to inflict their malice, and permitted them to
attack. Then, having systematically made his young life hell, society just
as systematically denied him all hope. - Rodney
Croome Says Society is Encouraging Deaths: Youth Suicides Due to Narrow
Social-Sexual Pressures (1999): "Tasmanian gay activist, Rodney Croome condemned
what he described as the' tyranny of heterosexuality' at the launching
of the Victorian Law Foundation's new book, A Just Society?
Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender Health and Wellbeing Needs Assessment. Tasmanian Department of Health and Human Services’ Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender Reference Group (Blanch Consulting Pty Ltd., 2003, PDF):
Contemporary research indicates that health and wellbeing issues faced
by GLBT people include higher rates of suicide and drug and alcohol use
and are they are at increased risk of homelessness than the general
population. The research also finds that these health and wellbeing
issues are an outcome of homophobic/transphobic harassment and
discrimination... 4.7.1 Suicide: Studies indicate that a range
of factors is associated with increased suicide risk, though there is
much debate over the level of risk of suicidal behaviour and resultant
protective measures necessary. Whilst mental illness is considered one
of the highest risk factors, it is erroneous to assume that all
suicidal behaviour is connected to mental illness or mental health
problems... • A study of 403 gay men in Australia in 2000 indicated
that 27% experienced major depression; • A study of 200 lesbians in
Sydney (1992) found that 60% reported feeling depressed, 63% had
contemplated suicide and 30% attempted suicide30; • A study of the
transgender/transsexual group that found that 32% attempted suicide;
and • Department of Human Services Youth Suicide Task Force Report in
1998 found same-sex attracted young people (SSAY) in Victoria to be six
times more likely to attempt suicide than the population as a whole...
The results of the first Australian population-based study that
involved a comparison of the health status of young lesbians and
bisexual women with heterosexual women were released at the Health in
Difference 4 Conference in Sydney, November 2002. More than 9,000 young
women participated in the Women's Health Australia study and among its
findings were that young non-heterosexual women reported higher levels
of depression and anxiety than young heterosexual women and twice as
many non-heterosexual women reported that life was not worth living.
The Tasmanian Sexuality and Suicide paper32 found that more than twice
the proportion of the gay and bisexual male participants considered
suicide compared to heterosexual participants. This was found to
correlate with other studies about suicide ideation among gay and
bisexual male youths. The interviews conducted with sexual minority
young people in the North West (Working it Out) also found that
extremely low self-esteem and reactions or fears about coming out
directly contributed to suicidal thoughts and self-harm... [Tasmiania
citations: 32 Fordham, K, (1998) Sexuality & Suicide, An
Investigation of Health Compromising And Suicidal Behaviours Among Gay
and Bisexual Male Youth In Tasmania, University of Tasmania, Thesis
Study.33 Hogge, R. (1998) Working it Out, A Needs Analysis of Sexual Minority Youth in North West Tasmania]
Special Report: Queer Street Youth:
In an OUTinPerth special report, journalist Scott-Patrick Mitchell
examines how the rise in homelessness has affected queer street youth
in Western Australia: ‘When I first came out on the streets, I was
meeting say maybe one new kid a week, or even one a fortnight,’ says
Dwayne, a 24-year-old homeless gay man. ‘But now it seems to be getting
to the stage where it’s half a dozen to a dozen new people every week.’
... For those who are not only homeless but also queer – be that gay,
lesbian, bisexual, transsexual or transgender – the struggle to survive
on the street is often even harder... Esben Kass, from mobile youth
service Step One, agrees in part with Dwayne about the difficulties
GLBT street youth face. ‘We have quite an issue with a lot of same-sex
attracted young people entering into crisis accommodation because of
the harassment they get from the other kids. It contributes to them
returning to the streets. It [GLBT youth] is a difficult group to place
into accommodation services, especially if you are dealing with
transgender or any sort of those issues. Accommodation services just
seem to give up with that.’
Corboz J, Dowsett G, Mitchell A, Couch M, Agius P, Pitts M (2008, PDF).
Feeling Queer and Blue: A Review of the Literature on Depression and
Related Issues among Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Other Homosexually
Active People. A Report from the Australian Research Centre in Sex,
Health and Society, La Trobe University. Prepared for beyondblue: The
National Depression Initiative.
There is a pervasive tendency in the literature to exclude bisexual people or to obscure them by collapsing bisexual samples into gay, lesbian or same-sex-attracted categories. The studies that did explore bisexual people separately from homosexual people consistently showed that bisexuals have higher rates of depression or depressive symptoms than heterosexual people and, further, in some cases are at the same or even higher risk of depression than homosexuals. In an important study that analysed data from the Australian Longitudinal Study on Women’s Health, McNair et al. (2005) found that in a cohort of women aged 22 to 27 years, bisexual women showed consistently poorer mental health outcomes than exclusively heterosexual, bisexual and exclusively/mainly homosexual women on almost all measures. Further, in a cohort of women aged 50 to 55, mainly heterosexual women had the poorest mental health outcomes on all measures when compared with women in any other group. In another Australian study conducted in Canberra, Jorm et al. (2002) sampled both men and women and found that the bisexual group had significantly higher depressive symptom scores than the homosexual group which, in turn, had significantly higher depressive symptoms scores than the heterosexual group (respectively: 3.93 vs. 2.93 vs. 2.62, p < .001). These results are strongly confirmed by the ARCSHS studies. For instance, in the Writing Themselves in Again study (Hillier et al. 2005), young bisexual people were significantly more likely than homosexual respondents to report dissatisfaction with both themselves (23.3 percent vs. 14.5 percent, z = 4.02, p < .001) and their lives (17.2 percent vs. 6.7 percent, z = 6.26, p < .001). Overall, the literature suggests that higher rates of depression in non-heterosexual people may be slightly inflated due to even higher rates of depressive symptoms in bisexuals.
Ignored
to death: Representations of young gay men, lesbians and bisexuals
in Australian youth suicide policy and programs - 1996 (Alternate Link). - "A
[1998] mental health conference in Sydney addressing gay and lesbian youth
suicide has heard the problem is still largely ignored by governments and
rural communities." - Suicide
prevention projects Ignore Sexuality (1998). - Call
for action to combat youth-gay suicide rate (1998). - Gay
youth suicide prevention may be missing the mark (1999). - Youth
suicide in Australia: What are the causes and risk factors for suicide
among young people? Multiplicity of factors linked to youth suicide
(Homosexuality is not mentioned in the document "Youth suicide in
Australia - A Background Monograph". Is this an example of "being
ignored to
death"?). - The Australian Research Centre in Sex, Health and Society has published a report
"Don't ask, don't tell - Hidden in the crowd: the need for documenting
links between sexuality and suicidal behavious among young people" in
May 2003... Gay Issues continue to be ignored?: "The series on male
suicides and the letters following their publication (The Age, August
2003) all seem to have ignored one of the main at-risk groups - gay
males, particularly in the 15-24 year- old age group. Is this because
our society continues to be so homophobic or is it because the
mainstream media continue to ignore the issue? The recently issued
report: "Don't Ask Don't Tell - Hidden in the Crowd: Documenting the links between sexuality and suicidal behaviours among young people"
(Australian Research Centre in Sex, Health and Society, La Trobe
University, 2003) states that suicide is one of the leading causes of
death among 15-24 year olds in Australia. The report further states
that research in Australia has identified that same-sex attracted young
people may be up to six times more likely to attempt suicide than the
population in general, with those in rural areas being particularly at
risk. Nowhere in your reports or letters were these matters raised.
Maybe you should now spend some time on asking questions about these
at-risk young people in our communities - or are we now a society that
no longer worries about our younger people, particularly if they are
gay or lesbian?"
Ian's
goal to educate kids (1998): - Roberts, Australia's first leading sportsman
to declare his homosexuality, has received hundreds of letters from youths
frightened and bewildered about their sexuality. He proposed the development
of an education kit to be made available in all schools. "If people read
the letters I've had about kids being suicidal, and knowing people who
have committed suicide, you know it wouldn't be a problem to be introduced,"
he said. - A
challenge to the stereotypes (1997. Ian Roberts: Finding Out, by Paul Freeman):
"The social problem of homophobia, as Freeman shows, still remains, of
course. Gay youth are made homeless by being thrown out by intolerant parents;
gays are victims of hate crimes, verbal harassment and the assault of images
of heterosexuality as “normal”. All this drives some gay youth to suicide
attempts." - Ian Roberts slams Jason Akermanis over gay comments
(2010): And retired Olympic swimmer Daniel Kowalski has also attacked
comments from Akermanis, who controversially encouraged gay players to
stay in the closet... "One of the things that really upsets me is the
kids in the suburbs who aren't dealing with their sexuality. The gay
suicide rate is high. There are kids out there wanting advice and a
knucklehead says things like these.
Finding the Message in the Story
(2008): When I started thinking of writing articles about being young
and gay, I immediately became acutely aware of not lapsing into the
instances of cliché that dominate young and gay writing. I didn’t want
to be mentioning the “what about kids” question, or the “coming out”
saga, or the loneliness. With my intelligence and sophistication (yeah,
right), I believed I could rise above that shit. I was beyond that –
those thoughts and issues would offer me nothing. Many groups of
people, but none more so than arrogant teenagers, detest clichéd
emotional expression. They hate its contrived sentimentality, the
meaninglessness of the language teenagers use to describe their
feelings. They perceive the poems of the two girls who suicided in
Melbourne two months ago as pathetic, unintellectual, naïve and
immature... It is those who wage unconditional war on the cliché that
we should be worried about. Those who believe emotional expression can
only be validated by a standard of what they deem “artistry” are
denying themselves a body of artistic possibilities from which they
could really benefit. I think this is especially valid for gay boys and
girls in high schools, who are often lonely and isolated from any
prospect of a relationship but who might not seek the stories of those
who have experienced the same pains. Opening our minds can yield
valuable reassurance, and those kids need all the reassurance they can
get.
I’m From Sydney, Australia (2009): I’ve
always known that I was gay. Well before I had even heard the word, or
knew its full implications. I never believed it to be wrong, how could
love be so? But growing up in a small country town with a combination
of conservative Catholic parents and religious schooling,... It was
probably more a cry of help than any real serious attempt, but at
twenty one I attempted suicide. An overdose of pills, washed down with
scotch. I can remember being completely surprised at how many family
and friends visited me in the hospital. I remember thinking they don’t
understand me. I didn’t even feel that I understood myself.
Unfortunately, it was beyond me at the time to give any real
explanation for my actions, and so any chance to do so was lost... So
what’s a closeted, gay, alcoholic madman to do? Marry her, of course.
We married the following year. It seemed to an outsider looking in that
I was getting my life back together. Could that be so wrong? A
few years later our only child, a daughter, was born... I am writing
this now sitting in my inner-city studio apartment. Forty three years
young. I love my gay friendly neighbourhood, and I love this city. My
Indonesian born boyfriend and I live with a gay feline diva we call
Oscar. My uni-attending daughter, now jokingly referred to as the fag
hag, comes over every second weekend. Ten years of Buddhist practise
has grounded me, nearly seventeen years of being sober and clean has
healed me of many demons. I reflect on all those years living the lie,
and trying to drown the truth away in a sea of booze and alcohol. Being
gay is simply a part of me, as it has always been.
From XY Magazine
(1995): "Young
male suicide - reversing the trend." (Alternate Link) Reporting on a suicide prevention
conference: "One other excellent paper, by Kenton Penley of the Second
Storey Youth Health Centre in Adelaide, reported the dearth of research
into the effects of heterosexism and homophobia on youth suicide rates."
"But two out of 50 [papers presented] is a damming illustration of how
the community of "anti-suicide workers" regards the need to ask how gender
construction effects suicide rates." - Homophobia and masculinities among young men (Lessons in becoming a straight man)
(1997): Many lesbian and gay young people have negative experiences and
memories of schools and education [Nickson, 1996: 163]. They experience
verbal and physical harassment and violence,[4] marginalisation, and
other injustices in what is a systematic pattern of bigotry, exclusion
and oppression. The consequences of this for gay and lesbian students
are increasingly well documented, and include isolation, confusion,
marginalisation, higher rates of personal stress and alienation,
lowered self-esteem and self-hate, poor school performance, dropping
out of school, homelessness, drug and alcohol abuse, and suicide.
Silence is where the hate grows (1997, Alternate Link): - in reference to mainstream suicidologists
avoiding "homosexuality" issues in adolescent suicide research and prevention
work: "Although Casey reckons
he "always knew" he was gay, he became one of the kids who was "forced
into doing it". After moving to Sydney, Casey was drawn into a string of
abusive "relationships"...Because of his low self-esteem
borne of the silence, Casey says he was easy pickings for deeply-closeted
homosexual "sick tickets" who found more pleasure in hearing screams for
mercy as they held knives to the throats of other parents' sons than in
real and open love... Starved of real love and left
with little hope, Casey, like many young gays, turned to chemical "friends"
to fill the void. His only human friends became the other youngsters traded
by the "sick tickets"... "Of the thirteen of us, I'm one
of only three that's still alive today," Casey says. "Most of my friends
blew their heads off, some of them OD'd and some of them have died from
AIDS. They were all bright kids with talents and promising futures."
Christmas
can be Gay, but not Very Merry (1997): "Youth worker Ralph Graham says that
while Christmas is a hard time for many people who cannot be with their
loved ones, it is particularly hard for homosexuals. Coming to terms with
their sexuality and fear of rejection can be too much. The pressure is
reflected in homosexual suicide statistics around the festive season...
Last year Ralph received three calls from people attempting suicide in
the lead-up to Christmas. All three were young men trying to come to terms
with their sexuality. One had the support of his parents, another had not
yet told them and the third was not comfortable with being gay, fearing
rejection from his parents, family and friends." - A
gay man who survived a mutual suicide pact with his lover (1995, Alternate Link).
Shane
Hughes is a 23 year old bisexual who lives in Adelaide, South Australia. "Between the ages of 14 and 21, Shane attempted suicide several
times because he could not deal with his sexuality and the feelings he
was having." More on Shane Hughes: How a Gay Son Finally came out to his Parents (1998, Must Scroll): "Mrs Hughes, who lives
at Victor Harbour with husband Graham, said that after the initial shock,
there was a sense of relief. He’d had suicide attempts and we didn’t understand
why. We questioned ourselves." Mrs Hughes said. "...Mrs Hughes, who lives
at Victor Harbour with husband Graham, said that after the initial shock,
there was a sense of relief. He’d had suicide attempts and we didn’t understand
why. We questioned ourselves." Mrs Hughes said... Shane Hughes is 25 and
happy – but it wasn’t always the case. He recalls his primary school days,
when he noticed he was attracted to boys as well as girls. "I didn’t really
do anything about it until my early high school days, when I started feeling
my way around, if I can put it that way," he said. "I got mixed up from
there. I had a hard time of it. Maybe because it was all happening for
me and I didn’t have any positive gay role models..."
The
Wakeup Call (1998, Alternate Link):
I just received the news that my friend Robert killed himself early
this morning. I was not surprised. Indeed at the time I felt absolutely
nothing; a kind of emotional numbness I guess. He was a difficult man
to like, let alone love, but I could see the hurt child in him and I
loved that child. Robert called me last night. I guess his call was a
type of suicide letter. The pain he was in was obvious, the deep sense
of isolation he felt was palpable. His 27 years of life had been a long
series of rejections, one after another... Summary: Robert was sexually abused as a boy, expelled
from his adopted Christian family when his homosexual orientation was discovered
at age 14, survived via street prostitution in Brisbane, contracted HIV,
developed AIDS, and killed himself in a way that may be deemed "an accident"
by the investigating authorities. Sometimes a friend, such as Martin Worterding,
may know that it was not an accident and he remains emotionally troubled
because he is part of a society not deemed "innocent" with respect to such
ultimately fatal outcomes.
Homosexuality
and Suicide (1995, Part 2, Part
1) by Ed Green with Margaret Appleby (From: The
Suicide-Prevention Information Centre): Difficulties experienced
in the 'coming out' stage..., Difficulties in the school environment...,
Lack of friends and role models..., Discrimination in the workplace...,
Violence towards gays and lesbians..., Problems when sexuality is hidden...,
Attitudes of some religious denominations..., Isolation in rural communities...,
Higher risk for AIDS..., Providing support for homosexuals..., Bibliography.
(Extract from the "Suicide Awareness for Aboriginal Communities" by Margaret
Appleby & Dr. Raymond King Colleen, Brown Publishers - Rose Education). - Crucial statistics about same sex attracted youth: The
following statistics are based on a range of social research conducted
at Australian universities [1995-1998]. It paints a picture of
difficulty and marginalisation for same sex attracted youth - all the
more reason to adopt and promote tolerant attitude in schools, homes
and workplaces.
Homo!
Poofter! Faggot! Youth Focus Article (1998, Must Scroll) : A
17-year-old gay male describes his adolescent environment, a life a many
suicide attempts, the uselessness of psychiatrists (at least for his problems),
and a bleak outlook for the future "I've been rejected enough by family in my life,
so losing friends would have just thrown me," he explained. But school
was not easy for him. "Along with friendship break-ups at school, being
gay just topped it off." He attempted suicide over a dozen times. "I lose
count! I swallowed half a dozen different pills, drank nearly every household
chemical we had, and slit my wrists."" - Youth
at Risk: "Homelessness, Sexual Abuse, Family Rejection HIV: All
are contributing to Gay Youth suicides." - An
Australian expert reports that New Zealand has done very little to
stop young gays and lesbians from committing suicide. - Gay
Catholics Challenge Archbishop Pell on Youth Suicide.
Prejudice
can Affect Health: Australian Medical Association: "he cited a
1996 Australian study that showed that over half of gay male youths had
attempted suicide. "Because of homophobia, people are suffering. Young
people are dying. There can be no excuses for delays in achieving justice
and human rights for all people. Lives depend on it," said Phelps. "There
was very wide consultation in reaching this position statement," Phelps
told Reuters Health. "I believe that it's a very important document, and
it's one which the AMA will be disseminating widely to community groups
and medical colleges and universities." - AMA
Federal President, Dr Kerryn Phelps, To The Amnesty International Global
Human Rights Conference (2002): "Why Homophobia is a Health Issue." -
Sexual
Diversity and Gender Identity Position Statement of AMA (Alternate Link).
"Combating
Lesbian and Gay Youth Suicide and HIV/AIDS Transmission Rates: An Examination
of Possible Education Strategies in Western Australian High Schools in
Light of Prevailing State Statutes" by Christopher N Kendal & Sonia
Walker (E Law - Murdoch University Electronic Journal of Law, Vol 5, No
4, 1998): All of the above create an environment where suicide is considered a tangible
option by far too many young lesbians and gay men... - Aspects of youth suicide: summary report of a seminar (1997): 21.
Sexuality is also a suicide risk factor for young people. Although
there is little statistical data on whether young people who are
confused or harassed over their sexuality are at greater risk of
suicide, anecdotal evidence suggests that sexuality can be a strong
influencing factor. Professor Kosky told the seminar that although
statistics do not show an over-representation of homosexuals in
completed suicides, clinical psychiatrists feel that in truth, they are
over-represented. This is because many suicides linked to feelings of,
or abuse because of, homosexuality may not be reported as such. 22.
One invited representative pointed out that for all teenagers,
including young gays and lesbians, there are four main support groups -
their family, their peers, the church and school. For young
homosexuals, these support groups may become alienating and/or hostile
when homosexuality is revealed. Many young homosexual people fear
alienation and rejection, placing them in a situation of depression,
loneliness and despair, factors recognised as triggers for suicidalbehaviour.
Talking Sexual Health: A teaching & learning resource for secondary schools (2001, Implementing the National framework for Education About STIs, HIV/AIDS and Blood-Borne Viruses in Secondary Schools) PDF.
Note: the section on sexual minority (gay, lesbian, bisexual) students
and teachers leaves much to be desired. For example: "Teachers who are
not gay and lesbian can challenge stereotypes and affirm diversity by
not revealing their sexuality to students. They can also use inclusive
terms when referring to relationships e.g. partner instead of husband
and wife. It is easy and safe for a teacher to place gay and lesbian
people as ‘other’, by ensuring that students know they are
heterosexual. It is more powerful for this to be unknown to assist in
breaking down myths and discrimination." Comment: The first part is
good but the proposition that heterosexual teachers are NOT to mention
the existence of their wives and children - all meaning that they are
heterosexual - or will be presumed to be - is to live in dreamland, as
if heterosexual teachers would ever accept to be closeted heterosexual,
as it is inherently suggested that GLB teachers should remain closeted.
Smith A, Agius P, Mitchell A, Barrett C, Pitts M (2009). Secondary Students and Sexual Health 2008, Monograph Series No. 70, Melbourne: Australian Research Centre in Sex, Health & Society, La Trobe University (PDF - Note: Report does not contain survey results related to homosexuality, but related information was solicited). - Secondary students and sexual health 2008 (2009): "Same sex attraction: The
proportion of students reporting a sexual attraction exclusively to
those of the opposite sex declined between 2002 and 2008 surveys. This
decline was most marked for young men in Year 12, with the proportion
of students reporting heterosexual sexual attraction dropping from 96%
to 90%. There was also a marked increase in the number of students from
this group who were unsure of their sexual attraction. This may well be
indicative of schools dealing better with the issues and students
feeling more comfortable to sit with their uncertainty rather than
feeling rushed to a decision. Almost one in 10 students surveyed
reported their most recent sexual encounter was with someone of the
same sex. For young men, the likelihood of having a same sex encounter
at the most recent sexual experience had increased from 2% in 2002 to
8% in 2008."
The
primary report of the Australian Study of Health and Relationships is
published as the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health,
Volume 27, Number 2, April 2003. Sex in Australia: Summary findings of the Australian study of health and relationships (PDF): Sexual identity, attraction and experience:
In presenting the results of the survey the terms ‘lesbian’, ‘gay’ and
‘bisexual’ are used to describe only those people who identify by these
terms and not those who are attracted to others of the same sex or who
have had sexual experience with others of the same sex but do not
themselves identify with these terms. In this study 97.4% of men
identified as heterosexual, 1.6% as gay and 0.9% as bisexual. For women
97.7% identified as heterosexual, 0.8% as gay and 1.4% as bisexual.
Nevertheless, 8.6% of men and 15.1% of women reported either feelings
of attraction to the same sex or some sexual experience with the same
sex. Half the men and two thirds of the women who had same sex sexual
experience regarded themselves as heterosexual rather than homosexual.
This illustrates that same sex attraction and experience are more
common in Australia that is indicated by the relatively fewpeople reporting a homosexual or bisexual identity.
Our
son committed suicide because his Church regarded him as a sinner and his
state regarded him as a criminal (1999). - Cranebrook
is the fourth school he has had to leave. He has attempted suicide three
times and receives regular psychological counselling (1997). - Help
for parents dealing with youth suicide and homosexuality. A program run
by Jesuit Social Services N/A.- In
Queensland, schools left to decide whether GBL-positive materials will
be incorporated in their suicide prevention programs N/A.
Between
40,000 and 60,000 young Australians attempt suicide each year. Thirty per
cent of those attempts are related to homophobia and sexuality. Despite
this, only 300 out of 853 youth suicide prevention projects mention the
“gay issue”, and only 12 address it in their programs. - Study
examining lives of gay, lesbian teachers, students and ex-students in schools
found (1994). - College
hate campaign sparks reform call
(2000, Note: White Print on White Background. Use: "ctrl + a"): ."The
offending students in this case clearly intended to use homophobia as a
weapon to inspire others to hatred and violence towards an innocent
person. People who engage in hate speech must be held accountable for
the results of that speech." Walker's comments were supported by Union
Secretary Lisa Chesters, who urged LGBTs to join the Silver Wheat
Society's campaign for anti-vilification coverage. Chesters told
Queensland Pride the union had received information from individual
students for several years that homophobic and sexist harassment were
rife in a number of residential colleges on the campus. "The difficulty
the union has faced has been that, until recently, none of these
students had been willing to lodge a formal complaint or to come
forward openly to make allegations. These students have been
understandably fearful that retaliation would follow any such
publicity." Chesters said.
Boys
learn to be homophobic in the primary school playground, an academic says.
(Melbourne
Herald Sun, 27/12/'99) "...homophobia peaks in the mid to late teens, with boys in Years 8 and
9 reporting they use the word "poofter" 25 to 50 times a day... "At that
age it is extremely powerful - in fact 'poofter' was ranked as the worst
thing that a boy could be called." - Anti-homophobia
plan may curb suicide rate: (Alternate
Link, must scroll) "It started after surveys found bullying of same-sex
attracted students was rife. A study of 1200 rural high school students
found 11 per cent of teens aged 14-16 were attracted to the same sex. Another
study of same-sex attracted teens found 13 per cent had suffered physical
abuse and 46 per cent had suffered verbal abuse. Nearly 70 per cent of
the abuse happened at school: 60 per cent by other students, 10 per cent
by friends and 3 per cent by teachers. "It is total bullying," said Mr
Rojas-Morales. "It begins at primary school."
Students
admit same sex attraction. (Sydney
Morning Herald - 29/12/'99 - Smith A, Lindsay J, Rosenthal D (1999). Same-sex
attraction, drug injection and binge drinking among Australian adolescents.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 23-6, 643-6 - Abstract): 6% of
grade 10-12 students report having same-sex attractions and are at higher
risk for a number of problems. - Silencing (Homo)Sexualities in School ... A Very Bad Idea
(2005): A good deal of research has positioned SSA young people as
‘at-risk’, using data which places heterosexual-identifying adolescents
as a ‘control group’ and citing elevated drug and alcohol use, suicide
attempts/ideation, and risky sexual practices among the population of
SSA young people. This type of research problematises the SSA young
people themselves, rather than the environments which they are subject
to and the harassment they may be experiencing therein. - 11
Year Old Youngest In Australia To Undergo TG Therapy (2003): "The suicide
rate amongst transgenders is so high (43 per cent of transgenders in Australia
have committed suicide or have made an attempt) and I don't want a dead
child." (Alternate
Link)
The
abuse of a gay male adolescent in a Melbourne school is implicated in suicide.
A newspaper, The
Age, printed a related article (Nov, 1998 - not available online)
resulting in two
letters to the editor that outline the highly negative situation
existing in schools for gay and lesbian youth. - From a May, 1998 "The
Age" article: "Parents need to ask themselves if they would prefer
our schools to deal sensitively with homophobia, or read about a child's
anguish in a suicide note." From the Hunter
Institute of Mental Health: An innovative mental health education program,
servicing the Hunter Region and Northern New South Wales - Module
10: Gay and Lesbian Youth Suicide. - Module
10 available as PDF Download: Despite the current controversy surrounding the actual prevalence of
suicide among gay and lesbian young people, it is likely that a young
gay or lesbian person will experience some form of prejudice due to
their sexual orientation. It has been argued that, as a consequence of
such prejudice and discrimination, gay and lesbian young people are more
likely to experience risk factors for suicide such as depression,
substance abuse and homelessness. The issues relevant to gay and lesbian
young people include both external and internal pressures.
ACON's Submission to The Senate Community Affairs References Committee Inquiry into Suicide in Australia (PDF):
International and national research estimates that the rate of suicide
attempts for GLBT people is 3.5 to 14 times higher than for their
heterosexual peers. Further, it is well recognised that suicide and
self harm rates for same-sex attracted youth and GLBT Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islander people are even higher. Given this unacceptable
and alarming situation ACON welcomes the opportunity to comment on this
very important issue... Part B. Accuracy of Suicide Reporting in
Australia: Suicide statistics reported by government authorities such
as the Australian Bureau of Statistics currently do not contain figures
on suicide of GLBT individuals. The data is not and cannot be
disaggregated by sexual orientation or gender identity because the data
collected do not contain sexual orientation or gender identity
indicators. Current demographic indicators include Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islander status, age, sex and location. By expanding the
number of indicators to include sexual orientation and gender identity,
our understanding of which priority groups commit suicide at
disproportionate levels would be improved, which would enhance the
accuracy of suicide reporting in Australia and a create stronger of
evidence base for policy and program development. Creating an
opportunity to report on the sexual orientation and gender identity of
an individual in coronial reports and collecting this data is however
not sufficient to ensure accuracy... - 2008 ACOSS Conference Speech: Mark Orr, ACON President:
Gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender (GLBT) perspectives on social
inclusion/exclusion: A snapshot of the GLBT community
The Causes of the Causes: Oppression and Suicide - Beyond an Individualistic Mental Illness Perspective (by Catherine Keating, Hanna Rosenthal, Jacinta Wainwright & Kate Bennett, 2009, PDF): Oppression, Power & Suicide: Women; & Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual & Transgender (LGBT) People:
•
Research evidence demonstrates that the discrimination, rejection and
abuse experienced by LGBT people has a negative impact on their health
and wellbeing and significantly increases the risk of suicide. •
Addressing the higher risk of suicide for LGBT communities requires
changing the social and institutional norms that support discrimination
and prejudice due to sexual orientation. Interventions should also
target family, school and workplace settings given the high prevalence
of rejection, abuse and prejudice in these contexts... Social norms and
institutions that significantly advantage some people or groups and
disadvantage others are evident across society. Increasingly, research
has highlighted that the discrimination and prejudice experienced by
lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people in their everyday
life is linked with depression; alcohol and drug use; and suicide (Diaz
et al., 2001; Harper & Schneider, 2003; Hillier et al., 2005;
Johnson et al., 2007; McNair et al., 2001; Pitts et al., 2006; Rogers,
2007). Of interest to this submission, one British study (Johnson et
al., 2007) identified that an incident of discrimination often preceded
suicide attempts, suggesting that suicidal distress is not simply the
result of individualised problems but the response by some LGBT people
to institutionalised discriminatory practices perpetrated through
education, health services, religion, media and the family. As a result
of heterosexism and homophobia in the broader social and political
context, LGBT people experience feelings of guilt, shame, and fear of
their sexual orientation being identified, and often modify their daily
activities and behaviour due to fear of prejudice, discrimination and
abuse (Diaz et al., 2001; McNair et al., 2001; Pitts et al., 2006). The
capacity to develop a positive self identity and self worth is hindered
under such conditions, (Johnson et al., 2007) and negative beliefs and
feelings related to gender stereotypes and homophobia experienced in
the broader social context is often internalised (Harper &
Schneider, 2003; Oritz-Hernandez, 2005). Those who experience
discrimination and prejudice across a number of areas are even further
disadvantaged... Unlike the experience of other marginalised groups,
LGBT people often experience rejection and abuse from family and
friends due to their sexual orientation (Brown, 2002; Harper &
Schneider, 2003). The threat and everyday experience of harassment,
violence and abuse particularly for young LGBT people in their home,
school and their workplaces is alarming Many same sex attracted young
people hide their sexual orientation or lead a double life to protect
themselves from abuse and rejection adding a significant burden of
personal stress (Harper & Schneider, 2003). It is evident that if
we are to address the increased psychological distress experienced by
LGBT people, we must remove discrimination, positively recognise same
sex relationships and increase the legitimacy and acceptance ofdiverse
sexual orientation within the social and political context (Pitts et
al., 2006)...
Jake Lucas (PDF):
Early
2001 a young man named Mark had accepted his sexual orientation,
until he was repeatedly told by his church that God did not support him
being homosexual. He tried in vine to explain to them he didn't choose
this, it was who he was. Mark couldn't take the pressure anymore, he
ended his life leaving this note to God "I just don't know how else to
fix this." ... Mary Wallner, a very devoted Christian was led by the
Church to condemn her Lesbian daughter, after Anna her daughter hanged
herself. Her grieving mother Mary now says "If I can sheer just
oneperson away from the pain and anguish I've been living, then maybe
Anna's death will have meaning."
The Gender Centre Inc., Sydney, Australia (A, PDF): LGBT Organisations:
Issues of Sex and Gender Diversity are often seen as an “add-on” for
organisations focused around sexuality and/or sexual health. This
‘inclusion’ is not a comfortable one – either for Sex and Gender
Diverse people, or for many of the organisations affected. Issues of
Sex and Gender Diversity are fundamentally different from issues of
sexuality, and organizations whose primary goal is focused around
sexuality generally have little motivation to direct resources to Sex
and Gender Diverse issues. Roughly 40% of Sex and Gender Diverse people
identify as heterosexual and are not comfortable accessing services
that have been designed to meet the specific needs of gays and
lesbians. Levels of discrimination against Sex and Gender Diverse
people from within the gay and lesbian community are at least as high
as they are within in the broader community... In Conclusion:
As already said the issue of suicide is pertinent for all Australia and
for the transgender population the issues of extremely significant
because of the risks and experiences transgender people are exposed to
that make them more vulnerable to succumbing suicidal behaviors and
actions. The Gender Centre as the leading Centre for advocacy of this
marginalized community urge the senate to take note of the issues and
ideas discussed in this paper and recognize that there is a great need
for action to resolve the threat to the health and well being of the
transgender population inAustralia in an appropriate and open understanding framework.
I have a few concerns when it comes to youth and mental health: 1) Targeted programs/mental health services for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender,questioning (GLBT) young people. Rates of poor mental health, illness and suicide disproportionately affect young people who are gay. I can't think of anyone within my circle of glbt friends and acquaintances that HASN'T had depression, anxiety or another mental health issue. I know of too many young people who have taken their own lives due to issues around their sexuality and there are many for whom we will never know that it was a factor. A new friend told me during the week that his 16yo bf of two years recently committed suicide. Neither the person who died or my friend had/has support around them because it is not safe for them to be out. The issues/concerns that affect that are specifically glbt related. Female - age 23
New
Zealand: - Youth’07:
Youth'07 The Health and Wellbeing of Secondary School Students in New
Zealand: Results for Young People Attracted to the Same Sex or Both
Sexes (2009, Download Page):
"These aside, it is of concern that same/both-sex-attracted students
did not experience the same improvements as their
opposite-sex-attracted peers between 2001 and 2007. For example,
same/both-sex-attracted students did not show the increase in those who
felt happy or satisfied with life seen among opposite-sex-attracted
students, and of even greater concern, nor did they share the same
decreases in suicide attempts observed among opposite-sex-attracted
students between 2001 and 2007." Attempted Suicide results - same-sex
attracted vs. heterosexual: 2001 (22% vs. 7% = 3-times the risk), 2007 (20% vs. 4% = 5-times the risk). See Other Results From This Study on This Webpage. Related New Story: The challenges New Zealand's gay/bi teenagers face
(2009): "Youth '07 launched tomorrow, it's not all gloom and doom ya
know. Queer young peeps rock," Rainbow Youth chairperson Toni Reid
'Twittered' the night before New Zealand's biggest-ever insight into
the lives of gay/bi young people was presented to the public. She's
right of course. The Rainbow Youth crew see hundreds of healthy and
happy LGBT young people visit their centre, join their groups, and even
tell their 'coming out' stories to other students in the classrooms
they're invited to. But this week's headlines tell a different story:
Half of gay/bi students have self-harmed. Gay students are three times
more likely to be bullied at school. And, heartbreakingly, gay teens
are five times more likely to attempt suicide than their straight
peers. "There were some challenging findings," agrees researcher
Mathijs Lucassen. "But they can inspire us to make changes in our
schools and communities." Many same-sex specific "at risk" results are given in the article.
Ministry of Health (2008). New Zealand Suicide Prevention Action Plan 2008-2012: The Evidence for Action. Wellington, NZ: Ministry of Health (PDF).
Note:
GLB youth issues are noted but their suicidality is mentioned in
such a way that the problem is somewhat "minimized." The following was
written: "Recent research strongly suggests that people of
non-heterosexual orientation are at increased risk of developing mental
disorders and have higher rates of suicidal behaviour (Fergusson,
Horwood and Ridder et al 2005; Herrell et al 1999; Russell and Joyner
2001; Skegg et al 2003). Among New Zealand young adults, the rate of
mental health problems was higher for those with a predominantly same
sex orientation than for their exclusively heterosexual peers – five
times higher for males and twice as high for females (Fergusson,
Horwood and Ridder et al 2005). A United States study of high school
students found that those with a same-sex orientation were twice as
likely to attempt suicide as their heterosexual peers (Russell and
Joyner 2001). Initial indications are that transgender and
intersexpopulations are also at increased risk (Fitzpatrick et al 2005;
Johannsen, Ripa et al 2006)." The Risk Ratios for the Russell
and Joyner 2001 study was about 2.5 for both same-sex attracted males
and females, this being the near-lowest RR produced in American
studies. Not mentioned was the RR of 3 for males and females combined
in the 2001 NZ school survey given above, that would become and RR of 5
in the 2007 school survey. Also not mentioned is why New Zealand is NOT
producing studies of child/youth suicide as it was done in British
Columbia, Canada... with likely results that would then permit the
mainstream New Zealand "suicide" authorities to state that
non-heterosexual children/youth are at risk for suicide.
Child Death Review Unit, BC Coroners Service (2008). "Looking for Something to Look Forward to" (a B.C. youth who died by suicide) ... A Five-Year Retrospective Review of Child and Youth Suicide in B.C. : In the five-year period between January 1, 2003, and December 31, 2007, 81 children and youth died by suicide in British Columbia. When this project was initiated, 66 of these cases were closed and 15 remained open and under investigation. The Child Death Review Unit’s review of the 66 closed cases resulted in the following findings: • Older youth (age 17–18 years), males, Aboriginal children and youth, and gay, lesbian and bisexual children and youth, as well as those who were questioning their sexuality, were at increased risk of suicide... Sexual orientation: Four children and youth identified as gay, lesbian or bisexual. Three other children and youth had been questioning their sexual orientation in the months prior to death.
From The National Centre of Mental Health Research, Information and Workplace Development: Funded Research in Progress or Published (September, 2010):
In Progress: Review and update of suicide prevention guidelines for schools. Research team: Dr Sunny Collings (University of Otago), Barry Taylor.
These researchers will review and update the existing suicide prevention guidelines for schools. New evidence and services have emerged since the original guidelines were developed over 10 years ago. The guidelines update will be informed by stakeholder consultation, literature review and pre-testing of the updated guidelines. The researchers will produce a full guideline, literature review and summary guideline aimed at school stakeholder audiences. These documents will include evidence-based recommendations for safe and effective suicide prevention in schools. Note: May contain "at risk" GLBT adolescent related guidelines.
In Progress: Report to inform the provision of mental health promotion and prevention services to gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender and intersex populations in New Zealand. Research team: (SHORE and Whariki Research Centre) Jeffery Adams, Dr Pauline Dickinson, Dr Launuola Asiasiga, Dr Tim McCreanor, Associate Professor Helen Moewaka Barnes.
This project will produce a needs assessment report on mental health promotion and prevention service requirements for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender and intersex (GLBTI) populations in New Zealand. The report will include a review of the evidence, a description of existing services and programmes and identification of gaps in service provision. It will also provide recommendations for service provision and funding which would improve mental health promotion and prevention service provision and inter-agency collaboration for resourcing services.
Published: Youth '07: Fact Sheet - The Health and Wellbeing of Secondary School Students in New Zealand (2010): Notes that... Another group that is particularly vulnerable are students who are attracted to the same sex or both sexes (4% of students). Of these students, 20% reported making a suicide attempt in the previous 12 months which is five times the rate reported by students attracted exclusively to the opposite sex. PDF. Download Page. Download Page.
Published: Fortune S, Watson P, Robinson E, Fleming T, Merry S, Denny S (2010). Youth’07: The health and wellbeing of secondary school students in New Zealand: Suicide behaviours and mental health in 2001 and 2007. Auckland: The University of Auckland. PDF. Download Page. Download Page. Notes that... "Another group that is particularly vulnerable are students who are attracted to the same sex or to both sexes. These students show much higher levels of significant depressive symptoms, self-harm and suicide behaviours than those who are attracted to the opposite sex (Rossen, Lucassen, Denny & Robinson, 2009 [See Study Results on This Webpage]). Analysis of the 2007 survey results showed that students who were attracted to the same sex or to both sexes were much more likely to report a suicide attempt (20.0%) in the past 12 months than students who were attracted to the opposite sex (4.0%). Comment: Results should at least be given separately for sexual minority males and females. Also separately for bisexual students." The report also supplies Useful Links for Youth Mental Health: Young People Attracted to the Same Sex or Both Sexes: - Rainbow Youth. - OUTlineNZ: OUTLine is a free, confidential telephone counselling service for the rainbow community New Zealand wide. - Out There! Project: OUT THERE! was a Joint National Youth Development Project between the New Zealand AIDS Foundation (NZAF) and Rainbow Youth. Out There aimed to enhance the wellbeing of queer youth within Aotearoa New Zealand by providing resources, running workshops, commissioning research and organising hui (conferences). Due to multiple reasons Out There was unable to continue. - The "Making Schools Safe for People of Every Sexuality – PPTA Guidelines" link is not available,
SAFETY
IN OUR SCHOOLS - KO TE HAUMARU I O TATOU KURA: An action kit for
Aotearoa New Zealand schools to address sexual orientation prejudice
(2005): During the past year 30.4% of non-heterosexual students report
that they have thought of killing themselves - During the past year15.3% of non-heterosexual have attempted suicide [ Le Brun C, Robinson E, Warren H, Watson PD (2004). Non-heterosexual
Youth - A Profile of their Health and Wellbeing. Findings of Youth2000.
A National Secondary School Youth Health Survey. Auckland: The University of Auckland. Download Page. Study Results.]. Note: Results are from the 2001 survey. "Youth2000 survey" Reports (2001 & 2007 Surveys): Download Page.
Fleming TM, Merry SN, Robinson EM, Denny SJ, Watson PD (2007). Self-reported suicide attempts and associated risk and protective factors among secondary school students in New Zealand. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 41(3): 213-21. Abstract. Study Results.
The Significance of Diversity for Suicide Prevention Initiatives (2007, Download Page):
‘GLBTI’people: Rates of suicidal thoughts and behaviours, and mental
health problems associated with suicide are between 1.5 and 12 times
higher for GLB people than for heterosexuals in NZ (eg Fergusson et al.
2005, Skegget al. 2003, Fleming et al. 2007 ) - Transgender and
intersex people also have higher risk of psychological distress,
suicidal thoughts and behaviours (egFitzpatrick et al. 2005,
Johannsenet al. 2006) - Many people are aware of same-sex attraction by
age 13, but few disclose this to anybody before leaving school (eg Le
Brunet al. 2004) - Most GLB youth who attempt suicide have not ‘come
out’ - Many GLBTI people are reluctant to access health services or
‘come out’ to professionals for fear of a negative response (eg
Semp2006, Fish 2006, Myers et al 2005, Meckler et al. 2006, Neville
& Henrickson 2006)
Queer Subjects of Suicide: Cultural Studies, Sexuality and Youth Suicide Concepts in New Zealand (2001, by Rob Cover, Must scroll): Abstract: This
paper undertakes a brief examination of current trends in New Zealand
youth suicide research and policy, arguing that the extent to which
youth sexuality is addressed is comparatively limited. Although
lesbian/gay/bisexual sexualities, concerns and identities are relatively
absent, it is important not merely to add minority sexualities to
suicide concepts in New Zealand research and policy development; rather
these are well-placed to take on-board highly-nuanced understandings of
sexuality that (a) draw on culturalist, queer theory and
postmodern/poststructuralist approaches, and (b) are more in line with a
culture of sexual fluidity among contemporary youth. Personal and
identity-related anxieties around such a sexual culture, it is argued,
may be among risk factors for youth suicide. By showing how youth
sexuality is either marginalised or mis-read by policy-makers and
researchers, some early indicators of directions suicide research might
take with regard to sexuality are asserted here.
New
Zealand: First New Zealand study to explore GLB suicidality
issues:
Longitudinal
Youth Study (By age 21: Suicide attempt incidence for GLB identified
youth is 32.1%, and 7.0% for the others (Fergusson DM, Horwood LJ, Beautrais AL (1999). Is sexual orientation related to mental health problems and suicidality in young people? Archives of General Psychiatry, 56(10): 876-80. PubMed Abstract. Full Text.). The risk also continues after the teenage years: Fergusson DM, Horwood LJ, Ridder EM, Beautrais AL (2005). Sexual orientation and mental health in a birth cohort of young adults. Psychological Medicine, 35(7): 971-981. PubMed Abstract. PDF Download. - A
2000/2003 study of suicidality and gay youth by John Fenaughty: "Life on the seesaw:
an assessment of suicide risk and resiliency for bisexual and gay male
youth in Aotearoa / New Zealand.
New
Zealand: New study to eventually be ready for peer review and likely publication
- "A New Zealand study being conducted by researchers at the Dunedin
School of Medicine will determine the association between
sexual orientation (based on a measure of sexual attraction) and a range
of behaviours indicative of deliberate self-harm (suicidal, non-suicidal
intent). The study is based on the Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and
Development Study (DMHDS). The findings are expected to complement those
reported by Fergusson and colleagues (1999) in the Archives of General
Psychiatry." (Cited from a March 21, 2000 email from Shyamala Nada-Raja
written in response to a request made by Pierre Tremblay for related information.).
- The study was then published in the American Journal of Psychiatry: Lifetime suicide attempt incidences for young adult males:
Heterosexual (6%), Minor Homosexuality (16%), Significant Homosexuality
(25%). For females: Heterosexual (9%), Minor Homosexuality (11%), Significant
Homosexuality (33%). Skegg K, Nada-Raja S, Dickson N, Paul C, Williams S (2003). Sexual orientation and self-harm in men and women. American Journal of Psychiatry, 160(3): 541-6. PubMed Abstract. Full Text.
New
Zealand: - In
Ya Face - Like, for
example, the mis-conception that sexuality has nothing to do with some
people killing themselves. I disagree. Large numbers of gays and lesbians
have grappled with the thought of putting a gun to their head, or jumping
off the bridge. Why? Because being gay, lesbian or transgendered in Aotearoa,
despite the changes in the past decade, is still a bloody hard thing to
be. It's incredibly hard, and the pressures are such that it pushes too
many youths, literally, off the edge... Let's get very real, very quickly,
and start to recognize that a large proportion of youth suicides may be
attributed to the pressures of being gay or lesbian. - Andrew,
a married man with 3 children, attempted suicide 3 times before coming
to terms with a secret few would have known - except for the males he had
sex with - had he died from his suicide attempts (1998).
Factors
influencing the risk of suicide for gay and lesbian people include (NZ
Site): (Home
Page): Awareness of being gay or lesbian and first sexual experience
- Total rejection by family over coming out - Rejection by society - Promiscuity
and unsafe sex - Homophobic assaults and cruel taunts. - Risk
Factors for Youth Suicide (2002): "Sexual Orientation: There is growing
international evidence to confirm that young gay, lesbian and bisexual
people have higher rates of suicidal behaviour, arising from lack of support
for their sexual orientation and the discrimination they face."
Suicide in New Zealand II: a review of risk factors and prevention
(Annette Beautrais, New Zealnad Medical Journal, 2003): "Psychosocial
stresses... Sexual orientation Clear linkages have been established
between sexual orientation and suicide attempt behaviour. These
findings have been reported for New Zealand, with results indicating
that young people of gay, lesbian and bisexual orientation had rates of
suicidal ideation and attempt that were over five times those of
heterosexual youth."
Europe:
England
England: - Rates
and predictors of mental illness in gay men, lesbians and bisexual men
and women: Results from a survey based in England and Wales (Pub
Med 2004 Abstract) (Full Text): "Of the 1285 gay, lesbian and bisexual respondents
who took part, 556 (43%) had mental disorder as defined by the revised
Clinical Interview Schedule (CIS - R). Out of the whole sample, 361 (31%)
had attempted suicide. This was associated with markers of discrimination
such as recent physical attack (OR=1.7, 95% CI 1.3-2.3) and school bullying
(OR=1.4, 95% CI 1.1-2.0)..." - Boy, 10, hangs himself after telling his mother: 'I want to be a girl' (2008). - Another Gay Male Suicide in Cornwall (with Police involvement?) (2008). - Lesbian couple found dead in suspected suicide pact (2009). - Gay torment drove me to suicide bid (2008-1996). - Frazer M (2005). Some
Queers are Safer Than Others: Correlates of Hate Crime Victimization of
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender People in Britain. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, Philadelphia, PA. Readable online a unformatted document text. - GLBT show educates community: Outloud! advocates for suicide prevention, rights (2010).
Study:
Mental health and quality of life of gay men and lesbians in England and
Wales (Abstract)
(PubMed
Abstract) (Full Text): "Gay men and lesbians were more likely than heterosexuals
to have consulted a mental health professional in the past, deliberately
harmed themselves and used recreational drugs. Lesbians were more likely
to have experienced verbal and physical intimidation and to consume more
alcohol than heterosexual women." - New
Study Indicates Gays and Lesbians Prone To Psychological Symptoms and Substance
Abuse - But School Harassment Rates Not Higher for Gay Males. - Boy, 15, lay down in front of train after gay taunts (2007). - Suicide teen told to stop wasting taxpayer's money (2009). - Britain ‘more comfortable’ with homosexuality but two-thirds of gay students are bullied (2010).
Salford National Union of Teachers (2010). Prevalence of Homophobia Survey. Salfrod N.U.T. (National Union of Teachers). Full Text.
The results. The results confirm the growing body of evidence from both academic research, human rights and LGBT groups indicating the cultural prevalence of homophobia in our schools. The overall reported incidence of homophobic abuse/ hate crime in Salford secondary schools is disturbingly high. In fact it is to be hoped that if any other form of criminalised discrimination was reported at this level (e.g. racism, sexism) there would be formal governmental demands for the immediate implementation of child protection measures.
Cull M, Platzer H, Balloch S (2006). Out On My Own: Understanding the Experiences and Needs of Homeless Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Youth.
Brighton & Hove, England: Health and Social Policy Research Centre,
Faculty of Health, School of Applied Social Science, University of
Brighton. Internet: PDF. Research Summary: PDF: Nearly
all the young people in our study reported a history of mental health
problems or substance misuse. Over two thirds had a history of
attempting suicide and half reported alcohol or substance misuse.
Ignoring
the evidence dictating the practice: sexual orientation, suicidality and
the dichotomy of the mental health nurse (Pub
Med 2004 Abstract): "Until recently in England, Section 28 of the Local
Government Act (1988), forbidding the promotion of homosexuality, further
reinforced negativity towards this group of people. This compounded the
negative mental health consequences for those developing a gay sexual orientation
in a climate of heterosexism. Current health care policy in England concerns
itself with the rising number of suicides among young people but fails
to acknowledge the importance of the research findings relating to gay
people by integrating them into the development of mental health policy.
This paper reviews the literature relating to homosexual people and suicidality,
and addresses the seriousness of a policy rhetoric which results from ignoring
the evidence while dictating mental health nursing practice." - A greater awareness of the mental health needs of lesbian, gay and bisexual (LGB) people is required.
Suicide problems after becoming
part of gay community: No
Way Out
- "The shocking statistics for suicide amongst gay teenagers have
traditionally been attributed to the pressures of coming out in a
hetero-defined society. Murray Healy discovers an alarming new trend
amongst twenty-somethings who find the promised land of the urban gay
community isn’t all they expected it to be... Last year, six friends of
mine tried to kill themselves.
All men in their twenties, all intelligent, attractive, popular, and
seemingly
happy; and all, to a greater or lesser extent, identifying as gay. I
started
the year never having known anyone who’d attempted suicide. By
christmas
it felt like my world had been struck by an epidemic:" Three cases are
described. "The
Project for Advice, Counselling and Education N/A (PACE) recognize that
gay suicide is not a problem restricted to the pre-coming-out years of
adolescence. "It’s an ongoing problem", one counselor told me. Many gay
men don't find the support they need on the gay scene." It's a telling
indictment of gay society that, far from providing a solution to the homophobia
of conventional life, the gay scene, and it's me-generation hedonism, makes
gay people feel more isolated and alienated. - Warning over gay community's suicide rate
(2007): Gay and transgender people are up to three times more likely to
attempt suicide than heterosexuals, a charity has claimed. MindOUT, a
mental health group for the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender
community in Brighton, says it deals with at least 150 people a year
who have either made suicide attempts or had suicidal feelings... "If
you come with high expectations of lovely LGBT Brighton and then don't
fit in or are confronted with as much homophobia than ever it seems
like there is no hope at all"... MindOUT has been working on a suicide
prevention project which culminated with planting a weeping cherry tree
in St Ann's Well Gardens, Hove, last month." - LGBT Suicide
Prevention Strategy for Brighton & Hove (2008, PDF). - Community Psychology and LGBT Suicide Prevention in Brighton and Hove
(2008, PPT): A central concern for participants at MindOut was ‘double
stigma’ being alienated from the LGBT community because of mental
health issues was as problematic as being isolated, and sometimes
pathologised, within mental health services because of their LGBT
identification. - MINDOUT & The Stigma
(2009): MindOut was created as a response to the poor service LGBT
people received from mental health service providers and to change the
way LGBT people were being treated at the time. It now reaches 300
people a year in every part of the community including trans people. It
has recently launched BlackOUT for BME people in the community.
Gay
and Lesbian Humanist Association News Release - 1999 (Alternate Link):
- "Take the case of Simon Harvey, son of George Harvey who runs a so-called
counselling service for gays in East Anglia. Simon killed himself because
he couldn't reconcile his homosexuality with the stance taken by his evangelical
Christian father. More recently, a young man in Rotherham killed himself
after listening to the American evangelist Pat Robertson condemning homosexual
relationships - a tragedy brought to light by the coroner at the inquest. - Gay star reveals suicide attempt
(2006): "Gay actor Stephen Fry will reveal his struggle with depression
and suicide contemplation in a new BBC documentary highlighting the
condition later this year."
The cultural context of youth suicide: Identity, gender, and sexuality (2005, PDF. Research in Progress: (PDF Download (Alternate Link) - Downloads):
"There is growing international evidence that young people struggling
with issues of sexuality and gender identity face increased likelihood
of attempting suicide. This has been raised repeatedly as an issue in
the U.K. though not yet researched in detail. The proposed study will
explore the cultural context of youth suicide in England and Wales,
with a focus on the significance of gender identity and sexuality." On The Edge Project: Research on young people in distress: Project Summary. Handout: One-Day Workshop. - LGBT young people's experiences of distress: resilience, ambivalence and self-destructive behaviour
(2009): The empirical basis for the paper is qualitative research that
was carried out in the North West of England and South Wales. Focus
groups and interviews were conducted with a total of 69 young people,
with a purposive sample to reflect diversity of sexual identity, social
class and regional and rural-urban location. The paper presents a
thematic analysis of the data specifically relating to the experiences
of LGBT young people. A range of strategies that LGBT young people
employ in the face of distress are described. These are categorised as
resilience, ambivalence and self-destructive behaviour (including
self-harm and suicide). The potential implications for health and
social care of these strategies include the need for ecological
approaches and for sexual cultural competence in practitioners, as well
as prioritisation of LGBT risk within suicide prevention policies. - Avoiding shame: young LGBT people, homophobia and self-destructive behaviours
(2008): Data from interviews and focus groups with young LGBT
participants suggest a strong link between homophobia and
self-destructive behaviours... The paper argues that these strategies
of shame-avoidance suggest young LGBT people manage homophobia
individually, without expectation of support and, as such, may make
them vulnerable to self-destructive behaviours.
'Suicide
wish' of gay bullying victims (07/18/00, BBC):
"A large proportion of lesbian, gay and bisexual pupils who are bullied
by their classmates try to commit suicide, according to research.
A study suggests that half of them contemplate killing or harming themselves,
and four in 10 actually harm themselves at least once... The research also
indicates that 17% - nearly one in five - display symptoms associated with
post-traumatic stress disorder later in life... The findings by Dr Ian
Rivers, of the College of Ripon and York St John, were being presented
to The British Psychological Society's Lesbian and Gay Section Conference
at the University of Surrey on Tuesday. " - Rivers I (2000). Social exclusion, absenteeism and sexual minority youth. Support For Learning, 17(1): 13-18. Abstract. Study Results. - Victims of gay bashing suicide link. - Rivers I (2004). Recollections of bullying at school and their long-term implications for lesbians, gay men, and bisexuals. Crisis, 25(4):169-75. PubMed Abstract. Full Text. Full Text.
On
October 6, 1998, in a news item titled "UK 'Teachers bully gay pupils'"
BBC
News reported that some teachers abuse boys known (or believed)
to be gay, thus creating and/or exacerbating problems - including suicide
problems - for these adolescent. Anecdotal suicide-related information
is given. (Alternate
article link.) - A 1996 double lesbian
youth suicide.
At
the time of his suicide Fashanu was wanted by police after fleeing America,
where he had a coaching job, in the wake of charges that he performed a
sexual act on a 17-year-old boy N/A. - Peter Tatchell says it was homophobia that ultimately destroyed the career and life of football star Justin Fashanu (1998). - The last days of a footballer, by Brian Deer. - Darren
Steele (N/A, 1998) had suffered a five-year ordeal of
taunting and beating from fellow pupils at de Ferrers High in Burton because
he was thought to be gay, purely because of his love of cookery and drama
classes. Darren left a suicide note naming those he blamed for his death,
and this resulted in the arrest of 11 pupils, although the Crown Prosecution
Service decided not to prosecute them. Choirboy [Darren Steele] hanged himself after years of bullying. More related items: 1,
2,
3, 4.
- Let's
talk about sexuality (1998): The Samaritans and the London Lesbian
and Gay Switchboard have been building bridges to improve services available
to the despairing and suicidal. - Student
who died under train told family he was gay
(2002): "A gifted Cambridge University
student was killed under a Tube train hours after revealing his
homosexuality
to his parents, an inquest was told yesterday.... An argument erupted
after Frederick Hodder, 21, made his announcement and he had left the
family home in a "distressed state". His family did not learn until the
next day that he had died after drinking the equivalent of a bottle of
whisky."
Straight
Talk (2000): One of the
top four causes of young people committing suicide is conflict due to sexual
orientation (according to the Department of Health booklet Sometimes
I Think I Can't Go On Anymore published in 1995). If young gay men and
lesbian women were to receive supportive education, and their peers were
encouraged to become more understanding of homosexuality, many of the suicides
committed by young people will be avoided.
The
UK
Childline states (1998): "Groups
particularly at risk of suicide include unemployed or homeless young people,
young gay men and lesbians and young people who have problems with drugs."
Suicide
and deliberate self-harm N/A (2001): The Fundamental Facts from The UK Mental
Health Foundation. Includes some information on gay and lesbian suicide
problems.
Gay
Health Issues: In 1992
The Department of Health set a target to reduce the suicide rate among
the general pollution by 15 per cent by the year 2000.. A group called
'Esteem' is currently researching attempted suicide rates among the lesbian,
gay and bisexual young people as it is believed that the rates are alarmingly
high.
The
Community News" May 1999: "Young gay men have the highest percentage
of attempted suicide. A recent study (Toner et al 1999) found that 54.1
% of their sample of gay men had made at least one suicide attempt. Indeed
their sample was 30 times more likely to attempt suicide than the generic
population." (From the "AIDS
Education Unit N/A (Archive Link): HIV health promotion in Barnet and surrounding
areas..." web site, London).
Suicide
Is Everyone's Concern: A Thematic Review by Her Majesty's Chief Inspector
of Prisons (1999). - Inquest opens into lesbian prison suicide (2009). - Gay
prisoners: "5.19 Young people who are gay can be seen as particularly
vulnerable to the risk of suicide or self-harm. This is not because of
their sexual orientation as such, but due to their isolation, fear of being
misunderstood or abused, and lack of people to trust and talk to. Again
we stress the importance of increasing understanding and tolerance of diversity.
Discrimination
Hurts: New Research Reveals the Damaging Impact fo Homopnobia on Mental
Health
(1998). "More than half of mental health workers have helped
gay men and lesbians left emotionally scarred by discrimination because
of their sexual identity, according to a national survey by the Health
Education Authority for World Mental Health Day... Fifty three per cent
of those surveyed said they had helped patients who had been
discriminated
against because of their sexuality, accounting for nine per cent of the
patients of psychiatrists, 13 per cent of Community Psychiatric Nurse
cases
and a third of primary care specialist cases." ... A spokesperson for
PACE
said: 'We are pleased that this campaign recognises that the
discrimination
and homophobia faced by lesbians and gay men can have detrimental
effects
on their mental health.' ... According to those surveyed, the most
common results of discrimination were: * lower self esteem (94 per
cent) * social isolation/exclusion (89 per cent) * depression and
anxiety (77 per cent) * drug and alcohol misuse (58 per cent)* suicidal feelings (51 per cent)
Lesbian
Information Service reports on "a qualitative study conducted 1990-1991."
IT "found high levels of attempted suicide and self-harm ( 14 out of 20
participants: Word Download )." Study Results are reported in Bridget J and Lucille
S (1996). Lesbian Youth Support Information Service (LYSIS) : Developing
a distance support agency for young lesbians. Journal of Applied Social
Psychology, 6 (5), 355-364. (Note: The study also reports high levels of
abuse of the young lesbians studied by older lesbians). - Meads C, Buckley E, Sanderson P (2007). Ten years of lesbian health survey research in the UK West Midlands. BMC Public Health, 19(7): 251. Full Text. Abstract: Results: The
mean age of respondents varied between 29–33 years and 5–7% were from a
non-white ethnic background. The smoking rates varied from 42% o 55%,
being twice the West Midlands regional average of 21% for women aged 16
or more. Similarly, problems with alcohol were reported in 25–37% of
respondents, higher than the West Midlands regional average of 7% for
women aged 16+. The prevalence of any mental health problem varied
between 31–35% and any suicide attempt between 20–31%. Only 29–45% had
revealed their sexual orientation to their GP and of these,
approximately 50% had experienced a positive reaction.
Inaugural
European Conference: Gay and Lesbian Identities N/A: Working with Young
People, their Families and Schools
- University College London - 29-30 March 1999 -- ‘Improving and Informing
Theory and Practice’ - Changing
Families: Lesbian, gay, and bisexual identity work in mental health: An
evidence-based guide for people who work with families (2006, PACE: PDF Download).
2008 National Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Conference:
Children who do not fully conform to traditional gender stereotypes
(whether or not they self-identify as lesbian, bisexual or transgender
are frequently emotionally, verbally and physically bullied not only by
their peers but even by the adults in their lives. This can lead to
children becoming withdrawn, social outcasts and in some cases result
in severe depression and suicide. The effect on self-esteem, social
interaction, confidence and academic achievement can often continue
into adulthood and significantly reduce future employment prospects and
workplace confidence. Institutional transphobia and lack of recognition
of gender diversity within families by educational and social service
provider's often results in lesbian, gay, bisexual transgender (LGBT)
families receiving discriminatory or inappropriate service provision.
Conference is extremely concerned that the United Kingdom (UK)
Government currently fails to recognise the need for protection of
children and families from transphobic discrimination and harassment in
education service provision.
Ireland & Northern Ireland
Ireland & Northern Ireland:
-A fifth of gay people tried suicide - study (2009):
Almost 20 per cent of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people
have attempted suicide and almost all saw this as related to their
sexual identity and the experiences of being abused and feeling
isolated, a report to be published today has found. The study,
Supporting LGBT Lives: A Study of the Mental Health of Lesbian, Gay,
Bisexual and Transgender People, also found almost one-third of
respondents had self-harmed at least once. Report Download Page: Report PDF, PDF. Report's Key Findings (PDF):
Supporting LGBT Lives: A Study of the Mental Health and Well-being of
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender People (Mayock et al, 2009) is
the most significant and comprehensive study of LGBT people and their
lives in Ireland to date, and it has a special emphasis on young
people. The online survey gathered data from 1,110 lesbian, gay,
bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people, and face-to-face interviews
were carried out with 40 people. The study was commissioned by BeLonG
To Youth Services and GLEN (Gay and Lesbian Equality Network), funded
by the HSE’s National Office for Suicide Prevention (NOSP), and
conducted by the Childrens’ Research Centre, Trinity College Dublin,
and the School of Education, University College Dublin.- Irish president warns of link between anti-gay bullying and suicide. - I'm gay myself -- but even I was shocked by this new Irish survey. - LGBT Health: Towards meeting the health care needs of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people (2009, PDF). - A framework to support social inclusion for lesbian, gay & bisexual people (2008, PDF).
Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Students in Post-Primary Schools: Guidance for Principals and School Leaders (2009, PDF, Download Page).
School leaders often find themselves having to deal with these
challenges without supports and resources being readily available. In
response to this, the Department of Education & Science has worked
collaboratively with GLEN (Gay and Lesbian Equality Network) to produce
this resource. It is intended to support school leaders when addressing
the challenge of homophobic bullying and when addressing other sexual
orientation issues in their school. The resource is set out in
stand-alone sections and provides information and practical suggestions
on how school leaders can support young people who are lesbian, gay or
bisexual. - Minister for Lifelong Learning Speech (2009, Word Download, Download Page). - Comments by Sandra Gowran, Director of Education Policy, GLEN at the launch (2009, Word Download, Download Page). Related Press Release (2009, Word Download, Download Page).
Gay, Lesbian & Bisexual People: The Irish Institute of Mental Health Nursing: A Good Practice Guide for Mental Health Nurses (2010, PDF, Download Page):
"This good practice guide has been developed by the Irish Institute of
Mental Health Nursing (IIMHN) in collaboration with GLEN (Gay and
Lesbian Equality Network) to inform mental health nurses of what they
need to know when providing a service to a lesbian, gay or bisexual
(LGB) person. In recent years, a number of national policies have
highlighted the need for lesbian, gay and bisexual people’s needs to be
considered by health professionals and for health care providers to be
more inclusive of lesbian, gay and bisexual people in their practice.
There are specific issues that mental health nurses need to be aware of
when providing a services to LGB people. By being aware of these issues
nurses can help to reduce or eliminate the barriers to accessing
support services that LGB people face. This guide is intended to
support mental health nurses to provide services that are accessible
for LGB people and one that is appropriate to theirneeds." Suicidality Study Results Given: "17.7%
of respondents had attempted suicide, just under two thirds of whom had
tried to end their lives on more than one occasion. 85% of those who
had attempted suicide saw their first attempt as in some way related to
their LGB identity and almost 50% saw it as very or very much related
to their LGB identity. A quarter of all female survey participants and
fifteen percent of male participants had attempted suicide at least
once in their lifetime. A higher proportion of those identifying as
bisexual (25%) had attempted suicide than those who identified as gay
or lesbian (17%). 13% of participants had actually made a suicide plan
during the previous twelve months and almost a fifth of these had gone
on to attempt suicide. The average age of first attempted suicide was
17.46 years (with an age range of 8 to 42 years), which supports
existing evidence that it is young LGB people who are most at risk of
suicidal behaviour. Over half of those aged 25 or younger admitted to
ever having given serious consideration to ending their own lives while
just under a fifth admitted to ever having attempted suicide. Over a
third of those aged 25 years and under had thought seriously about
ending their lives within the past year. This indicates that a
significant sub-group of young of LGB young people in particular are at risk for suicidal ideation and attempting suicide.
Supporting Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual & Transgender (LGBT) Callers: An Introduction for Samaritans Volunteers (2010, PDF, Download Page):
This guide is written for Samaritans volunteers to support them in
providing a confidential, non-judgemental listening service to LGBT
callers. It aims to advance their understanding of the circumstances
and experiences of LGBT people in Ireland so that they may better
understand the issues callers may be dealing with. In addition to the
general reasons for someone calling Samaritans, there are specific
issues that LGBT callers may be facing. They can also face challenges
and barriers which Samaritans volunteers can help reduce or eliminate.
The guide includes good practice guidelines for Samaritans volunteers
and the appendix contains a list of LGBT organisations and services in
Ireland as well as a reading reference list.
Report: Suicide prevention plan largely ignored
(2009): Only a fifth of recommendations from a major suicide prevention
plan have been properly acted on three years after it was first
published, it emerged today. The report – The High Level of Suicide in
Irish Society – was launched in July 2006 by the Oireachtas Health
Committee with 33 actions aimed at tackling the country’s high suicide
levels. But a review found work has been carried out on just seven,
with limited or no progress made on the rest by the agencies
responsible, including the Department of Health, HSE and gardaí.
“We absolutely have to challenge it because it can result in young
people, who are trying to come to terms with their sexual orientation,
self harming or worse and that’s not acceptable,” he said. “There are a
lot of people who would consider this to be inappropriate in certain
schools. “I think some places don’t even have proper sexual education
never mind discussions about the danger of homophobic bullying so we do
have a bit work to do.” Mr Andrews said he was concerned over reports
teachers have victimised youngsters over their sexual orientation. “If
it exists at all it’s a real worry to me,” said Mr Andrews. “I was a
school teacher myself and I find it hard to believe that teachers would
be, in the first instance, that ignorant about homosexuality but also
to bully children about it. - A fifth of gay people tried suicide – “Step up and Speak out”.
Invitation to Tender (2010, Word Download):
The Gay and Lesbian Equality Network (GLEN) in collaboration with Age
& Opportunity wish to commission a research project entitled,
Identifying the experiences and needs of older Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual
and Transgender (LGBT) people in Ireland and recommending positive
ageing strategies and actions to promote their full participation and
inclusion in Irish society. Full details, including tender guidelines,
are attached... No large-scale research has been carried out in Ireland
that specifically identifies the experiences and needs of older LGBT
people in Ireland. As a result, the Gay and Lesbian Equality
Network (GLEN) wish to commission a research study to identify the
circumstances and needs of older LGBT people in the Republic of Ireland
(55 and over). The research will also recommend mechanisms for
addressing the identified needs of older LGBT people in an Irish
context... In an Irish context, the most significant research to-date
on LGBT people is the Supporting LGBT Lives study (Mayock et al
2009). This study was commissioned by BeLonG To Youth Service and
GLEN and was funded by the National Office for Suicide
Prevention. The aim was to examine LGBT mental health and
well-being, including the identification of suicide risk and resilience
factors among Irish LGBT people... While the findings of Supporting LGBT Lives
give an in-depth picture of what it is like to grow up and live as an
LGBT person in Ireland, LGBT people over 50 were under-represented in
the sample. This further highlights the need to examine the
particular circumstances, experiences and needs of older LGBT people
and to carry out research on this sub-group of the LGBT population.
Responding to the needs of vulnerable lesbian, gay, bisexual
and transgendered youth (2005, Word Download). By: Michael Barron, Belong To Youth
Project and
Eoin Collins, Gay and
Lesbian Equality Network. Paper Presented to: Irish Association of
Suicidology
5th National Conference ‘Partnerships for Reducing Youth Suicide’: One
of the most alarming findings from research on lesbian, gay, bisexual
and transgender (LGBT) people has been evidence of elevated rates of
suicide and attempted suicide, and mental health problems among young
LGBT people. The 2004 ShOut Report, commissioned by the Department of
Education in Northern Ireland for example, found that that among young
people surveyed across Northern Ireland, those who identified as LGBT
were: • At least three times more likely to attempt
suicide; • Two and half times more likely to self harm;
• Five times more likely to be medicated for depression;
and • Twenty times more likely to suffer from an eating disorder
than their heterosexual counterparts (YouthNet, 2004). These problems
are directly linked to the additional challenges that LGBT youth face
in their lives, challenges that others of the same age may not
experience, or experience to the same degree. These include:...
Suicide shocks Derry gay community
(2007): "Eamon Johnston, the winner of Mr Gay Derry 2003, has committed
suicide. He was 22... Mr Johnston was a hairdresser and support
counsellor for gay group Rainbow Project... His mother told Derry
Journal that her son was a "lovely wee boy" and appealed to other
suicidal peopleto seek help instead of taking their lives...- Ireland’s First Gay & Lesbian Awareness Week for Young People (2010).
Study:
Suicide rate high for Irish gay teens (Alternate Link): "Inside Story
January 20, 2004 - Belfast, Northern Ireland | Nearly a third of young
lesbian and gay people in Northern Ireland have tried to kill themselves
because of ongoing persecution and bullying, according to a new survey.
Just over 29 percent of gay respondents to the Department of Education
(news - web sites) poll said they had attempted suicide, with as many as
50 percent saying they suffered some sort of bullying regarding their sexuality.
Additionally, 26 percent of young people self-harmed as a way of dealing
with the pressures they faced regarding their sexuality." - Boys
Don't Cry: How many gay Irish men have taken their lives in the last year?
Nobody knows (2003, Alternate Link): "The report's findings on the experiences of gay men
and women show an increased risk of suicide - though this varies considerably
according to individual, social, economic and sociopolitical circumstances...
Will Peters of Gay HIV Strategies says: "Personally I believe the rates
have always been very high. It is a hard thing to say publicly because
of the families who have been bereaved by suicide, but I think that a lot
of these young men who are being mourned were gay. And they were gay 20
or 30 years ago." ..."People had plenty of anecdotal evidence. Schools,
for example, told us that most bullying manifests itself in homophobia." - Mental health: lesbians and gay men: Developing Strategies to Counter the Impact of Social Exclusion and Stigmatisation (2003, PDF) by Brian Dillon & Eoin Collins. Report prepared for Gay HIV Strategies and The Northern Area Health Board.
Gay
Suicide problems (Ireland) N/A:
"Ross White, the winner from The Queen's University of Belfast, undertook
his research with The Rainbow Project.
Together they looked at the incidence
of suicide among gay men in Northern Ireland. Both students have now undertaken
further study at their respective Universities... Ross's project looked
at the relationship between factors associated with a gay lifestyle and
attempted suicide. "The number of suicide attempts among the people we
spoke to was very high, with some reporting four, five and even nine attempts
to take their own life. Thirty-two percent of those who took part in the
study had attempted suicide. Although the project stands on its own as
a body of work, my involvement with the Rainbow Project and the gay men
who participated in the study educated me over and above what can be written
in a report. The experience had a profound effect on me and the stories
of those I met will stay with me forever." - Ulster's Young Gay men 30 Times More Likely to Attempt Suicide (1999):
"The number of suicide attempts among the people we spoke to was very
high, with some reporting four, five and even nine attempts to take
their own life. Thirty-two percent of those who took part in the study
had attempted suicide. According to Ross, most of those who tried to
kill themselves had taken a drug or alcohol overdose: Men who had been
sexually assaulted or bullied at school were more likely to attempt
suicide. Those who had lost a friend through suicide or who had
low-self esteem/high hopelessness were also more likely to try and kill
themselves. It is clear that problems exist and they are not being
adequately addressed."
Research into Male Suicide
(2008, Ulster): Researchers at the University of Ulster are
urging young men in north and west Belfast who have considered suicide
to speak to them in a bid to help others in this situation. They hope
to speak confidentially to men aged between 16 and 34 who have thought
seriously about or acted with the intention of suicide, in order to
develop care and support programmes for those at risk. During the
interview the men will be asked to talk about issues in their lives
that have influenced their thoughts about suicide and the types of help
and support that they have used when feeling suicidal. Around 50 of the
242 people registered in 2007 in Northern Ireland as taking their own
lives were men in this age group according to statistics released this
month by NISRA... Dr Joanne Jordan, from the School of Nursing and
Midwifery at QUB, is leading the study, which is entitled Providing
Meaningful Care: Learning from the Experiences of Suicidal Men. -
Related Conference Presentation: Engaging Men in Research on Service
Improvement around Sensitive Issues: Some Insights from a Study on
Suicidal Behavior amongst Young People in Northern Ireland (2009, PDF):
In seeking to engage potentially emotionally vulnerable young men,
efforts to date have concentrated on establishing the necessary
infrastructure to ensure a methodologically rigorous and ethically
sound approach to understanding suicide. Consequently, this study has
consulted with a diverse range of agencies, organizations, and
individuals within both the statutory and non-statutory sectors in
Northern Ireland. These consultations have been invaluable in ensuring
that researchers are cognizant of, and respond appropriately to, the
needs of all those involved in the study. Discussion: The presentation
discusses a number of issues encountered in the course of preliminary
research activity and the steps taken by way of research design,
associated training activity, and support mechanisms put in place for
the young men, the clinicalinterviewers, and wider research team.
NI survey shows extent of gay suicide issue
(2006): early two-thirds considered killing themselves and 30% self
harmed, according to the survey, which was carried out over three years
by the Rainbow Project in Belfast. The survey of 190 young gay or
bisexual men revealed one third were diagnosed as having a mental
illness at some time in their lives with almost as many having had a
potential psychiatric disorder. A quarter had attempted suicide and
over two thirds thought about taking their own lives. Four out of five
who had thoughts of suicide indicated those were related to same sex
attraction. Among the key factors which contributed to suicidal
thoughts and self harm were negative experiences in school such as
bullying. The findings of 'Out On Your Own' were released at a
conference in Belfast opened by the Chief of the Equality Commission,
Bob Collins.
McNamee H (2006).
Out on Your Own: An Examination of the Mental Health of Young Same-Sex
Attracted Men. Belfast: The Rainbow Project. Internet: Download Page. PDF Download. Alternate Link, Alternate Link:
Over one quarter (27.1per cent) of the respondents had attempted
suicide and over two thirds (71.3 per cent) of respondents had thought
about taking their own life. Four out of five (80.5 per cent) of the
respondents who had suicidal thoughts indicated that the suicidal
thoughts were related to their same-sex attraction. Within the survey,
30.7 per cent of the respondents had self harmed. One fifth (20.6 per
cent) of the respondents had self harmed more than once and 11.1 per
cent had self harmed once. Two-thirds (64.4 per cent) of those who had
self harmed indicated that the selfharmingwas related to their same-sex attraction. - The USL GLBT Mental Health Campaign:
""A recent survey carried out in Northern Ireland showed over ‘one
quarter (27.1 per cent) of respondents had attempted suicide and over
two thirds (71.3 per cent) of respondents had thought about taking
their own life’ (Out on You Own, McNamee). This is a huge problem
within the LGBT community and further research and initiatives are
needed to help solve the problem."
Carolan F, Redmond S (Youthnet, 2003). ShOut:
Research into the Needs of Young People in Northern Ireland Who
Identify as Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and/or Transgender (LGBT). Commissioned by the Department of Education. Belfast, Ireland: Youthnet. Internet: Full Text. Full Text. Full Text. Download Page. Full Text. Full Text: N = 362, 14 (4%)
= Trannssexual/Transgender, 52 (14%) = Bisexual - Lifetime Suicide Attempt
Incidence: Males (28%, N = 232) - Females (30%, N = 130) - TS/TV (64%,
N = 14).
On Tuesday 19th March, OUThouse at 105 hosted a Panel Discussion on the topic of LGBT youth suicide (Word Download).
To the best of my knowledge, this is the first time a discussion has
been held to discuss the issue of suicide in the Gay community, and
particularly among younger members of that community... During his
input on the evening, Cathal Kelly spoke of his disappointment and that
of other Community groups who made a submission to the Government’s
Task Force in 1996. This Task Force purported to look at the
higher rates of suicide and identify what might be done to reduce
them. Submissions were requested via the media, and the NLGF and
Lesbian Line Dublin responded. Submissions were based on research
conducted abroad, and by the Combat Poverty Agency. They included
a list of recommendations such as specifically mentioning LGBT’s in
targeted activities to reduce suicide rates. In relation to LGBT
youth, the submission identified key people in the Community,
Gardaí, doctors, youth workers etc. who particularly needed to
be made aware that clients they encounter could potentially be LGBT,
and this needs to be factored into how these clients are dealt
with. Despite this submission, there was a resounding silence on
the issue of LGBT suicide when the Report was published... Fergal
Carroll based on his own research and clinical experience, outlined
some of the factors contributing to this increased vulnerability.
While it is obvious that LGBT adolescents will face the same stressors
as any adolescent, in the case of LGBT youth, these stressors are
enhanced by the lack of positive role models and positive messages
about their sexuality. There are also issues around the education
system and the lack of gay positive messages, and anti-homophobic
policies in the school system. These means that as well as
internalised negative images, there are external factors that may come
into play such as bullying or harassment. All of this at a time
of life when pressure to conform is at its highest can increase suicide
risk for LGBT youth.
Growing
up as a gay young person in Ireland - so what's the story? (2000) "I feel so trapped and isolated that my life doesn't feel worth living...
He attempted suicide by overdosing deliberately on paracetamol. He survived
and is lucky to have suffered no long term effects on his health... To
pretend the problem of homophobic bullying does not exist as an issue in
every school is just naive... The levels of gay youth
suicide are alarming and if one looks at these type of situations, is this
surprising? A report in Northern Ireland, conducted by the Science Shop
- a joint initiative by the University of Ulster and Queen's University
- revealed that: "YOUNG gay men are 30 times more likely to attempt suicide
than their heterosexual counterparts." "Some have made as many as nine
unsuccessful attempts to kill themselves. About 54 per cent of those interviewed
had seriously considered suicide and one in three had attempted suicide.
More than half had been bullied at school as a result of being gay." Queen's
student Ross White carried out the research for the Rainbow Project, a
health organisation for gay and bisexual men. He looked at the relationship
between factors associated with a gay lifestyle and attempted suicide.
"The number of suicide attempts among the people we spoke to was very high,
with some reporting four, five and even nine attempts to take their own
life," Mr White said. "Thirty-two per cent of those who took part in the
study had attempted suicide." Most of those who tried to kill themselves
had taken a drug or alcohol overdose. "Men who had been sexually assaulted
or bullied at school were more likely to attempt suicide," Mr White said.
"Those who had lost a friend through suicide or who had low self-esteem/high
hopelessness were also more likely to try and kill themselves." The Rainbow
Project has launched an anti-bullying campaign in the north. Adrian McCracken
of the Rainbow Project said: "We knew there was a problem but didn't realise
how big it was. "It's particularly high here because a lot of young gay
men are not able to come out at school, there are no support services."
Statements on Suicide Prevention Strategy - 24th October 2007:
"[Homosexuality for young gay men] is a discovery, not a decision and
for many it is a discovery which is made against a backdrop where ...
they have long encountered anti-gay attitudes which will do little to
help them deal openly and healthily with their own sexuality. The
multiplier effect relating to suicide is significant for young gay
people and is an established fact so I will put supporting research on
the record of the House of which I hope the Minister of State is
aware..."
The
gay youth suicide issue is noted in the article Young,
Queer & Proud!, published in Worker's Solidarity,
No. 53. Jan. 1998). A Workers Solidarity Movement position paper
titled Gay,
Lesbian & Bisexual Oppression
is also available at the
same web site: The Gay Liberation movement has been active in Ireland
since the early 1970s. A small number of activists have been successful
in putting the issue of discrimination at work, in housing, and
socially on the public agenda. Two public sector trade unions passed
anti-discrimination policies. In the late 1980s this position was
adopted officially by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions.
The
1995 report - Poverty
- Lesbians and Gay Men: The Economic and Social Effects of Discrimination
- published by the Combat Poverty Agency, Ireland (ISBN 1 871643 53 8 reports
facts possibly implicated in suicide problems. "The study found that 21
per cent of respondents were living in poverty and over half (57 per cent)
of respondents said they found it difficult to make ends meet. The findings
also outlined clearly the range of effects of harassment and discrimination,
and the extent of social exclusion experienced by lesbians and gay men."
Researching lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender issues in Northern Ireland (2004, PDF Download).
Research highlights: 95 Gay/Bi
Males aged 15-26 (Average age = 20.8 years). 28% of respondents had at
some point deliberately injured themselves with no suicidal intent. This
compares to 2% of men in the general population.. 54% of respondents had
seriously considered taking their own life, compared to 13% of men in the
general population who have ever considered suicide. 51% of respondents
who had previously considered suicide now no longer felt suicidal. However,
15% of respondents still seriously considered suicide at least once a month.
27% of young gay/bisexual men have attempted suicide compared to 4% of
the general population. Suicide attempts were most common in those young
gay/bisexual men aged 14 to 20. 58% of those who had attempted suicide
made only one attempt. 35% had made three or more attempts. 23% made five
or more attempts. 54% of respondents who had attempted suicide had at some
point deliberately injured themselves without wanting to take their own
life.
Overview of mental health services: Ausit Scotland (2009, PDF):
Edinburgh Crisis Centre: Edinburgh Crisis Centre was established in
August 200 to provide support to people who are using, or have used,
mental health services in Edinburgh and their carers.The service is
community-based and can be accessed 24 hours a day, 3 5 days a year.
The Centre provides crisis support through a free telephone helpline,
face-to-face support and also has facilities for people who need to
stay overnight... Monitoring data based on 78 callers show that 23 per
cent of Centre users define themselves as lesbian, gay, bisexual or
transgender and 4 per cent identified themselves as disabled.
Truth Hurts: Report of the National Inquiry into Self-harm among Young People (2008, Mental Health Foundation). PDF. Download Page. GLBT issues mentiones, nothing that there is a lack of related research specific to Scotland.
Challenging Prejudice: Changing Attitudes Towards Lesbian,
Gay, Bisexual and Transgender People In Scotland: Recommendations of the
LGBT Hearts and Minds Agenda Group (The Scottish Government, 2008, PDF).
Whittle S, Turner L, Al-Alami M (2007). Engendered Penalties: Transgender and Transsexual People’s Experiences of Inequality and Discrimination. Manchester Metropolitan University. A Research Project and Report Commissioned by the Equalities Review. PDF Download.
Investigating the links between mental health and behaviour in schools (2005, PDF): A report to the Scottish Executive Education Department Pupil
Support and Inclusion Division. "Agencies such as the Mental Health
Foundation, Stonewall and LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender)
Youth Scotland have found levels of suicide among young gay men to be
higher than among the male population generally. Equally, homophobic
bullying has been recognised as a major issue within schools but little
systematic work has taken place on this. Levels of understanding about
the experiences of young lesbians in schools remains poorly understood.
Particular fears about disclosure are likely to influence the ways in
which research with these groups takes place.
‘Towards
a Healthier LGBT Scotland’ - report [October, 2003] on LGBT health
in Scotland: (Alternate Link) (Alternate Link) "The INCLUSION Project, working for LGBT Health, was launched
in October 2002, a partnership between Stonewall Scotland, representing
Scotland’s LGBT communities and the Scottish Executive Health Department.
The project has been gathering available evidence, undertaking new research,
co-ordinating demonstration activity and supporting community capacity
building, to identify the support needed by local NHS services to better
meet the needs of individuals from LGBT communities... 25% of respondents
in a Scottish survey of LGBT people had experienced inappropriate advice
or treatment due to sexual orientation or gender identity and 24% had experienced
homophobic staff... Research investigating the link between suicide and
sexual orientation suggests unusually high rates of attempted suicide in
the range of 20 – 42%... 75% gay men under 36 yrs have tried drugs compared
to 47% general population - 80% lesbians / bi women stated they had been
affected by their own drug / alcohol use or someone close to them...
Scottish Government Publication: The case for LGBT equality (2008): Results of studies given.
On
the basis of a report on the Equality
for All Conference held on June 20th 1997 in Edinburgh City Chambers,
the following problems negatively affecting GLB youth - listed in the "youth"
section - are similar to the ones negatively affecting their North American
counterparts who are at high risk for having suicide problems.
General
social and legal discrimination.
Becoming
"homeless after coming out to parents." "Parent support - often absent
for young LGBT people." "Often when coming out they may face rejection
from family and friends, they may need to become independent at an early
age and this may lead to financial problems, leading to prostitution and
abuse."
Ignorance of GLBT issues in education, and anti-gay abuse by peers ("bullying"). "Gay bashing."
"Lack - a general lack of services for young LGBT people... Support networks - support networks are mostly heterosexist for young people."
"Gay scene - baptism of fire, expensive and predatory... off-putting, exploitative... lack of diversity on the gay scene."
"Prostitution - need for money for living, confirmation of sexuality in absence of school or other support."
"Marginalisation - young people's needs marginalised, high priority on needs of older men especially i.e. fucking."
Summary Excerpt: "The workshop raised a number of issues in terms of interconnections between various areas not noted above: ...Most young LGBT people are not out and so have no access to information, little positive imagery or support networks, this will normally lead to low self-worth, lack of confidence, under achievement, isolation, development of damaging emotional defences, participation in damaging relationships, self-harm, premature independence and associated effects."
Scottish
Parliament Scraps Clause 28 (June 2000).
A
Suicide Problem Indicator: Robertson AE (1998).
The
mental health experiences of gay men: a research study exploring gay men's
health needs. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 5(1),
33-40. (A PubMed abstract)
From the Abstract: A study of 37 gay men reports that they "faced profound social difficulties when coming to terms with their sexuality, a process that can occur throughout their life time." Married gay males were especially at risk and "cited alcohol misuse and depression amongst the effects of this stressful [double] lifestyle."
ScotsGay
Magazine has an occasional mention of suicide issues related
to a number of situations.
Morrison
C, Mackay A (2000). The Experience of Violence and Harassment of Gay
Men in the City of Edinburgh. The Scottish Executive Central Research Unit.
Internet: http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2000/07/6540/File-1
.
France
France:
- Détresse psychique et homosexualité: état des connaissances et enjeux méthodologiques de recherche (2008, PDF, PDF):
À la lumière des résultats avancés par les
études relatives à la santé mentale des
homosexuels, et quelle que soit l’approche préconisée, il
existe une détresse psychique importante dans cette population. - Le Mal-être Des Jeunes Homos [enquête]
(2009): Un tiers des jeunes homos de 14 à 21 ans disent avoir
été victimes d'actes homophobes, la moitié
rencontrent des difficultés à assumer leur
homosexualité, 1 sur 5 a fait une tentative de suicide : ce sont
les principaux enseignements de l'enquête du MAG.- Le suicide révèle la souffrance singulière des jeunes homosexuels (2005). - HES
et le MAG livrent les premiers résultats de l'enquête
qu'ils ont menée sur le vécu des jeunes populations trans
en France (2009): Un tiers (34%) des jeunes trans déclarent
avoir tenté de se suicider. Par ailleurs, 98% des jeunes trans
interrogés expriment un mieux-être une fois le parcours de
transition de genre commencé. - Le suicide, un mal homosexuel ? Nombre de jeunes gays français se donnent la mort (2010).
Le
risque de suicide chez les jeunes a orientations sexuelles non conventionelles
(lesbiennes, bisexuelles, gais) (PDF
Download, Homosexualites et Socialism, Rapport, 2001). - Le
rejet social comme origine du suicide (2003). (Alternate Link) - Avoir
16 ans et être homo (2004): "La vie est très difficile lorsqu'on
se découvre gay au collège et au lycée. Un petit aperçu
de mon histoire à moi et mes conseils... C'était également
un moyen d'annoncer mon homosexualité aux gens qui m'entourent.
Grave erreur. Dans le cercle de mes amis, je me suis découvert des
ennemis suite à cette annonce. ça a été un
calvaire cette dernière année. Insultes, sous-entendus mal
placés, et même des crachas..." - Suicide
et dépression: "Suicide et sexualité sont encore
aujourd'hui en France des sujets relativement tabous. De nombreux experts
estiment que les statistiques sur le suicide sont sous-évaluées.
De plus, à la différence des États-Unis, du Canada
et de l'Italie, aucune étude n'a été menée
à ce jour sur les risques suicidaires dans la population des jeunes
gais et lesbiennes et celles réalisées sur le suicide chez
les jeunes n'interrogent, ni ne prennent en compte les difficultés
liées à l'acceptation de l'homosexualité ou de pratiques
homosexuelles...
Suicide
et dépression chez les adolescents homosexuels, l'urgence
d'une action!!! - Le suicide qui n’ose pas dire son nom: "Le livre Homosexualité
& suicide, au travers d’études et de 13 témoignages,
propose une explication du taux de suicide apparemment plus élevé
chez les gays et lesbiennes et particulièrement les jeunes... Je
cite un paragraphe du livre qui résume les principaux facteurs à
risque pour le jeune gay : « on s’aperçoit que les risques
suicidaires les plus élevés sont, soit associés à
un vécu persécutif de la part de membres de la famille, de
pairs, ou de professionnels référents ; soit à une
difficulté extrême à traverser la prise de conscience
et / ou la révélation de l’homosexualité ; soit enfin
à une incapacité à vivre l’un de ses premiers amours,
à un rejet de sa part ou à une rupture amoureuse.." - Tentatives
de suicide à l’adolescence: souffrance singulière et mal-être
social: "Les jeunes face à l’homophobie" par Eric Verdier, Coauteur
de Homosexualité et suicide (p. 14-16. PDF
Download) - Suicide
Mortelle homophobie: Entretien réalisé par Dany Stive:
Éric Verdier et Jean-Marie Firdion, Homosexualités et
Suicide (Alternate Link). - Contribution d’Eric Verdier À L’amphi 2005. - Une
recherche action d’Éric Verdier: Préférence
sexuelle, niveau social, origine ethnique : la discrimination conduit
à la prise de risque..
Modes
de consommation d’alcool et tentatives de suicide chez l’homme jeune:
"Population et méthodes: Il s’agit d’une population exclusivement
masculine, représentative des 400 000 sujets sélectionnés
tous les ans dans l’ensemble des 10 centres de sélection de métropole
[Paris]. 9 758 sujets ont été tirés au sort. 9 270
réponses furent exploitables (taux de participation : 95 %). L’âge
moyen est de 20 ans, les extrêmes se situant de 17 à 29 ans.
Le taux de réponse aux 119 items de l’autoquestionnaire varie entre
88 % et 99 % selon les questions. L’enquête s’est déroulée
entre novembre 1992 et février 1993... Conclusions: ...D’autres
facteurs du risque suicidaire, non étudiés en détail,
ont été relevés, tels l’usage de drogues illicites,
de tabac et l’homosexualité. Parmi les sujets ayant fait un geste
suicidaire, un sur deux présente deux facteurs de risque ou plus."
État
de la question et pistes de prévention: Synthèse de la journée
d’étude organisée le 17 juillet 2001 (PDF
Download): "Depression, tentatives de suicide et trise de risque
parmis les lecteurs de la presse gay francaise" (Philippe ADAM, Institut
de Veille Sanitaire, Saint-Maurice, France): "4753 questionnaires remplis
par des hommes... Pour ce qui est des répondants masculins, l ’échantillon
se caractérise par une forte représentation des personnes
qui vivent en région parisienne (42%) et qui sont allés à
l ’université (62%). L ’âge moyen est de 35 ans. La plupart
(91%) des répondants se définissent comme gays. La moitié
ont un partenaire stable. 12% des répondants sont séropositifs
pour le VIH... Nous commencerons par dresser un état des lieux à
partir des autodéclarations des répondants. Parmi eux, 17%
déclarent avoir déjà fait une tentative de suicide
au cours de leur vie... Le graphique précédent montre que
le taux de déclaration de tentatives de suicide est déjà
à son maximum (27%) parmi les moins de 20 ans puis il décroît
régulièrement avec l’âge pour se stabiliser autour
de 15% après 35 ans."
Evaluation
de l’effet éventuel de la sursuicidalité sur les comportements
sexuels à risque chez les jeunes hommes ayant des relations entre
eux. Conséquences sur la pratique du dépistage du VIH
(PDF
Download, PDF
Download): "La sursuicidalité des jeunes hommes ayant des relations
entre eux (HSH)... Cette étude exploratoire a été
réalisée en 2001 en milieu ouvert (à l’occasion d’une
manifestation festive) sur un échantillon (n=368; F=55%; âge
médian: F=19 ans; [ET=6,7]; H=21 ans; [ET=8]), vivant principalement
en région parisienne –sur-représenté en HSH (17%)
– rapportant pour environ 12% au moins une tentative de suicide (TS) durant
la vie. Les résultats obtenus confirment la sursuicidalité
des HSH (30%; p<0.05 ; 6 fois supérieure à celle des hommes
hétérosexuels) strictement comparable aux données
épidémiologiques disponibles..."
Suicide
et tentative de suicide parmi les personnes à orientation homo-/bisexuel (Alternate Link, 2003):
- Prévalence des tentatives de suicide (France) selon le sexe et
l’orientation sexuelle... Hommes: 17%. 17%; Femmes: 25%. - Vos
avis au sujet de l'homosexualité: "Bonjour à tous....
je m'appelle Vanessa, je vais avoir 20 ans au mois de juin 2003. Je suis
homosexuelle (lesbienne, gwenn, comme vous le désirez...). Je n'ai
pas choisi d'être comme celà! Je me suis rendue compte malgré
moi que j'aimais une femme! Autre chose, c'est grâce à des
homophobes comme ceux-ci qu'à mes 17 ans, j'ai fait une tentative
de suicide! ...Un jour il a tenté de se suicider mais sa mère
est arrivé avant pour éviter la catastrophe. Ensuite il a
dit à toutes les personnes qu'il connaissait qu'il était
homo. Tout le monde l'a plus où moins accepté mais il est
quand même retourné avec un fille à cause de la pression
et des regards. Maintenant il vit avec une fille, mais il fait dépression
sur dépression, tentative de suicide sur tentative de suicide, il
est terriblement malheureux, il ne sort plus beaucoup à cause du
regards des gens. En gros, il est en train de se détruire et de
mourir tout ça à cause de ces crét... d'homophobes!"
En
prison, être homosexuel, c’est la pire des choses: "Mais
le pire s’est produit récemment et au moment où vous lisez
ce témoignage, mon ami est dans un service psychiatrique, suite
à une tentative de suicide. J’ai effectivement appris récemment
qu’il a été violé par trois détenus sous les
douches quelques jours avant son transfert. Comme d’habitude en prison,
ses cris n’ont pas été entendus. Les trois détenus
et les surveillants ont probablement tous supposé qu’un homosexuel
apprécierait de se faire enculer violemment par des inconnus. En
11 ans, mon ami aura donc subi deux viols en milieu carcéral. Première
incarcération : premier viol : transmission du VIH. Deuxième
incarcération : second viol : tentative de suicide..."
Les
chiffres noirs du suicide: "Selon les nouvelles données
de l’Enquête presse gay 2000, que «Têtu» présente
en exclusivité, un gay sur six a déjà fait une tentative
de suicide. Et les liens entre dépression et prise de risques sexuels
font froid dans le dos... Le premier mérite de cette enquête
est qu’elle nous donne, enfin, des chiffres précis sur la dépression
et les tentatives de suicide chez les gays. Malgré les informations
alarmantes en provenance d’autres pays depuis quelques années, ces
problématiques, bien documentées chez les hétérosexuels,
étaient jusqu’à présent complètement ignorées
en ce qui concerne les gays. Parmi les hommes ayant répondu à
l’Enquête presse gay, 17 % déclarent avoir déjà
fait une tentative de suicide au cours de leur vie, soit environ un homo
sur six. Ces données sont similaires à celles de plusieurs
enquêtes menées à l’étranger, notamment aux
États-Unis..."
Le
Refuge: L'Association nationale: Agir contre l'isolement des adolescents
attirés par une personne du même sexe. - L'association
dresse un constat troublant sur la situation des adolescents homosexuels
en France. Face à cet état des lieux, il était urgent
de réagir. Jeanne (Alternate Link):
"Mon fils s'est suicidé il y a de cela quatre ans, il avait 17 ans.
Personne n'a compris ce geste à l'époque, même s'il
présentait depuis quelques temps des signes de dépression.
Pour moi ce fut un choc. En rangeant ses affaires, j'ai compris, il y a
trois an de cela, son " secret ". Je pense que mon fils était homosexuel.
J'ai retrouvé des revues érotiques masculines sous son lit
et des lettres assez équivoques. Je comprends maintenant cette douleur
qui le hantait." - Le
suicide de jeunes homosexuel/le/s. - Et
si votre enfant était homosexuel?
L'université
euroméditerranéenne des homosexualités: ..."Le
ministère s'intéresse également à la santé
des lesbiennes, cible du cancer du sein et peu touchée par les campagnes
de prévention. Mais surtout, dans le cadre de la prévention
du suicide chez les jeunes - l'une des premières causes de mortalité
dans cette population -, la DGS mène des actions spécifiques
pour prévenir les dégâts générés
par l'homophobie. Robert Simon rappelait « il y a un lien très
fort entre violation des droits de l'Homme et santé »." - Suicide : un risque plus eleve chez les jeunes homosexuels. - La
place de l'homosexualité dans l'éducation sexuelle en milieu
scolaire: L'homosexualité à l'adolescence (2002, Alternate Link). - Adolescence,
Homosexualité et Violence - Projet Daphné. - Adolescence
et homosexualité: souffrance, tabou social et inertie éducative.
- Autour
du coming-out: Quand la sortie est mal acceptée par la famille Réfléchir
avant de sortir de son placard.
Le
suicide du jeune gai, réalité ou mythe? - Les
adolescents homosexuels et le suicide: "Notre propos ne portera pas
sur l'interprétation à donner aux articles de Gageure, mais
il nous a semblé important de les évoquer afin de montrer
à quel point la question peut être tabou tant chez les homos
que chez les hétéros. Pour aborder le plus objectivement
possible la question du suicide chez les adolescents homos ou bisexuels,
il faut avant tout présenter ces statistiques que certains mettent
en doute..." - Controverse
sur l'existence d'un risque accru de suicide chez les jeunes homosexuels.
Prévention du suicide et pratiques de réseaux-congrès international-Liège du 18 au22/11/2002 (PDF):
" Les résultats obtenus : • confirment la sursuicidalité
des HSH (30% ; p<0.05 ; 6 fois supérieure à celle des
hommes hétérosexuels..." - Suicide des jeunes : premiers chiffres français. - Péril suicidaire chez les jeunes homos:
Une enquête indépendante révèle qu’un homo
ou bisexuel homme a treize fois plus de risques de faire une tentative
de suicide qu’un hétérosexuel. Extrait de l’article paru
dans liberation.fr. - Le suicide révèle la souffrance singulière des jeunes homosexuels (2005): "Les résultats préliminaires du travail de Marc Shelly,
médecin de santé publique et responsable du centre de
dépistage anonyme et gratuit de l’hôpital parisien
Fernand-Widal, font apparaître que, "toutes choses égales
par ailleurs" âge, lieu de résidence, niveau
d’études, catégorie socioprofessionnelle, structure
familiale parentale, modes de vie (couple ou célibat) , les
jeunes homosexuels ont treize fois plus de risque de faire une
tentative de suicide que les jeunes hétérosexuels. Ces
résultats confirment les chiffres issus des études
américaines, canadiennes et australiennes : elles aboutissent,
chez les homosexuels, à des chiffres de "sursuicidalité"
variant de six à treize."
A
French politicians outs himself and states the following (N/A):
"Je suis et resterai persuadé que plus de visibilité (de
tous en général, mais des hommes et femmes publics en particulier)
éviterait sans doute un certain nombre de suicides de jeunes (ou
moins jeunes homosexuels)." - Les
suicides: " En réfléchissant à cette première
tentative des années plus tard, il est possible que cela soit le
refoulement de mon homosexualité qui était encore endormie,
je me souviens étant à l'internat à cette époque
dans une école d'horticulture, dans le dortoir le thème homo
avait été employé et d'ailleurs certains mecs étaient
passé à la pratique pendant la nuit et que moi je ne savais
pas ou j'en étais, le sexe, la masturbation était inconnue
jusqu'à 20ans environ... Pourtant de nouveau quelques années
plus tard je fais ma deuxième tentative de suicide, juste environ
1an avant mon coming out, pourquoi cette nouvelle tentative de me supprimer,
je ne le sais toujours pas, je sais que je suis quelqu'un de très
différent des autres, plutôt fragile, c'est comme ça
surtout que je suis en pleine période d'anorexie physique et mentale,
je veux un suicide rapide et aussi un suicide morbide, j'ai décidé
de ne plus manger et de me laisser mourir à petit feu..." - Le suicide chez les jeunes homosexuels.
Pas
de mission sur le suicide pour Christine Boutin (communiqué
Inter-LGBT - 26 mai 2003): "A l'unanimité, le Conseil de l'Interassociative
lesbienne, gaie bi et trans, réuni ce samedi 24 mai, a voté
une décision demandant à Jean-Pierre Raffarin de retirer
la mission qu'il a confiée à Christine Boutin sur les taux
de suicide en France (cf. décision ci-dessous). Constatant que "Christine
Boutin s'est faite le relais d'une homophobie des plus violentes, et sans
doute des plus destructrices auprès des jeunes en construction de
leur identité", le Conseil de l'Inter-LGBT estime que "la mission
confiée par le Premier Ministre à Christine Boutin est une
provocation à l'égard des associations LGBT". Les associations
font remarquer que la députée " a offert une tribune inédite
à une haine homophobe qu'elle n'inscrira probablement pas dans son
rapport comme une cause de suicide"." - Ex
Aequo écrit à Christine Boutin sur le suicide des jeunes
gays. - Suicide,
prévention : deviner le risque chez l'adolescent. - Le
suicide à l'adolescence.
Italy
/ Italie: - Enquête
Italienne: (Must Scroll) "L'Associazione gay e lesbica de Florence
a mis en place une enquête sur internet à laquelle 800 gais
et lesbiennes du monde entier ont répondu (les deux tiers des réponses
provenaient d'Europe). Cette enquête fait suite à une série
de suicides de jeunes gais en Sardaigne, en Sicile (immolation par le feu)
et en Lombardie ainsi qu'à la mise à mort publique d'un jeune
homosexuel par son père à Foggia dans les Pouilles. Les résultats
de l'enquête internet sont frappants. Si 65 % des gais et 61 % des
lesbiennes avouent avoir pensé au suicide, 22 % des hommes et 21
% des femmes ont effectivement un jour tenté de mettre fin à
leur jour. 28 % des répondants ont effectué un traitement
psychologique ou psychiatrique (11 % contre leur volonté). Enfin
la moitié environ des questionnaires fait état de violences
subies en raison de l'orientation sexuelle, ces violences pouvant être
physiques (le plus souvent les parents et les camarades d'école),
psychologiques ou sexuelles."
Le
suicide de jeunes homosexuel/le/s: "En Italie, par exemple, selon
une enquête réalisée dans le cadre du programme Daphné
financé par l'Union européenne, 40 % des personnes interrogées
avaient envisagé le suicide, et 13 % avaient tenté de se
suicider. C'est dans la tranche d'âge des 14-16 ans que prévalaient
les idées de suicide, tandis que les tentatives de suicide avaient
généralement lieu entre 16 et 18 ans." - Situation
des lesbiennes et des gays dans les États membres du Conseil de
l'Europe: "En Italie, par exemple, selon une enquête réalisée
dans le cadre du programme Daphné financé par l'Union européenne,
40 % des personnes interrogées avaient envisagé le suicide,
et 13 % avaient tenté de se suicider. C'est dans la tranche d'âge
des 14-16 ans que prévalaient les idées de suicide, tandis
que les tentatives de suicide avaient généralement lieu entre
16 et 18 ans." - Situation of lesbians and gays in Council of Europe member states
(2000): In Italy, for example, in a study within the framework of
the EU funded Daphne programme 40 % of respondents had contemplated
suicide and 13% had attempted suicide. The age in which thoughts about
suicide were most prevalent was between 14 and 16, whereas the suicide
attempts tended to take place in the following two years.
Italy has been rocked by the suicide of a teenager who was subjected to anti-gay taunts at school N/A: According to Italy's Gay Help Line, more than one third of the calls it gets are from students distressed by taunting and bullying at school. On Friday homophobic graffiti was sprayed across the front of a well-known gay and lesbian bookshop in Milan. Also on Friday, the Rome chapter of Arcigay claimed that local priests were pressuring mothers to have their gay children exorcised. Arcigay also complained about RAI state TV broadcaster news reports implying that the dead boy was picked on not because he was gay but because he was seen as a 'swot'..."
Self-harm and suicidal behaviour among young Italian lesbians, gays and bisexuals (2007, Conferene Paper, by A. Buffoli University of Padua, Word Download):
720 Italian partecipants (605 M and 115 F) , 18-24 years old, who
identified themselves as lesbian, gay or bisexual answered to an
on-line survey hosted on an internet website. Data collected through
the semi-structured questionnaire are compared for gender, geographical
provenience and sexual orientation. More than 80% of the sample
reported to have thought about suicide and 20% reported one or more
suicide attempts. Participants living in rural areas in South Italy
were at greater risk of suicide.
Belgium
/ Belgique:- A study referenced on the Unit
for Suicide Research's Current
Research Page. (Unit for Suicide Research, University of Gent, Belgium) Study Title: Controlled cross-sectional
study of suicidal thoughts, impulses, and behaviour among homosexual adolescents (1998).
- Homosexualité
et suicide: liaisons dangereuses? - Les
jeunes gays et lesbiennes et le suicide: etat de la question et listes
de prevention. - État de la question et pistes de prévention:
Synthèse de la journée d’étude organisée le
17 juillet 2001 (PDF
Download).
Le
taux des tentatives de suicide est plus élevé chez les jeunes
homosexuels (6 octobre 1998, Must Scroll): "Une étude menée
en Flandres par l'université de Gand montre que les jeunes homosexuels
de 15 à 25 ans ont 2 à 5 fois plus de risque de tenter un
suicide que les jeunes hétérosexuels. 25% des femmes bisexuelles
ou lesbiennes et 13% des hommes homosexuels avaient tenté un suicide,
contre 5.4% des femmes et 5.9% des hommes hétérosexuel-le-s.
45% des femmes bisexuelles ou lesbiennes et 33% des hommes homosexuels
avaient envisagé un suicide, contre 24% des femmes et 16% des hommes
hétérosexuel-le-s. L'étude a été conduite
par le sociologue John Vincke et le psychologue Kees van Heeringen auprès
de 404 jeunes, homosexuels pour la moitié et présentée
au 7ème Symposium Européen « The Suicidal Process:
Challenges for Treatment and Prevention » du 9 au 12 septembre.
Cycle de séminaires: Regards croisés sur la sexualité (Observatoire du Sida et des sexualités,
Belgique, 2005): ... Séance 3 : Les orientations sexuelles,
l’homophobie et l’hétérosexisme... 1. Le paradoxe du
processus de normalisation de l’homosexualité... Processus de
médicalisation de ’homosexualité... L’évolution du
statut de l’homosexualité et le paradoxe de la reconnaissance :
la visibilité
de l’homosexualité sous tension... Santé et
vulnérabilité des personnes homosexuelles... Fonction
sociale des stéréotypes de genre et
vulnérabilité des personnes homosexuelles... L’origine de
l’homophobie : la pyramide socio-historique des sexes, de genre et des
orientations sexuelles et la construction du modèle de la
virilité... Une hiérarchisation sociale et une pyramide
socio-historique... La construction du modèle de la
virilité et l’homophobie...
Switzerland
/ Suisse: - Un
jeune gai sur quatre a tenté de se suicider! - Statistiques
relatives aux tentatives de suicide commises par les adolescents homosexuel(le)s.
(Must Scroll) - Parler
d'homosexualité à l'école? La question gay déchire
leRoyaume-Uni. (Et la situation en Suisse?) - Un
jeune gay sur quatre a tenté de se suicider: "Selon une étude suisse, les garçons âgés
entre 13 et 17 ans qui aiment les garçons traversent une crise profonde.
Le psychiatre lausannois Pierre Cochand propose d'aborder le sujet dans
les écoles. Il note que plus on parle des comportements homosexuels,
plus leur fréquence diminue..." - Suicide
et tentative de suicide parmi les personnes à orientation homo-/bisexuel.
Etude
et statistiques sur les jeunes gays en Suisse Romande: - Le questionnaire
ciblait explicitement des jeunes hommes de 16 à 25 ans... Durant
ces 6 derniers mois, avez-vous eu des idées de suicide? non, jamais:
68.3%; oui, rarement: 16.3%; oui, parfois: 9.8%; oui, souvent: 5.7%...
Avez-vous par le passé tenté de vous suicider? Oui: 24.4%;
Non: 74.4%; ne répond pas: 1.6%. Echantillion: n = 102 jeune hommes
homosexuels et bisexuels. - Le suicide et l'homosexualité.
Germany
/ Allemagne: - A study summary from - Statistiques
relatives aux tentatives de suicide commises par les adolescents homosexuel(le)s: 217 GLB individuals aged 15 - 27 years. 18% have attempted suicide
at least once, 50% responded to negatively in their families, and 66% were
abuse verbally and/or physically in their families. Reference cited:"Sie
liebt sie. Er liebt er." Etude berlinoise sur la situation psychosociale
des adolescents homosexuels (217 personnes entre 15 et 27 ans), Administration
du Sénat, Berlin, 1999 (www.sensjs.berlin.de).
Study Summary (Etude
et statistiques sur les jeunes gays en Suisse Romande): 18% des adolescents
homosexuel(le)s affirment avoir tenté au moins une fois de mettre
fin à leur jours. A l'annonce de leur homosexualité, plus
de 50% des adolescents reçoivent une réaction négative
de la part de leur environnement familial. 66% affirment subir des violences
verbales, voire physiques au sein de leur famille. Plus de 50% des adolescents
interrogés affirment (ab)user de substances nocives (tabac, alcool,
drogues) pour amenuiser leur mal-être. "Sie liebt sie. Er liebt er."
Etude berlinoise sur la situation psychosociale des adolescents homosexuels
(217 personnes entre 15 et 27 ans), Administration du Sénat, Berlin,
1999 (www.sensjs.berlin.de).
Austria: -
The Contribution of Schools to the Feeling of Acceptance and the Risk
of Suicide Attempts among Austrian Gay and Bisexual Males (2007, Word Download, Poster Presentation PDF: 2007, Abstract:
Published Paper, 2010) by M. Plöderl, G. Faistauer, R. Fartacek:
18% of the participants reported having attempted suicide. - The Relation Between Sexual Orientation and Suicide Attempts in Austria (2010). - Suicidality and associated risk factors among lesbian, gay, and bisexual compared to heterosexual Austrian adults
(2005): This is the first study in German-speaking countries to compare
the suicidality of lesbian, gay, and bisexual adults (n = 358) with
matched heterosexual adults (n = 267). The former had significantly
elevated incidences of current suicide ideation (28% vs. 13%) and
lifetime suicide attempts defined in three ways (14% vs. 1% to 10% vs.
2%), including higher incidences for most suicidality-related risk
factors. - Childhood
Gender Nonconformity and Harassment as Predictors of Suicidality among
Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Heterosexual Austrians (2009).
Slovenia:
- "Tednik"
also conducted an interview with gay leader Sandi Perdih at the largest
cemetery in Ljubljana, the capital, as Perdih paid his respects to gays
who were driven to suicide by homophobia N/A. (Must scroll to
locate article.) - Alternate
Link. - Sexual Orientation Discrimination in Slovenia: A Report by SKUC-LL (2001 Survey, Full Text):
One particular response brought home just how profound the effects of
this discrimination can be: one gay man reported that his partner had
committed suicide because he could no longer deal with the problems
brought about by his sexual orientation. - The social situation concerning homophobia and discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation in Slovenia (2009).
Albania: - Country Summaries
- Europe (2008): Many MSM reported extreme frustration at their social
and economic circumstances, while nearly one third reported having
suicidal thoughts.
Hungary:
-
A
father wrote, that his son was gay. His wife, the sons mother, couldnt
accept it and attacked her son. He committed suicide. She couldn't cope
with that and she also committed suicide." - Social Exclusion of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) People in Hungary
(2008): An acquaintance, who works at OMSZ (National Ambulance
Service), encouraged a suicidal transgender girl to continue her
attempt to end her life, and was not prepared to call her by another
name than that on her identity card. He does not tire himself too much
either when attending to Roma people in critical condition.
Romania:
-
The
right that dares not speak its name: "Two young gay men from the Romanian
town of Timisoara, Mirel Ciprian Cucu and Milorad Mutascu, who had been
living together in a flat, were arrested in January 1993. Mirel Cucu was
charged with having sexual relations with a person of the same sex. Milorad
Mutascu was charged with relations with a minor (a heterosexual relationship
between people of the same ages as Cucu and Mutascu would have been lawful).
They received suspended sentences of one and two years respectively. The
two men also faced vilification in the official police newspaper which
published their names, photographs and addresses even before formal charges
had been brought against them. The paper described their relationship as
a 'social danger'. Milorad Mutascu was subsequently unable to find work
because of his 'criminal' record. Two years after his trial, he committed
suicide." - Looking
For Acceptance: "The conference heard testimonies from older participants
who had attempted suicide or been subjected to blackmail; almost without
exception, most had chosen to live a clandestine life, either with a partner
or more likely alone, to escape the attention of a state which in the Ceausescu
era, gaoled homosexuals and subjected them to electric shock treatment." - Romanian MPs vote to decriminalise homosexuality
(2000): Coman, while unable to give any data or numbers on gays and
lesbians in Romania, said human rights watchdogs estimated that
thousands of homosexuals had been put in jail, thrown out of their jobs
and houses, committed suicide or fled the country since 1989.
Greece:
- Konstantin
Tsolakis on the persecution of gay people in Greece N/A: "I grew up in
a society that still considers homosexuality a grave taboo, despite the
fact that it ceased to be illegal a long time ago. I will never forget
watching the Greek Orthodox archbishop, Christodoulos, preaching on television
that “all homosexuals are sinners and will definitely end up in Hell,”
imagine the impact that had on me, a gay boy of 17, struggling to come
to terms with my sexuality in a country where gays are constantly humiliated,
albeit mainly verbally, in the media, the tabloids and everyday conversations
one happens to overhear. During the summer, a young gay man committed suicide
in jail after being arrested in a police raid in an Athenian gay bar, giving
thus “proof” to many conservative Greeks of homosexuality’s “ungodly” nature
that “only leads men to destruction.”" - Gay
activists stage public kiss protest in downtown Athens (2003). (Article on Doc Download): One homosexual committed suicide in jail after a police raid on a gay club earlier this year, Mr Yiannelos said. - Gay,
transvestite activists stage public kiss demo in downtown Athens.
Sweden
/ Suède: - La
Suède aux prises avec un grave taux de suicide N/A. - Justin
Lundsten (1997): "I suppose I should devote my first column to myself. So
read my life story, and I hope you enjoy it, that's why it's here... I
have been clear with my sexuality as long as I can remember. I can't say
a date or a year when it "came to me" that I was gay. But it is only in
the last few years that I have realized what it means. I slipped in to
a depression and cried a lot. I didn't meet any new people, or went with
my friends out or to parties. I isolated myself, living of my own egoism.
I even thought of committing suicide! ..." - Le
suicide inquiète en Suède (2003). - Les
communes doivent se mobiliser contre le suicide des jeunes homosexuels:
Plus d'un tiers des jeunes suédoises homosexuelles ou
bisexuelles, de 16 à 24 ans, ont commis une ou plusieurs
tentatives de suicide en 2002. Un quart des garçons du
même âge ont essayé de mettre fin à leur
jour.
- Stockholm
veut aider les jeunes homos, bi et transsexuels (2003). A Webpage on GLB Suicide Issues in Sweden. - Belonging
(2005): Despite this development, gloomy statistics show that the
frequency of suicide is much higher among lgbt youth, who are left to
the mercy of an adult world slow toabsorb rapidly changing perspective shifts.
Norway:
- "The
need for developing strategies for suicide prevention among young lesbian
women and gay men: empirical and theoretical rationales written on the
subject," was presented at the Conference
on the Status of Nordic Health Promotion Research: Progress during the
Decade after the Ottawa Charter. - The
National Plan for Suicide Prevention 1994-1998: Chapter 3: Homosexuality
mentioned without explanations. - A
web page on Norway's GLBT suicide problems. - Friis, Eva: Suicide
and suicide prevention among gays and lesbians (First published in
the Norwegian journal Suicidologi 1998, no. 3.) - Is
there an elevated risk of attempted suicide among homosexual adolescents? - Suicide Attempts among Norwegian Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Youths
(2007): The national non-probability sample included 407 GLB youths
aged between 16 and 25 years of age, among whom 26 per cent of both
genders reported a previous suicide attempt. - Webpage on Norway's GLB Suicide Issues (Alternate Link).
The Netherlands: - Suicidality and Sexual Orientation: Differences Between Men and Women in a General Population-Based Sample From The Netherlands
(2006): Younger homosexuals were not at lower risk for suicidality than
older homosexuals in comparison with their heterosexual counterparts.
Among homosexual men, perceived discrimination was associated with
suicidality. This study suggests that even in a country with a
comparatively tolerant climate regarding homosexuality, homosexual men
were at much higher risk for suicidality than heterosexual men. This
relationship could not only be attributed to their higher psychiatric
morbidity. In women, there was no such clear relationship.
Denmark: Qin P, Agerbo
E, Mortensen PB (2003). Suicide
risk in relation to socioeconomic, demographic,
psychiatric,
and familial factors: a national register-based
study of
all suicides in Denmark, 1981-1997.
American Journal
of Psychiatry, 160(4):765-72. (Abstract) (Full Text) - "...registered
[same-sex] partners included as a separate
category
in the analysis had an odds ratio of 4.31 (95% CI=
2.23–8.36) in the crude analysis and 3.63 (95% CI=1.71– 7.67) in
analyses with adjustment for other factors in the
full model
[for having committed suicide compared to
opposite-sex
married couples]". Note:
This is a First-Time Research Result! See: Frisch M, Bronnum-Hansen H (2009).
Mortality among men and women in same-sex marriage: a national cohort
study of 8333 Danes. American Journal of Public Health, 99(1): 133-7. Abstract. After 1995, higher risk of death in same-sex marriages occur in first 3 year of the marriage. Note:
The paper does not mention the Qin et al (2003) suicide results
(above), and suicide is only mentioned as possibly being implicated in the higher
risk of death for same-sex couples.
Caribbean:
Trinidad: - Homophobia
and gay youth suicide: two interrelated destructive forces in our society.
An open letter to the people of Trinidad and Tobago. -
Jessie:
I had to visit delusive shrinks who got rich off of my misery.
I still have this scar on my wrist, an ugly memento of the power he once
had over my decision to live or die. I may never get to tell him, "Even
after all the blows, ostracism and emotional turmoil, I'm still gay...
- NM:
"I hate the fact that I hurt inwardly and no one can tell. I hate the inalienable
truth that being gay is like living a whole other existence... I
had that happy place in my mind that I would retreat to whenever everything
was bad. However everytime I retreated into it, it grew smaller until there
was nothing left. Now when I really need it there is nothing that I could
go to. I need that place and I have to find it back otherwise I will end
up doing something really drastic. Right now, I need to retreat into that
place otherwise I swear I am going to go mad." - Trinicontact:
"But finally, deciding that telling everybody I was gay would be marginally
more fun than committing suicide... One of the big things I get is that
homosexuality wrong, but because this is a free country I can be gay if
I want. This is an improvement over the kill-the-faggots attitude of #7,
but still not good enough." - Homophobia
and gay youth suicide: two interrelated destructive forces in our society:
"The recent suicide of Surajdeo Lall is a prime example. This young gay
man committed suicide at his work place just after some co-workers outed
and harassed him."
- In Trinidad, Putting Gays and Lesbians Lower Than Adulterers and Rapists (2010).
Jamaica: - Bisexual woman struggles with identity
(2001): "My situation is very common with other gays in this
country," she added. "If only society was just a little kinder, life
would be so much easier for all of us. There are homosexuals who have
committed suicide because they couldn't deal with their sexuality.
There are gays in the church who have to sit in congregation after
congregation and listen to their pastor blasting homosexuals. The
prospects of coming out of the closet are very frightening and which
explains why so many gays are so reluctant to go public. To openly
declare one's sexuality in today's Jamaica could be the difference
between life and death. We have to maintain the faith and keep fighting
though." - Homos at risk
(2001): "Kids can be merciless," explained one principal who requested
not to be identified in the story. "I have had to both suspend and
expel students for brutally beating up on other schoolmates believed to
be homosexuals. Sometimes even the taunting can be vicious. I have
spoken to principals of other schools and they also have similar
experiences with their students."
Puerto Rico: - Suicide, adolescents and Puerto Rico:
Risk factors that correlate highly with the Puerto Rican experience
include homosexuality, due to the hostility that the person may
experience, depression, gender, prevalence of psychiatric disorders,
lack of social integration and social skills, military experience,
cultural and religious factors, alcoholism, substance abuse and
unemployment/poverty. The literature reviewed indicates that the Puerto
Rican adolescent male is in a high risk group for suicide and that the
risk increases with age, sexual preference, dysfunction in the family
and substance abuse. - Strengths and Vulnerabilities of a Sample of Gay
and Bisexual Male Adolescents in Puerto Rico (PDF Download):
Participants were 61 highly educated GB youths living in Puerto Rico.
Levels of depression, perceived social support, alcohol and drug use,
and sexual behavior were assessed. Results show that 45% of
participants reported high levels of depression. However participants
reported low levels of alcohol and drug consumption, no unprotected
sexual behavior, and high satisfaction with social support...
Asia:
China:
- Official gay bar to open in China's Dali
(2009): Zhang Beichuan, a professor at the Qingdao University
specializing in sexual health, said among Chinese homosexuals, 60
percent feel extremely distressed, between 30 and 40 percent show
strong inclination to committing suicide, and between 3 and 13 percent
have attempted suicide. - China: The death of a lesbian
(2007): Li yinhe blogs about the death of Juan Zi, a lesbian who
committed suicide because her mother locked her up for six months upon
finding out her sexual orientation. - Coming out in China (2002): Zhang
recalls his search for sexual identity nine years ago --- when he was
19. "I found a thick medical book and read this little section, which
said homosexuality is abnormal and perverse and gays get AIDS. I got
very scared," says Zhang. So scared that he tried to commit suicide.
Later, he met other gays in Beijing. "That made me feel that
homosexuality is something perfectly normal . . . There was nothing
wrong with me," Zhang said.
- Chinese
lesbians commit suicide (N/A, 1994). (Must scroll to locate information.).
China's opening up : nationalist and globalist conceptions of same-sex identity (2007, PDF):
My marriage was a failure it was largely to please my parents. Prior to
my marriage, I was in love with a woman for more than ten years.
However, this woman had to leave China for Singapore. as she was
involved with Falungong [a religious group which is still considered to
be subversive by Chinese government authorities]. I miss her immensely.
I feel insanely lonely from time to time. On a few occasions. I
seriously wanted to commit suicide. My parents do not know that I am a
lesbian. My brother and sister know something about it. But my family
members do not want to talk about it. They are not open enough (Jie Fan
2004, pers. comm., 27 April)... According to Zhang Yun [himself], he
openly proclaimed his gayness at the first HIV/AIDS Conference which
was held in Beijing in 2001. He has been pursued by the local and
foreign press since this proclamation. Long before this proclamation at
the age of nineteen, he attempted to commit suicide. He used to think
that lie was perverse as lie was attracted to men.
South Korea:
Life
and Death in Queer Korea: "I consider myself lucky, though. Between
1997 and 1999, three of my gay friends in South Korea committed suicide.
In May 1998, Oh disclosed his homosexuality to his family. They immediately
rejected him and expelled him from their home. After living and suffering
on the streets for months, and at one point sleeping in an office, Oh killed
himself. The other two went to Seoul National University, which is South
Korea's Harvard or Yale. One was in Law School; the other was a graduate
student in biology. Their success in society was "guaranteed." However,
when they came to the age of marriage, they both faced a brutal dilemma.
Neither wanted to marry. But they also didn't want to disown their families
and disappoint their parents.